Life Could Have Evolved in Armoured Clay Bubbles
The discovery that natural clay forms a protective shell around tiny air bubbles has profound implications for our theories about the origin of life on Earth.
One of the great mysteries in biology is the origin of cell membranes, the protective layers that completely surround the complex chemical soup in which many of life’s most delicate processes take place.
DNA and its attendant biochemical machinery can only operate in the carefully controlled environment that the cell membrane creates. But curiously, one of the important jobs that this machinery does is to create the chemical building blocks that then self-assemble into the membrane itself. So that creates a paradox: the membrane cannot form without the biochemical machinery but this will not work without the protection of the cell membrane.
The puzzle is which came first. How could cell membranes have evolved without biochemical machines to manufacture the building blocks? And alternatively, how could the biochemical machines have evolved without the crucial protection that cell membranes provide? It’s a chicken and egg problem.
This story is only available to subscribers.
Don’t settle for half the story.
Get paywall-free access to technology news for the here and now.
Subscribe now
Already a subscriber?
Sign in
You’ve read all your free stories.
MIT Technology Review provides an
intelligent and independent filter for the
flood of information about technology.
Subscribe now
Already a subscriber?
Sign in
In recent years, an answer has emerged. It very much looks as if the cell membranes came first and the evidence comes from numerous studies that show how simple organic molecules can self-assemble into bubble-like structures called vesicles.
Various groups have shown how these vesicles can form not only in the prebiotic soup that probably existed early in Earth’s history but also on the surface of ultracold crystals that we know to exist in interstellar space.
By this way of thinking, the vesicles provided a protective environment in which the molecules of life slowly evolved.
Today, we get another option. Anand Bala Subramaniam at Harvard University and a few pals have discovered that this process of vesicle formation also happens in a naturally occurring clay called montmorillonite. That’s the kind of stuff that might clogg your boots after a hike.
They say bubbles easily form in a mixture of water and clay mix. When that happens, the clay forms a surface around the bubble which traps the contents inside. Then, any contact with chemicals called surfactants, stabilises shell. Subramaniam and co call the result a “clay armoured bubble”. “These vesicles of clay are mechanically robust and are stable in water and other liquids,” they say.
Clay armoured bubbles have several interesting features. First, they can easily form in the gaps between sliding rocks or between pebbles tossed back and forth by waves and tides. And the surfactants that stabilise their structure are known to have existed throughout Earth’s history.
Most interesting of all, the armoured bubbles are covered in pores that allow molecules of a certain size to pass in and out of the structure. That makes it all the more likely that these structures “may have served as simple primitive inorganic precursors to organic proto-cells,” as Subramaniam and co put it.
Of course, there is no proof that life on Earth evolved in armoured bubbles but it is yet another indicator that the conditions in which life can flourish are more common and more likely to form than anyone could have imagine just a few years ago.
Ref: arxiv.org/abs/1011.4711: Semi-Permeable Vesicles Composed Of Natural Clay
