SINGAPORE (AP) – Mobile phones are a potential gold mine for advertisers, the most personal and intimate way to communicate and engage with subscribers – more than 2 billion of them and counting worldwide.
Yet the advertisers’ two-liner text pitches have largely fueled a growing hate club, with recipients quickly equating the messages with spam they abhor on desktops.
Now, thanks to improved technologies, advertisers believe they have struck upon the formula for getting their messages across without irking consumers. The development is important given the mobile handset’s promise to be a ”third screen” – after the television and the desktop computer.
Several blue-chip brands like Nokia Corp. and McDonald’s Corp. have been experimenting with interactive ads on cell phones, taking advantage of the device’s ability to know where you are. Customers have the option of finding the nearest retail or restaurant outlet with the press of a key.
Others partner with search engines and e-mail services to slip in an ad or two, similar to how Google has mastered the use of e-mail and search keywords on the desktop to help determine which topics users find interesting and, in turn, what ads appear.
Better handsets and faster networks mean ”more brands utilizing mobile devices for more advanced marketing and advertising initiatives,” said Laura Marriott, executive director of the Denver-based industry trade group Mobile Marketing Association.
The search-based advertising model seems to be working in Japan – a mature mobile phone market where the bulk of the 98 million mobile phone users have phones with Internet capabilities.
Japan’s mobile advertising expenditures are expected to reach $1 billion (euro740 million) by 2011 – more than three times the $328 million (euro244 million) last year, according to an April report from media and communication think tank Dentsu Communication Institute Inc.
Although subscribers had felt they were wasting their time and money going through ads while conducting searches on their phones, those concerns have diminished with faster speeds and flat-rate pricing for Web access, said Akira Miwa, the report’s author.
Yahoo Inc. took the plunge in June with a mapping service that combines search and location-based mobile technology. All one has to do is to enter a keyword to search, and advertisers registered on Yahoo’s database pop up on a digital map.
The advertising industry is mindful of earlier mistakes, including inundating consumers with pop-up ads on the desktop and text messages on the phone.
Many agree that preserving a good customer experience is critical.
”Push marketing and spam have a very short shelf life,” said Frank Brown, director of the mobile marketing and technology firm Sydus.
People need to feel, Brown said, that they had specifically invited the pitch or are engaging with the brand in a relevant and entertaining way.
Rebecca Ye, a 22-year-old Singaporean, said she wouldn’t mind having ads sent to her phone as long as she had subscribed for them, like ”a notification on upcoming sales.”
”Let’s say you’re on the train and you get a message telling you something’s going on somewhere you can just drop by,” she said. ”So it’s very targeted and purposeful.”
MobileOne, Singapore’s second largest mobile communications provider, promises to cater only to the ”willing customer.”
Subscribers can choose to receive offers, free news headlines and advanced functions with an interactive ad-based text messaging service, but if a customer declines, ”he continues to send and receive (text messages) the way he does today,” Chief Executive Neil Montefiore said. ”It is completely under the control of the customer.”
Wireless carriers, meanwhile, are starting to loosen restrictions on third-party ads, which they had resisted for fear annoyed customers might defect to competitors. Until now, most mobile ads are found on content producers’ own Web sites, which are accessed through a mobile browser rather than through the carrier’s cell phone menu.
Yum Brands Inc.’s Pizza Hut and KFC are among the first to advertise through a free, ad-based e-mail service from Southeast Asia’s largest operator, SingTel.
”Our customers are fully aware that they will be receiving the ads, and from our initial findings, they aren’t disturbed by them at all,” SingTel spokeswoman Tricia Lee said. ”We also found that a relatively large segment of customers are willing to try mobile advertising provided they receive something in return.”
Analysts say slowing revenue growth and saturation in developed markets have forced wireless carriers to reconsider – good news for advertisers that want to target specific groups. After all, the carriers have the key to a treasure cove of customer demographics – where they live, their age and what games they play on their phone.
”Carriers today are now focusing on targeted advertising and personalization capabilities,” said King Yew Foong, research director of Gartner Singapore. ”The crucial point is whether carriers understand their customers well enough to execute this flawlessly. They will have to develop better customer intimacy.”
The risks are high if they don’t do it right.
”Consumer aversion to such advertisements in the past is due to the fact that they were irrelevant to the recipients,” King said.
To mitigate the risks, Korean and Japanese companies that have allowed advertising have also put in place spam filters.
The Mobile Marketing Association has set up guidelines that include letting consumers decline to receive ads and ensuring that information advertisers obtain from customers be kept confidential.
”So because of that, spam will be less of an issue,” MMA’s Marriott said.
Brands themselves are also learning to be more subtle with its mobile campaigns, tapping on to a trend where youths in Asia are increasingly turning to their phones rather than an iPod for on-the-go entertainment.
Bacardi Ltd., the company best known for its top-selling rum, recently extended its yearlong partnership with Sydus to stream music to cell phones through a virtual radio ”brand-channel.” The company hopes to connect with a younger audience that way – without overt advertising.
It may take time, though, for mobile ads to gain better esteem among consumers. Some parts of Asia have yet to embrace the third-generation, or 3G, phones that can carry multimedia ads. Handset technology and network signals differ among mobile carriers and countries, forcing advertisers to cater only to the tech-savvy group.
But it’s only a matter of time before mobile networks improve – and the mobile ads follow. The key is to avoid simply importing techniques from television and the desktop.
”We should all by now (know) that doing boring TV ads aren’t much appreciated,” Craig Davis, worldwide chief creative officer of New York-based advertising agency JWT, said during a recent visit to Singapore. ”Doing annoying things is no way to seduce people that your brand is for them.”
Our best illustrations of 2022
Our artists’ thought-provoking, playful creations bring our stories to life, often saying more with an image than words ever could.
How CRISPR is making farmed animals bigger, stronger, and healthier
These gene-edited fish, pigs, and other animals could soon be on the menu.
The Download: the Saudi sci-fi megacity, and sleeping babies’ brains
10 Breakthrough Technologies 2023
Get the latest updates from
MIT Technology Review
Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more.