Is the Chatbot Trend One Big Misunderstanding?
Picture a nightmarish future in which half-witted “conversational user interfaces” drive us insane with mindless conversation and misunderstandings. As U.S. tech companies rush to emulate the success of China’s messaging platforms, this could be where we’re headed.
Dan Grover, a product manager for China’s wildly successful WeChat messaging service, argues that the chatbots and chatbot tools being developed by U.S. companies, such as Microsoft and Facebook, are inspired, in large part, by the many chat-based services now available in China. These chat services can be used for all sorts of tasks, including transferring money, paying restaurant bills, and looking up flight information.
The chatbots being developed in the U.S. are designed to perform tasks, such as searching for a flight or ordering a pizza, via a friendly back and forth with users. But, as Grover notes, China’s most successful chat interfaces forgo natural language in favor of more conventional input mechanisms such as multiple choice answers or buttons that appear in chat bubbles.
That might seem backward, but it’s actually a more efficient way to order a pizza through a messaging platform than using a chatbot. Grover points out that conversational user interfaces require far more actions from a user than a simple messaging interface (73 taps compared to 16 when ordering a pizza, for example).
To some extent, I fear, he is right that chatbots may be incredibly annoying. And things may be even more annoying if app designers fail to appreciate the significant challenges that remain with using computers to parse and respond to natural language.
But it would also be a mistake to give up on conversational interfaces altogether. For more open-ended tasks, some sort of dialogue may well be more desirable. And as devices like Amazon’s voice-controlled Echo device show, when speaking to a device you really need something that can converse, even if only on a very basic level.
(Read more: Dan Grover, "How to Prevent a Plague of Dumb Chatbots")
Keep Reading
Most Popular
How to opt out of Meta’s AI training
Your posts are a gold mine, especially as companies start to run out of AI training data.
How a simple circuit could offer an alternative to energy-intensive GPUs
The creative new approach could lead to more energy-efficient machine-learning hardware.
How gamification took over the world
Gamification was always just behaviorism dressed up in pixels and point systems. Why did we fall for it?
Apple is promising personalized AI in a private cloud. Here’s how that will work.
Apple’s first big salvo in the AI wars makes a bet that people will care about data privacy when automating tasks.
Stay connected
Get the latest updates from
MIT Technology Review
Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more.