Views from the Marketplace are paid for by advertisers and select partners of MIT Technology Review.
Managing Risk in a High-Flying Industry: A Look at Aviation
Competition may be intense and margins tight but aviation insurance coverage remains a buyer’s market.
In terms of negative, high-profile events, 2014 has been a challenging year for the airline industry, primarily because of two incidents. In early March, Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 mysteriously disappeared, with 239 passengers and crew on board, while en route from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing. And in July, the same airline’s Flight 17 was shot down over war-torn Ukraine, shortly after departing Amsterdam en route to Kuala Lumpur. All 298 passengers and crew members were killed. These were obviously terrible human tragedies. But they were also highly unusual events, with at least one (the crash in Ukraine) not a “typical” airline accident at all.
Because they were so unusual, and because they were the first major commercial airline disasters in the five years since 2009, they serve as a reminder of the resiliency of the airline industry and its long-term gains in safety. So safe, in fact, that last year, The New York Times was prompted to publish an article entitled “Airline Industry at Its Safest Since the Dawn of the Jet Age.”1 The authors note that, on average, a passenger could fly every day for 123,000 years before encountering a fatal flight.
This kind of record has been a boon to the airline industry, and to travelers, with more and more passengers flying every year; almost 3 billion globally in 2012, according to the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO).2 That number marked a 5% increase over 2011, and the ICAO projects the number of annual passengers to reach 6 billion by 2030.3 Competition for passengers is fierce, and airline margins, even in good years, remain tight, at around 2% to 3%. But despite this year’s two major tragedies, the industry’s singularly impressive safety record over the years has helped keep premiums at attractive levels. In fact, even though rates have climbed from where they were in 2013, they are less today than they were 10 or even 15 years ago.
Given the industry’s tight margins, pricing for aviation insurance will always be an important consideration for industry buyers. But it is not the only factor in purchasing decisions. Risk management among airline companies is highly sophisticated, and this sophistication is reflected in their demands for coverage. As Rob Sage, AIG’s U.K. Head of Underwriting Aerospace, points out, “In addition to price, buyers were until recently also looking to broaden their coverage.However, after the spate of recent losses, price has once again become key with some buyers, even though rates are significantly lower than they were pre-9/11. The more sophisticated buyers will always be looking for the broadest cover available even if there is a cost for that.”
Coverage for Cyber threats
One area of interest for many industry buyers has been protection against cyber-attacks. Cyber threats have become ubiquitous across most, if not all, industry verticals, and aviation is no exception. It is not difficult to imagine the kinds of damage, and not just financial, that could be caused by a major security breach at an airline or airport. As the rate and sophistication of cybercrimes and the threat of cyberterrorism grow, the risk profiles of airlines and airports are changing, and industry buyers are adjusting their risk management strategies to accommodate those changes. A number of companies in the insurance industry, including AIG, have responded by providing a number of offerings to help meet these evolving needs.4
In addition to cyber threats, risk managers in the aviation industry are seeking to broaden their coverage in other areas as well. These range from potential liabilities relating to pollution from de-icing and fuel storage to situations involving, for example, the loss of GPS satellite communications data, which airlines rely on for navigation and terrain mapping.
This article has been updated from its original version. To read the original article in its entirety, please download the PDF here:
Importance of Claims Handling in Aviation
As the aviation industry grows in both size and complexity, the importance of claims handling has been magnified. As the two horrific incidents discussed earlier illustrate, when things go wrong in the industry, they can go very wrong – along multiple dimensions. Risk managers in the industry absolutely rely on insurance partners that can help them navigate the sometimes labyrinth-like claims process quickly and as painlessly as possible, so that necessary liquidity is available when and where it’s needed. Some providers outsource the claims handling function, while others, such as AIG, handle it with experienced internal claims teams. Buyers should lean toward whichever provider they believe will partner with them best in a crisis.
The aviation industry will continue to evolve in order to meet the ever-increasing demands of the flying public. In the process, industry risk managers will need to continue to regularly assess their organizations’ risk profiles to ensure they have the breadth of coverage they need.
1 Jad Mouawad and Christopher Drew, “Airline Industry at Its Safest Since the Dawn of the Jet Age.” The New York Times, Feb. 11, 2013.
2 “Annual Passenger Total Approaches 3 Billion According to ICAO 2012 Air Transport Results.” ICAO press release, Dec 18, 2012. Accessed online on Sept 15, 2014 at http://www.icao.int/Newsroom/Pages/annual-passenger-total-approaches-3-billion-according-to-ICAO-2012-air-transport-results.aspx
4 AIG’s principal cyberrisk solution is CyberEdge PCSM. For more information, go to http://www.aig.com/cyberedge-pc_1247_593419.html
Become an MIT Technology Review Insider for in-depth analysis and unparalleled perspective.Subscribe today