A Collection of Articles
Edit

Computing

Toyota Applies the Brakes

The company hopes a “smart pedal” will help defuse criticism.

In the wake of a massive public-relations nightmare involving brake problems in its cars, Toyota is investigating two more reports this week of unintended acceleration in its vehicles. Both cases involved Priuses: one in Harrison, NY, that resulted in a crash, and the other on an interstate east of San Diego.

Electronic testing: Matthew Schwall, an engineer with the consulting firm Exponent, demonstrated an experiment designed to test claims of a fundamental flaw with Toyota’s electronics throttle systems.

The troubled carmaker has already recalled 5.4 million cars. It has replaced floor mats that it said snagged acceleration pedals, and it has modified certain pedals that the company said could be prone to sticking. Toyota also recently announced that it would retrofit some models with a brake-override system, also known as a “smart pedal.”

It rejects claims that the car’s electronic throttle system could be responsible for unwanted acceleration.

On February 23, David Gilbert, a professor of automotive technology at Southern Illinois University Carbondale, told a congressional hearing that he was able to short-circuit the electronics behind the gas pedal in a Toyota Tundra, causing it to accelerate automatically without triggering a fail-safe system. Gilbert’s review was commissioned by Safety Research & Strategies, a company hired by lawyers representing people who allege that unintended acceleration in Toyota cars has caused accidents.

Toyota hired the consulting firm Exponent to test Gilbert’s claims. On Tuesday, the company presented the results of its own experiments, which it says show that the electronic system in question needs to be modified significantly to malfunction in the way described. Christian Gerdes, a professor of mechanical engineering at Stanford University’s Center for Automotive Research who took part in the experiments, says that Gilbert “created a different pedal circuit than the one Toyota engineered,” and that it doesn’t accurately reflect a real-world situation. (Stanford’s Center for Automotive Research is affiliated with Toyota.)

“We haven’t found any problems with the electronic throttle control system, and we have thoroughly and rigorously tested it many times on vehicles that have had complaints,” adds Brian Lyons, a safety manager at Toyota. Nonetheless, Lyons says, a brake-override system will be installed on every Toyota in North America by the end of the year and globally by the end of 2011.

The brake-override feature, already found in many cars, is a software program that monitors sensors in a vehicle’s gas and brake pedals. If both pedals are pressed while the car is moving at a certain speed, the program gives precedence to the brake by cutting off the engine. Lyons says that Toyota has been developing a smart pedal for some time. “It was designed to be a feature that would be included in vehicles in the future,” he says.

Last week, at a Senate hearing concerning the Toyota recalls, transportation secretary Ray LaHood said the government may recommend that all cars have smart pedals in the future.

“The smart brake pedal removes the power from the engine so you can slow the car down more quickly,” says Thomas Plucinsky, a product manager at BMW of North America. BMW’s cars have included a brake-override system since 1988. The system uses two solid-state position sensors in the brake pedal and one in the accelerator. Chrysler also has smart pedals in about 97 percent of its cars. Its system causes a car to go into a reduced-power mode after about two to four seconds when both pedals are pressed. Other car companies, including Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen, and Nissan, have had brake overrides in their cars for years.

Toyota’s brake-override system uses the accelerator pedal position sensor, the vehicle speed sensor, and the brake light circuitry. When the system senses that both the brake and gas pedal are activated–as might happen when a floor mat edge holds the accelerator in place and the driver is trying to brake–it reduces the engine to idle speed. The smart pedal activates when the accelerator pedal is depressed at least 25 percent and the car is moving more than five miles an hour, says Lyons. This way it knows not to activate when a driver is doing a hill start (easing off the brake as the accelerator is slowly pressed) or if a driver momentarily taps the brake pedal while accelerating. “It’s a very smart system and completely unobtrusive,” says Lyons.

Not everybody’s convinced. Sean Kane, founder of Safety Research & Strategies, is skeptical that Toyota’s smart pedal solution really addresses the problem. “It doesn’t seem to me that this application will accomplish what it needs to,” he says.

If a driver whose car has a smart pedal is in a situation when the system need to be activated, Plucinsky’s advice is: “Apply the brake quickly. Press as hard as you can to stop quickly and switch into neutral.”

Uh oh–you've read all five of your free articles for this month.

Insider basic

$29.95/yr US PRICE

Subscribe
What's Included
  • 1 year (6 issues) of MIT Technology Review magazine in print OR digital format
  • Access to the entire online story archive: 1997-present
  • Special discounts to select partners
  • Discounts to our events

You've read of free articles this month.