Challenging China: Speaking at the Newseum in Washington, D.C., U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton said no company should tolerate government intrusion into internet freedom.
Getty Images

Web

Clinton Pressures China over Google Attack

Security researchers are also working to unravel the nature of the espionage.

  • Friday, January 22, 2010
  • By Erica Naone

In a speech given yesterday at the Newseum in Washington, D.C., U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton put pressure on the Chinese government to address the cyber attacks revealed recently by Google. For much of the speech, which focused largely on promoting Internet freedom, Clinton avoided mentioning China specifically. But her comments condemned Internet censorship and cyber attacks in no uncertain terms.

Clinton's remarks paint the U.S. vision of the Internet in stark contrast to China's. In her talk, Clinton stressed the benefits of enforcing the principles of freedom of expression, assembly, and universal access online. In contrast, China has a reputation for routinely blocking access to politically sensitive content and gathers information on dissidents via their Internet communications.

Clinton also addressed Google's disclosure directly. "We look to the Chinese authorities to conduct a thorough review of the intrusions that led Google to make its announcement," Clinton said.

Clinton sharply criticized Internet censorship and companies that cooperate with it. "Censorship should not be in any way accepted by any company from anywhere," she said, warning that efforts to limit information flow create a less useful, fragmented Internet. In particular, she said that "unfettered access to search engine technology is so important in individual lives."

Advertisement

She also called for more cooperation across jurisdictions when fighting Internet crime. "Countries or individuals that engage in cyber attacks should face consequences and international condemnation," she said.

Although Google has not released details of the attacks it detected, security researchers have begun piecing information together. Though the search giant stopped short of blaming the Chinese government directly for the attacks, its decision to end cooperation with state censorship requests strongly implies that the company suspects government involvement.

Independent researchers have also begun gathering evidence that pinpoints the source of the attacks. Joe Stewart, director of malware research for the counter threat unit at an Atlanta-based security company called SecureWorks, went public this week with research suggesting a link between the malware used in the attack and research into algorithms posted on Chinese-language websites.

Stewart was analyzing the Hydraq Trojan, the worm believed to be responsible for accessing internal corporate networks at the companies that were attacked, when he found that the software used an unfamiliar algorithm to check for errors in stored or transferred data. Stewart investigated it and found that this particular implementation had only been described on Chinese-language sites, suggesting a link to hackers in mainland China.

Stewart notes that "reverse-engineering an executable binary is never conclusive," but adds that the Trojan's behavior also fits with that of other attacks that originated from China. However, he says he hasn't noticed any features of the malware that suggest sophistication beyond other recent attacks.

Print

Related Articles

How China and Others Are Altering Web Traffic

"Invisible" servers let governments quietly intercept and modify their citizens' online communications.

Google's Future in China Hangs in the Balance

The search company hopes an extra click will forestall cancellation of its license in China.

China's Internet Paradox

Will China's Web, like its larger economy, comfortably combine extraordinary growth with government repression?

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

gabrielg01

450 Comments

  • 754 Days Ago
  • 01/22/2010

communist China is only one of the ugly bunch...

Condemning communist China for practicing censorship is the right thing to do.

But let's not forget, that we also cooperate with countries which are just as bad as China in terms human rights. You can take "our friends" in Saudi Arabia. They practice Sharia law, which openly discriminates against women, and against non-Muslims. Their Internet is just as censored as China's.

The point is that we don't have credibility if we let others pass, while only bashing China.

Reply

doanwon

76 Comments

  • 754 Days Ago
  • 01/22/2010

Re: communist China is only one of the ugly bunch...

'In her speech in Washington, Clinton cited China as among a number of countries where there has been "a spike in threats to the free flow of information" over the past year. She also named Tunisia, Uzbekistan, Egypt, Iran, Saudi Arabia and Vietnam.'

Could not agree with you more.

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100122/ap_on_hi_te/as_china_google

Reply

skingw

31 Comments

  • 752 Days Ago
  • 01/24/2010

Re: communist China is only one of the ugly bunch...

Totally agreed. But please start with Patriot Act and Guantanamo first. That sounds much more credibility

Reply

gabrielg01

450 Comments

  • 752 Days Ago
  • 01/24/2010

Re: communist China is only one of the ugly bunch...

We do talk openly about the Patriot Act, Guantanamo and many other American failures...That's the basis of free society, and that is why problems (eventually) get solved. You can find lots of uncensored material on such issues.

But if you and I were Chinese citizens criticizing Beijing for Tibet, massive pollution, Internet censorship etc. , we would be jailed or killed in short order.

You can say openly, and loudly, that Obama is wrong on whatever policy. I challenge you to go to China, and say openly and loudly that Hu Jintao is wrong on whatever...Check back with us, to tell us about your experience...Ooops, you'll just disappear.

FYI: the Beijing communists trumpet to the world that the "Chinese Internet is open"...blatant stonewalling double-speak, right out of Orwell's 1984. I mean they completely blocked/banned Picasa, Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Flickr...and then they have the face to say that the "internet is open"...

Reply

mkogrady

425 Comments

  • 754 Days Ago
  • 01/22/2010

You are my Enemy's Enemy and therefore my friend

It seems a lot of these countries learned their Malware craft from Western Universities. I simple direct approach would be to kick anybody from these countries out of these western school where they learn these tactics. Only permit students from these countries to study Basic Medicine, Shelter Construction and Agriculture - keep them in the Stone Age for a few decades till they learn to behave themselves, not only in their own country - but globally.

Reply

jorgejch

7 Comments

  • 754 Days Ago
  • 01/22/2010

Re: You are my Enemy's Enemy and therefore my friend

Wow! Thank you. Sometimes I need to be reminded that there exists people that think and say things like this and sometimes even act upon these beliefs. So interesting that your comment also proposes a form of censorship, and an incredibly harsher one. You would have done good at mideval times.

Reply

skingw

31 Comments

  • 752 Days Ago
  • 01/24/2010

Re: You are my Enemy's Enemy and therefore my friend

Well, for the benefits of people of the earth, don't forget to send American kids before 5th grade to other countries to learn 1) Financial reponsibility 2) Anti-guns 3) anti-obessity 4) hard working... courses before we have time to persuade them not to ruin the world like their adult compatriots are doing.

Reply

Advertisement

Ion

2 Comments

  • 328 Days Ago
  • 03/24/2011

Wikileaks

Unfortunately there is no internet freedom in the U.S. itself.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

A Social-Media Decoder

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

First Solar

Twitter

HTC

Akamai

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement