Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

What Digital IDs Mean

Continued from page 1

By Kate Greene

Friday, February 17, 2006

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

TR: There are benefits to our identities being so mobile, such as remote communication and automated commerce. What are the challenges with mobile identities?

BB: We as an industry have implemented identity technology for a long time. We assigned people an online identity, and, in fact, we did that so successfully that people had a lot of them. Now the next generation of identity technology is trying to allow individuals to get a handle on the complexity that's created by them having all these different identities. They have these different identities not because they want so many, but because each organization they do business with has their own identification system and they don't talk to each other because they bought them from different vendors. So we're trying to reduce the complexity for the individual of managing identity technology.

TR: How do you do that?

BB: We recently announced Tivoli Access Manager Enterprise Single Sign On [a software application]. This allows people to simplify their management of log-on credentials if they have a lot. There's a much older technology that you probably have, that lets you do the same thing -- it's called a wallet. That's a credential management technology. It works in a physical world, but we are building credential management that works in an online world. If you look at Microsoft and their initiative aimed around "InfoCards," it's aimed at a similar problem.

TR: What other problems involving personal identity can software help to solve?

BB: The other thing we're trying to do as an industry is to reduce the overall expense that a business has to dedicate to managing identity. And the way that we're trying to do that is to allow people to share identities that are owned by other organizations. The general term for this kind of technology is "federation." But what it basically means is if I'm a customer of Citibank, and you're a merchant, but your bank is Bank of America, Citibank can manage my identification, but you and Bank of America can recognize it without having to create an identity record for me yourselves. That's a really big deal because managing an identity is expensive. If I have an identity, an account, a PIN number and password, the cost per year of me having to call the help desk every time I forget my password is really, really high. It's in the tens of dollars and sometimes as much as hundreds of dollars for one account per year. So if you can consume my identity without having to manage it, that saves you an enormous amount of money.

TR: People generally don't consistently think of themselves in terms of their digital identity. Should they?

BB: Yes and no. People need to establish accounts, and they do need to have a level of vigilance to insure that the identities used in those accounts aren't being used by other people and they haven't been contaminated by identity theft. You need to do that. But if you say that you're worried about identity, it seems to me that what you're really worried about is one of a variety of other things. You might be worried about your behavior. You might be worried about privacy, which is not exactly about identity. You might be worried that your establishing an identity is in some sense going to compromise privacy that you previously had before you established that identity. In which case what you're really worried about the behavior of the organization you're doing business with.

Comments

  • Digital ID
    Where it will be the trust in the future?
    Rate this comment: 12345
    Guest (Maria)
    02/17/2006
    Posts:1
    • Trust yes...forgiveness??
      Of course there will be trust Maria. The trust is being digitized and accredited to your account. Your one, single, universal account.
      Trust is afterall, only an expectation of behavior based on prior experience with an individual. Now your prior experiences will all be tallied and accessible by anyone has the rights to see them (i.e. anyone you transact with or communicate with).

      The real question becomes "How do you allow a human to change his/her ways?" Currently in the non-digital world there exists a thing called forgiveness. When someone makes a mistake (i.e. violates trust) they can be forgiven and the mistake not be held against them. But in a world where your past mistakes live eternally in your public record, what happens to the individual that wants to suddenly change their ways and live a completely different kind of life??
      Rate this comment: 12345
      Guest (Mark)
      02/21/2006
      Posts:1
      • Forgiveness has a cost
        On several levels, forgiveness has a cost. If you violate my trust, I might forgive you, but shame on me if I forget your violation of my trust in you.  In other words, in some manner, I likely will hedge the trust I extend to you in the future, such as by monitoring your behaviors more carefully, extending you less trust, charging you a higher fee or interest rate, etc.  Just as has been done for millenia in the "analog" world, if you can not afford the impact of such hedges in the digital world, you might offer me the trustworthiness of someone who will vouch for you, post collateral, or otherwise secure my "investment" in your previously untrustworthy behavior.  Not trivial, but certainly no insurmountable problems presented or revolutionary solutions needed here.
        Rate this comment: 12345
        Guest (Mike)
        02/27/2006
        Posts:1
  • admit it
    Digital ID's are an evil dehumanization: you were a only number, now you're only an even less expensive number
    Rate this comment: 12345
    Guest (james)
    02/18/2006
    Posts:1

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Ultra-Efficient Gas Engine Passes Test
Technology Review March/April 2010

Current Issue

TR50
TR presents the 50 most innovative public and private companies of the year.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.