Web

Blindfolding Big Brother, Sort of

(Page 4 of 4)

  • Monday, January 30, 2006
  • By Kate Greene

TR: Is there anything a person can do, other than living off the grid, to keep their digital trail to a minimum?

JJ: Oh, boy -- that's a great, great question. As consumers, we often trade our information, creating a bigger footprint, because of some opportunity being extended to us. And the biggest privacy problem I have with that is when it is a surprise to the consumer. My advice to companies and governments is to avoid consumer surprise. That's one of the most offensive things: when you find out somebody's doing something with your data about which you had no clue.

So my advice is to avoid consumer surprise, and that means having some degree of transparency. I believe consumers should be offered the opportunity to opt out. So the organizations that you transact with, the ones that allow the consumer to say "Hey, please don't sell my data" and those organizations that make it easy for the consumer to opt in or out -- I think consumers may eventually flock to those places where they feel the risk of consumer surprise is less.

TR: The Department of Justice has subpoenaed some of Google's data, and the company is refusing to cooperate. What is your opinion on this?

JJ: I haven't been following this very closely. But let's talk about consumer surprise. I think it would be a surprise to consumers [to find] that they would be identified to the government at individual levels. I think consumers would be less surprised if Google provided just statistics.

TR: As an engineer concerned with privacy issues, what is your opinion on the NSA domestic wiretapping program?

JJ: I have not read up much on that. I don't know whether it's legal or not legal. I would say if it turns out to be legal and it's going to continue, then I would say, "Could you do it with anonymous data?"

TR: As an entrepreneur, you've successfully looked around, found a problem, and solved it with software. In your mind, what is the most important problem to be solved today?

JJ: Picture this: We're in a canyon, and on the left there's this wall, and behind it is this back pressure, and that back pressure is "ill-will" that wants to do harm to democracy or the United States. And behind the other wall it is a police surveillance state. And the number of technology options that you have that don't turn you into a police surveillance state and that prevent the ill-will intent on the left are in the middle. There are a very narrow number of solutions between these canyon walls. But the problem is, should ill-will continue to grow, the pressure behind the wall on the left becomes such that, as we march forward through time, the canyon gets narrower and narrower, and eventually you have bad things happening and you have to be a police surveillance state to protect yourself.

But the real thing that has nothing to do with technology is, if we don't figure out how to lower ill-will, our future is darker.

Print

Related Articles

A Quantum Leap in Cryptography

Encryption products that use the principles of quantum mechanics are becoming more accessible to companies and government agencies.

Military Plays Its 'Smart' Card

U.S. armed forces and civilian workers are setting the pace with their use of chip cards -- a technology that's going to get a lot more use throughout the government thanks to a new federal mandate.

Technology Can Fix U.S. Intelligence

The intelligence reform bill evaded real reform.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

Guest (Colin)

  • 2206 Days Ago
  • 01/30/2006

Who Knew?

One of the best articles I've read.

Database Append - One Way Hashing - Reasonable & Sensative - and my fav, Immutable Audit Log?

Well done.

Reply

Guest (Jay Pons)

  • 2197 Days Ago
  • 02/08/2006

Blindfolding Big Brother

the only thing I would say about the corrupt individual may exist on either side, so the intergrity may be lost. I do believe that this is a defenite step forward in resolving the encrypt and decrypt hassels, but we need to monitor data offloads. Data offloads are primarily a big problem we need to electronically monitor this type of event.
I want to congratulate you it was a very good article and great idea.
Jay Pons
jesuspons@bellsouth.net

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

A Social-Media Decoder

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Zynga

A123 Systems

Synthetic Genomics

Roche

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement