Sapphire Screens Would Test Apple’s Manufacturing and Design Skills
To make sapphire screens, Apple would need to source high-quality raw material and be clever about incorporating it into devices.
According to one estimate, 11 percent of all iPhones have cracked screens.
Today Apple senior vice president for design, Jony Ive, called out the remarkable properties of sapphire, a material that’s so hard you’d basically need a diamond to cut it. It protects the back and front of Apple’s new watch.
Cracked screens are a common problem for smartphone users, so virtually unscratchable, unbreakable screens could make for a compelling marketing campaign. But just how durable sapphire will be is debatable. Much will depend on how well Apple can manufacture it in large quantities, and how it incorporates the material into its devices.
Rumors have been circulating for months that Apple plans to use sapphire, a substance that is significantly harder than glass, in its latest iPhones, and perhaps its first iWatch. The company’s decision to invest about $700 million in an industrial sapphire plant in Arizona starting last year added considerable weight to the theory.
Sapphire is already used in small amounts to make scratch-resistant screens for luxury watches, and Apple uses small pieces of sapphire to protect the camera and the home button on the iPhone 5S. But sapphire’s high cost has limited its applications; although new ways of growing sapphire crystals have made it cheaper to produce in recent years, it’s still roughly five times more expensive than toughened glass.
While sapphire can be much stronger than the toughened glass now used for most smartphone screens (it is second only to diamond on a standard scale of hardness), if it isn’t processed correctly, it can actually be more prone to breaking.
Indeed, one test a sapphire display removed from a Kyocera Brigadier shows it cracking after a drop of just three feet (the sapphire didn’t crack when it was still incorporated into the device). And Corning, the company that makes the Gorilla Glass, which is widely used in smartphones, has produced a video of sapphire cracking after being scuffed up by a few everyday objects.
But Corning is hardly an unbiased observer, and these tests say little about how Apple’s devices will perform, because the properties of sapphire depend so heavily on how it is processed and incorporated into devices.
Some types of cutting and polishing can introduce defects into the material that make it easier to break than glass. “Any flaws or scratches dramatically reduce the strength,” says Neil Alford, a material engineering professor at Imperial College of London. The material’s properties also depend on the orientation of the crystal—certain cuts of sapphire are stronger than others.
To prevent a gadget’s screen from cracking, you need to do two things, according to Robert Ritchie, a professor at the University of California, Berkeley, who studies the failure mechanisms of materials. First, you need be careful to avoid defects that might allow scratches, because these can lead to more serious cracks. Second, the overall design needs to absorb the energy of an impact–something the Kyocera phone does. Sapphire itself isn’t great at this—it’s a brittle material, though slightly more fracture-resistant than glass, Ritchie says. So you need to be clever about how you package it in a phone or a watch, so that the other materials in the device can absorb the energy of an impact.
This story was updated at 4:30 p.m. EST on September 9 with details of Apple’s announcement.
Keep up with the latest in Apple at EmTech Digital.
The Countdown has begun.
March 25-26, 2019
San Francisco, CA