Technology Review

Web

Your Groups Tell Hackers Who You Are

A malicious site can find out what social-networking groups you belong to--and then figure out your identity.

  • Friday, July 23, 2010
  • By Robert Lemos

People often get categorized by social group--jock, geek, soccer mom. The same is true for our online identities: If you have an account on Facebook or LinkedIn, you might also belong to several groups on each site.

Now researchers at the Vienna Institute of Technology, Institut Eurecom and UC Santa Barbara have found a way that malicious websites could find out what groups you belong to, and use that information to identify you. Such websites could use the trick for identity theft or to craft personalized scams.

The researchers found that a malicious site could "capture" a person's social networking groups from his browser with a trick known as history stealing. By cross-referencing these groups, they could reveal someone's social-network profile--and therefore their real-life identity--42 percent of the time. This means that an otherwise anonymous Web user could be identified correctly by a malicious site simply because the user visited that site.

"The browser can ask if these guys are a member of the iPhone group or the PC security group or the XYZ group, and by calculating intersections, we can identify them in many cases," says Gilbert Wondracek, a postdoctoral candidate in computer science at the Vienna Institute of Technology, who led the work.

Advertisement

Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn, and others major social networks let anyone see who belongs to certain groups. Other attributes can group people together as well. For example, Facebook not only has groups but also lets users express whether they "like" certain links or content.

Most people join these groups without thinking of how it might affect their privacy, says Elena Zheleva, a PhD candidate at the University of Maryland who has researched privacy issues and social networks. "People don't think about it, but groups are one way that information is transferred about a person," she says.

This would hardly matter if not for a well-known attack that lets a website check whether certain links are in a visitor's browser history. This so-called history stealing involves checking to see if a user has visited a particular link. Using history stealing, an attacker can use a snippet of code on a website to ask a visitor's browser if they have visited certain links. The technique can check thousands of links per second. Wondracek and colleagues used history stealing to find which groups people belonged on the social network Xing by checking to see if their history contained a link to the group's page.

"It's a perfect use of the history hack," says Jeremiah Grossman, chief technology officer for Web security firm WhiteHat Security.

Most social networks provide relatively simple Web links for groups so that users can share them easily, says Wondracek. "Social networks have a hard time defeating this," by making links more obscure, he says, because that would make them harder to share.

Browser makers have started to tackle history stealing by limiting the number of links a site can check every second. However, the attack, "will work, and will continue to work until most of the world upgrades their browsers to the latest version," Grossman says.

Print

Related Articles

The Government Has an Online Identity Plan for You

A draft strategy would help users manage their identities online.

Who Controls Identity on the Web?

Facebook and Mozilla have contrasting visions for the future of your online identity.

Augmented Identity

A new app makes it possible to identify people and learn about them just by pointing your phone.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

Asclaepius

53 Comments

  • 570 Days Ago
  • 07/23/2010

Hackensack Old Jersey

excellent article,
we noticed halfway through our first half  dozen blogs, an element of the MIT card counting poker project, brushing up on it's way to break the bank of Monte Carlo via Las Vegas; looking over our shoulder....
the impression here is that MIT deans, have an implicit trust in the kids present, knowing that the  ability to ace MIT entrance exams  accompanies traits sharp enough to spot real science hounds as opposed to wanna bees or jailhouse rockers.......
common sense reminders such as this article shapes well rounded educated individuals for the crossover into the real world beyond ivy league campus walls

Reply

mattgroom

290 Comments

  • 569 Days Ago
  • 07/24/2010

Identity theft

Identity theft is very common, and from regugitation will say is very difficult to undo

Sometimes it can take many months to a year to undo the identity theft issue. The problem is as you can imagine how do you tell who someone is except for there identity.

If someone has your identity, including bank statements, birth certificate, drivers licence, looks a little like you, can forge your signature, has changed your address perhaps. What can you do.

Hence it can take a long time to return to normal, all the while your bank account is cleaned out and various loans for 10'000's to 100'000's of (insert currency unit)has been racked up in your name.

You get your name back and then you still have loan agencies chasing you down.... and all the while are saying it was your identity used...hence it was you...

All i can say is Identity theft is possibly the worst kind of theft imaginable.

Identity theft existed before computers did....

Reply

theTonster

8 Comments

  • 565 Days Ago
  • 07/28/2010

Social Network hacks

Maybe pensioners who take a bus once a month to their local Bank, and otherwise use the WWW as the Planet Earth Library, ought not fear these attacks overmuch because the Conficker users are after money. Some protection is assured by keeping one’s Security software as current as possible.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

A Social-Media Decoder

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Twitter

BrightSource Energy

Silver Spring Networks

Novartis

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement