Bringing Cell-Phone Location-Sensing Indoors
App pinpoints people inside shops without requiring them to “check in.”
Walk into the Best Buy on San Francisco’s Harrison Street, and the consumer electronics giant knows a potential customer has arrived: at least if you’re using the ShopKick iPhone app that launched earlier this month.
The startup, based in Palo Alto, CA, takes advantage of your smart phone’s keen hearing to bring location-sensing indoors, where GPS won’t work. Beacons smaller than a person’s hand fixed to a store’s ceiling beam out an ultrasound signal at a frequency that can be picked up by a cell phone’s microphone but not by human ears.
The app decodes the signal and contacts ShopKick’s database to work out where the user is, and to retrieve some sort of reward. The reward might be a credit of 50 “Kickbucks” (which can be traded for gift cards) for visiting the store, or a discount code for a particular product. The data profile that a user builds up with the app could also be used to target more relevant offers. For privacy reasons, this tracking information isn’t tied to a user’s real identity; instead, it’s aggregated anonymously.
“This offers the consumer a new kind of interactivity,” says ShopKick CTO and cofounder Aaron Emigh, “and speaks to retailers about their most important measure of performance: foot traffic.”
Apps like Foursquare, Gowalla, and the newly launched Facebook Places have shown that some cell-phone users have an appetite for sharing their location. But the limited accuracy of these services–and the fact that they do not work well indoors–makes the data they produce less valuable to operators of bricks-and-mortar businesses. “These apps are really about vicinity, not location. We can’t really know if you’re there or driving down the street a block away,” says Emigh, “ShopKick can truly detect if someone is present at a location.”
The app is currently available only for the iPhone, but an Android version will appear “soon,” he says. He adds that tests on every common smart phone revealed “literally only a couple” that can’t detect the ShopKick beacon. This ultrasound beacon emits a signal that phones can identify from up to 150 feet away, says Emigh, and the nature of buildings neatly confines the signal to inside a store. “You can really tell which side of a door someone is on.”
For now, ShopKick is rolling out beacons simply to tell if an app user is inside a store or not. But they have also demonstrated how the approach could verify a person’s precise location–for example, a particular aisle–enabling the app to tell a person to visit a specific section of the store where they will receive a particular coupon or an extra slew of points.
Triangulation (comparing several signals to pinpoint a device’s location) is also possible with acoustic signals, says Emigh, and it is possible for a phone to detect the signal even from inside a pocket. “Because we want to be careful about privacy, for now we’re not monitoring for the ShopKick signal except when you’ve opened up the app,” he says.
Josh Marti of Point Inside, a Bellevue, WA, startup that offers indoor mapping in spaces like airports and shopping malls, agrees that pinpointing users more accurately, especially inside buildings, will be important. “The market is heading away from ambiguous ‘check-ins’ [using a location-based app to say you’re in a particular place] toward feet across the threshold.”
ShopKick’s app offers a good demonstration of what greater indoor location accuracy can offer shoppers and stores, Marti says. He acknowledges that it does require some effort from the retailer. “Using an acoustic signal makes perfect sense,” he says, “but anecdotally our big-box customers are not interested in putting extra stuff in their stores. Our belief is that existing infrastructure is a better route.”
Point Inside provides a mobile mapping experience like that of Google Maps, but its maps are indoors and are created with wireless access points to get a location fix. Companies like Skyhook Wireless, Google, and Apple operate databases of wireless access points detectable from the street to help refine location estimates of applications like Google Maps for Mobile. Point Inside works with retailers and mall operators to gather accurate measurements of Wi-Fi signals from transmitters already in stores and their locations indoors and submits the data to Skyhook and others for inclusion in their databases.
Point Inside can then create maps for those places and apps that allow people to locate themselves inside a building. The density of wireless points inside a retail store–a typical Walmart will have 24 spread across its floor–enough to pinpoint a phone to within five meters in some situations, says Marti. Last week, Point Inside released an app that makes it possible to locate a particular product inside department stores operated by Meijer.
Store owners are becoming more aware of the possibilities of encouraging people to share where they are inside their businesses, says Marti–and future cell phones will make indoor location easier. In particular, he thinks a technique called “dead reckoning” will become more common. This technique, recently demonstrated by Microsoft, involves using location and orientation sensors to keep track of how far a phone has moved since its last location fix.
Marti also expects more sensitive radios to become a typical feature as cell-phone designers look to help users to locate themselves indoors and out. Such radios will improve triangulation from cell towers, Wi-Fi, and other sources.
“Our opportunity is really all those gray spaces you see on Google Maps,” says Marti, referring to the areas on online maps between streets that contain buildings–and businesses that are keen to know more about the whereabouts of their customers.
Become an MIT Technology Review Insider for in-depth analysis and unparalleled perspective.Subscribe today