Skip to Content

Why the SEC thinks Bitcoin still isn’t ready for the big time

July 27, 2018

The US Securities and Exchange Commission has rejected a proposal from the Winklevoss twins to establish a Bitcoin-based exchange traded fund, and it was clear in its reasoning: the agency can’t be sure that Bitcoin’s price isn’t being manipulated.

Winkle-who wants to create a what? Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss first made a splash in the technology world during the early days of Facebook, as depicted in the 2011 movie The Social Network. They have since become two of the most prominent Bitcoin entrepreneurs. An exchange traded fund, or ETF, is a fund that owns a basket of underlying assets, which could be stocks, bonds, commodities, or other types, and offers tradeable shares to investors. The Winklevoss twins want to create an ETF whose underlying assets are bitcoins.

Strike two: The 3-1 vote to block the proposal is the second time the SEC has rejected an ETF proposed by the Winklevoss twins. The last rejection came in March of 2017. The decision is a setback for Bitcoin enthusiasts, since many observers expect that a regulated Bitcoin ETF would lead to an influx of institutional investors and, in turn, further legitimize the market.

The risk of fraud: In a lengthy analysis (PDF), the SEC laments the lack of data available to study today’s Bitcoin market, where much of the trading goes on in unregulated exchanges in other countries. It cites recent academic research suggesting that certain of those exchanges may be manipulating Bitcoin’s price. And it says that overall it cannot conclude that the Winklevoss’s fund would be sufficiently resistant to fraud.

The beat goes on: The SEC was also clear in its analysis that it has not shut the door on Bitcoin ETFs, and Reuters reports that there are at least five additional ETF proposals still pending. Don’t be surprised if the Winklevoss twins eventually head back to the plate as well.

Keep Reading

Most Popular

Here’s how a Twitter engineer says it will break in the coming weeks

One insider says the company’s current staffing isn’t able to sustain the platform.

Technology that lets us “speak” to our dead relatives has arrived. Are we ready?

Digital clones of the people we love could forever change how we grieve.

How to befriend a crow

I watched a bunch of crows on TikTok and now I'm trying to connect with some local birds.

Starlink signals can be reverse-engineered to work like GPS—whether SpaceX likes it or not

Elon said no thanks to using his mega-constellation for navigation. Researchers went ahead anyway.

Stay connected

Illustration by Rose Wong

Get the latest updates from
MIT Technology Review

Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more.

Thank you for submitting your email!

Explore more newsletters

It looks like something went wrong.

We’re having trouble saving your preferences. Try refreshing this page and updating them one more time. If you continue to get this message, reach out to us at with a list of newsletters you’d like to receive.