Skip to Content
Tech policy

Google contract workers voted to unionize. The law isn’t on their side.

Theoretically, Google could fire the Pittsburgh tech contractors who just voted to unionize.
September 25, 2019
Illustration of Google logo with letter L as a raised arm/fist in the air
Illustration of Google logo with letter L as a raised arm/fist in the air
Illustration of Google logo with letter L as a raised arm/fist in the airGoogle(logo); Deivid Sáenz | Noun Project (fist)

Do Google contractors work for Google? 

The question may sound silly. It may also determine the fate of the Google contract workers in Pittsburgh who voted to unionize with the United Steelworkers yesterday. These tech contractors say that they receive fewer benefits than full Google employees despite working alongside them, and want fairer treatment. The decision to unionize is being described as a game changer for the entire tech industry, which relies on a “shadow force” of temporary employees that do similar jobs as (and can even outnumber) full employees. But the momentum could face serious challenges because of an ongoing debate over who works for who. 

Here’s why. Companies are not allowed to fire employees for unionizing. That violates the National Labor Relations Act. “But if a company fires its contractor because the contractor’s workers have unionized, it is off scot-free,” says Brishen Rogers, a professor of labor law at Temple University. The Pittsburgh workers are contractors who work for HCL Technologies, so theoretically, Google could fire all of them because they voted to unionize—which would obviously be a huge blow. Google doesn’t need to bargain with the workers at all, Rogers adds. In fact, it’s possible that the United Steelworkers could be punished  by a federal court if the HCL workers picketed and had signs that said “On strike against Google” or influenced full-time Google employees to stop work and strike. 

But—and this is crucial—companies are not allowed to fire workers for unionizing if they're "jointly employed" by the contractor (in this case, HCL) and the corporation (Google)

What does “jointly employed” mean?  It’s not a settled question. In 2015, the National Labor Relations Board—inspired by McDonald’s workers who insisted they were jointly employed by the franchise and corporation—declared that a company didn’t have to directly control the worker every day to be an employer. 

But in recent years, the Trump administration has essentially tried to reverse that. It is proposing a new rule that would make proving joint employer status much harder—and Google and Microsoft support the rule. It hasn’t passed yet, but could by the time Google and the union finish litigation, if they end up going to court over this definition. “The issue has been going on for so long in part because there’s a lot of legal nuance, but also because there are literally tens of billions of dollars at stake all across the economy,” says Rogers. In the Pittsburgh case, lawyers would likely look at how much Google assigns, manages, and pays the workers, or whether HCL does most of the supervision on a daily basis. The future of efforts to organize tech contractors will depend on who is considered the boss.

The law may not be friendly, but this doesn't mean the union effort is futile or doomed to fail. Reuel Schiller, an employment expert at UC Hastings in San Francisco, points out that public relations could ultimately be more important. “The thing that makes it particularly interesting is the public face of Google, where they want to keep costs down but don’t want to appear to be union-busting,” he says.

Margaret O’Mara, a historian at the University of Washington, adds that yesterday's vote is far from the first time people in the tech industry have tried to unionize. There have been repeated efforts, starting from blue-collar unionization of fabrication plants, she says. A few years ago, Microsoft contractors unionized, but then their jobs were eliminated. But it may be different this time, O’Mara says. New activism in tech, like the protests of Uber and Lyft drivers and walkouts by full-time Google employees, may pressure companies into action.

But public attention is a volatile resource, and  a change to labor law would have a much bigger effect, especially if the attention goes away. “It should be much easier for workers to unionize,” says Rogers. “And after they do, they should be able to bargain with companies that hold power over their working conditions."

Deep Dive

Tech policy

wet market selling fish
wet market selling fish

This scientist now believes covid started in Wuhan’s wet market. Here’s why.

How a veteran virologist found fresh evidence to back up the theory that covid jumped from animals to humans in a notorious Chinese market—rather than emerged from a lab leak.

thermal image of young woman wearing mask
thermal image of young woman wearing mask

The covid tech that is intimately tied to China’s surveillance state

Heat-sensing cameras and face recognition systems may help fight covid-19—but they also make us complicit in the high-tech oppression of Uyghurs.

German woman stands in queue for vaccination
German woman stands in queue for vaccination

What Europe’s new covid surge means—and what it doesn’t

New restrictions are coming into place across Europe as covid cases rise again. But there are several reasons why a new wave is happening.

surveillance drone in Afghanistan
surveillance drone in Afghanistan

After 20 years of drone strikes, it’s time to admit they’ve failed

The very first drone attack missed its target, and two decades on civilians are still being killed. Why can't we accept that the technology doesn't work?

Stay connected

Illustration by Rose WongIllustration by Rose Wong

Get the latest updates from
MIT Technology Review

Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more.

Thank you for submitting your email!

Explore more newsletters

It looks like something went wrong.

We’re having trouble saving your preferences. Try refreshing this page and updating them one more time. If you continue to get this message, reach out to us at with a list of newsletters you’d like to receive.