It’s being billed as a triumph for solar power, but the Solar Impulse solar-powered airplane could also be seen as an illustration of just how amazing liquid fuels like jet fuel are, and how far solar power and battery technology would need to go to challenge them. A far better idea than solar-powered flight is nuclear-powered flight, although I don’t mean putting nuclear reactors on airplanes as the U.S. government once proposed (see these two pdfs). Let’s use fission to make low-carbon fuel.
The Solar Impulse plane, powered by a combination of crystalline silicon solar panels and lithium ion batteries, made news last year when it made the world’s first solar-powered intercontinental flight. And it’s scheduled to fly across the United States this summer. But the continents it travelled between—the plane flew from Spain to Morocco–nearly touch. And the plane will make the trip across the U.S. in five legs. The plane carries only one person, yet its wingspan is equal to that of a jumbo jet, which provides the needed lift and the area for the solar panels.
There are some things solar panels are good for, but they’re not good for passenger aircraft. The energy in sunlight is too diffuse. A square-meter solar panel generates less than 200 watts in full sunshine. In comparison, a small, half-meter-wide, gasoline-powered generator can generate 3,500 watts. It can run for 24 hours–at half power–on less than 12 gallons of fuel. The solar panel, of course, stops working at night. If it can generate some extra power during the day, that could be stored in batteries. But batteries store only about 1/100th as much energy as gasoline. (Incidentally, one of the attractions of nuclear power is that you can get about a million times more energy out of uranium in a power plant than you can get out of diesel in an engine.)
Don’t settle for half the story.
Get paywall-free access to technology news for the here and now.