Web

Net Compromise in Tunis

(Page 3 of 3)

  • Tuesday, November 22, 2005
  • By Kenneth Neil Cukier

The domain name system is, in fact, two decades old this year -- and has not evolved much in that time compared to other Internet technologies. Meanwhile, much traffic, from instant messaging to peer-to-peer networks, travels outside the ICANN-sanctioned domain name system -- underscoring that the Internet is not immutable and that one day all the political bickering may not mean much.

Yet legacy technologies can be awfully persistent. The British Admiralty used Morse code as a back-up for ship communications as late as 2000. Technologies still in widespread use are difficult to unseat, regardless of kings and presidents -- or even rough consensus and a running code.

Kenneth Neil Cukier covers technology and regulatory issues for The Economist in London.

The photo accompanying this article on the TechnologyReview.com home page shows President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali of Tunisia addressing delegates at the 2005 World Summit on the Information Society. It was taken by R. Guerra and is reproduced under a Creative Commons license.

Print

Related Articles

ICANN Feud: It's so 1995

Several nations are calling on the United States to give up its power over Internet addresses. But bigger problems loom.

Domain Master

The Internet's head administrator, Paul Twomey, on controlling the core functionality of the Web.

The Net's Faltering Democracy

Why does a corporation with no accountability have so much control over the Internet?

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

Guest (Jack Vaughan)

  • 2275 Days Ago
  • 11/22/2005

Stange confab

I know there has been controversy in similar hearings before..but the picture arises here of a contentious world confab. Not terribly unlike Hallie Ss League of Nations speech or one in StarWars. Have we entered a really new era in globalism and the Web?

Reply

Guest (Erik Karl Sorgatz)

  • 2274 Days Ago
  • 11/23/2005

Internet rights vs responsibilities

Ive read all the RFCs and the informal proposals - not one of these tin-pot backwater whinners is willing to step up to ICANN and offer to trade good practices and accepted methods for autonomy in managing their network extensions. France is a global haven for spammers, scammers and identity thieves, as is Korea, the Caymanns, China, etc. Besides, the Internet is really the commercialized product of ARPA-NET so why shouldnt the US continue to lead in the businesss of names and IP numbering? If those people want it SO BAD, let em build a national LAN! - we can always discuss the idea of allowing their traffic on gateway-basis, IF they behave themselves! I mean come on, half these places dont even have indoor plumbing or a stable agricultural infrastructure, yet theyre worried about having &quotcontrol&quot over something to do with the Internet? Whats the point? They just dislike the idea that America is the last standing superpower - plain and simple.

Reply

Guest (Erik Karl Sorgatz)

  • 2274 Days Ago
  • 11/23/2005

Internet rights vs responsibilities

Ive read all the RFCs and the informal proposals - not one of these tin-pot backwater whinners is willing to step up to ICANN and offer to trade good practices and accepted methods for autonomy in managing their network extensions. France is a global haven for spammers, scammers and identity thieves, as is Korea, the Caymanns, China, etc. Besides, the Internet is really the commercialized product of ARPA-NET so why shouldnt the US continue to lead in the businesss of names and IP numbering? If those people want it SO BAD, let em build a national LAN! - we can always discuss the idea of allowing their traffic on gateway-basis, IF they behave themselves! I mean come on, half these places dont even have indoor plumbing or a stable agricultural infrastructure, yet theyre worried about having &quotcontrol&quot over something to do with the Internet? Whats the point? They just dislike the idea that America is the last standing superpower - plain and simple.

Reply

Guest (Jack Vaughan)

  • 2275 Days Ago
  • 11/22/2005

New age?

I know there has been controversy in similar hearings before..but the picture arises here of a contentious world confab. Not terribly unlike Hallie Ss League of Nations speech or one in StarWars. Have we entered a really new era in globalism and the Web? Is the U.S. in its own world?

Reply

Guest (Jack Vaughan)

  • 2275 Days Ago
  • 11/22/2005

Stange confab

I know there has been controversy in similar hearings before..but the picture arises here of a contentious world confab. Not terribly unlike Hallie Ss League of Nations speech or one in StarWars. Have we entered a really new era in globalism and the Web?

Reply

Guest (Jack Vaughan)

  • 2275 Days Ago
  • 11/22/2005

New age?

I know there has been controversy in similar hearings before..but the picture arises here of a contentious world confab. Not terribly unlike Hallie Ss League of Nations speech or one in StarWars. Have we entered a really new era in globalism and the Web? Is the U.S. in its own world?

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

A Social-Media Decoder

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Goldwind Science and Technology

First Solar

Serious Materials

BIND Biosciences

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement