Big wind: An installation ship jacked-up over the water’s surface constructs three-megawatt wind turbines off the coast of the United Kingdom. The 100-turbine wind farm was completed in June.
Vattenfall

Energy

Europe's Renewables Unfazed by Recession

The financial crisis in Europe is unlikely to derail Brussels' clean power vision.

  • Monday, July 12, 2010
  • By Peter Fairley

European renewable energy installations hit record levels last year and are likely to grow strongly over the next decade, despite European governments' budget woes. That's the view of a report released last week by the European Commission's Joint Research Centre in Brussels. The report suggests that the growth won't be slowed by the German parliament's approval on Friday of a reduction in price supports for solar power, or by a similar reduction in solar incentives by Spain last year.

Solar companies in Germany had warned that the proposed reductions in incentives would hurt the solar industry there, but the lead author of the new report, Arnulf Jäger-Waldau, a Joint Research Centre senior scientist, downplays their warnings. "The solar lobby was very efficient in drawing a dramatic picture that's clearly overstated," he says. While German solar panel manufacturers could face challenges, he says, installers will still make a decent profit.

The European Commission review estimates that European utilities and developers installed 10.2 gigawatts of new wind farms and 5.8 gigawatts of photovoltaic panels and solar thermal power in 2009, with such renewable power installations accounting for 62 percent of all new electricity generation capacity. And plans submitted to Brussels last month by European Union member states affirm their intention to install plenty more to meet targets set last year under the E.U.'s Renewable Energy Directive, which would boost Europe's use of renewables from 8.5 percent of total energy consumption to 20 percent by 2020.

European states will deliver on their targets to avoid heavy fines from the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg, according to Hélène Pelosse, who helped negotiate the Renewables Directive and is now interim director general for the Abu Dhabi-based International Renewable Energy Agency. "A binding target is really a binding target. It's not something you can ignore," says Pelosse.

Advertisement

Pelosse says that the German and Spanish photovoltaics incentives--feed-in tariffs that require utilities to buy renewable power generation at premium prices--were cut back because they were overly generous, based on the price of solar panels. She says that crafting the feed-in tariffs is an imperfect process, because governments lack insider information on production costs. Jäger-Waldau agrees that the German and Spanish tariffs were set too high, providing excessive profits to generators and thus imposing unfair costs on utilities and their consumers.

Looking forward, he says anxiety created by the widely anticipated changes to Germany's feed-in tariffs for renewable energy approved last week are actually stoking growth further--at least temporarily. The price that utilities must pay for generation from rooftop photovoltaics dropped 13 percent this month, and will be trimmed a further 3 percent in October. Developers rushing to complete projects ahead of the German reductions will install as much as eight gigawatts in 2010, Jäger-Waldau predicts. He estimates that, as a result, European photovoltaic installations will roughly double from last year's 5.4 to 5.6 gigawatts.

Print

Related Articles

Khosla Biofuel IPO Draws Doubters

As yet another biofuels company prepares for a stock offering, some wonder if the company is worthy of going public at all.

The German Experiment

The government sets a premium price on solar and other alternative power sources. The policy offers lessons in ways to encourage the use of renewable energy.

Western U.S. Grid Can Handle More Renewables

A study says 35 percent of electricity could come from solar and wind--without expensive new backup power plants.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

StupidPeasant

98 Comments

  • 576 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2010

Socialist planners unfazed by reality.

Reply

smithsomian

182 Comments

  • 576 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2010

well, duh

so a heavily subsidized industry in which incomes are guaranteed by a heavy-handed government mandate to purchase their product is not severely impacted by recession? imagine my shock. let's see them compete on a fair playing field in a real marketplace, and see whether the recession affects them or not.

Reply

patrsnw

9 Comments

  • 576 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2010

Re: well, duh

Not like other utilities, right?  Let's cut the subsidies to oil, gas, and conventional power, and let's see what happens.

Reply

gabrielg01

450 Comments

  • 576 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2010

Re: well, duh - What fair playing field?

What "fair playing field" and "real marketplace" are you talking about?...There is no such thing. The oil-gas-coal industries receive humongous government incentives. To add insult to injury, the oil industry also receives a gigantic military backing. What if the oil industry had to pay the bills for all the military bases in the Middle East? What would be the real "market price" of oil then? If you believe that gasoline costs only $3/gallon, you live in Lala land.

Reply

R Sweeney

67 Comments

  • 576 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2010

Re: well, duh - What fair playing field?

Let's hear about those subsidies to coal and petroleum. I want to know who's taking my money and giving it to Exxon.

BTW... allowing a company to KEEP it's own money is not a subsidy.

Reply

gabrielg01

450 Comments

  • 576 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2010

Re: well, duh - What fair playing field?

You can just Google "oil industry subsidies".
Here are 2 examples:
http://cleantech.com/news/554/oil-industry-subsidies-for-dummies

http://www.ucsusa.org/clean_vehicles/vehicle_impacts/cars_pickups_and_suvs/subsidizing-big-oil.html

The 2nd report is old (from 1995), but nothing changed since then.

You can also add the costs of our military presence in the Middle East as part of the oil subsidy.

Reply

PermanentMarker

6 Comments

  • 575 Days Ago
  • 07/13/2010

Re: well, duh - What fair playing field?

if our economy didnt run on oil.
we would not even be in the middle east.

so instead of pumping money in the militairy, science of new weapons, or keeping old tech car industries a live for this broken oil dream.
We do have a choice to get our energy from somewhere else, for example wind solar geothermal energy are plentyfull available, and would cover the needs for the world..

Reply

Advertisement

R Sweeney

67 Comments

  • 575 Days Ago
  • 07/13/2010

Re: well, duh - What fair playing field?

Roads are a subsidy????

Won't electric cars and human pedicabs of the green "future" run on them too?

Reply

smithsomian

182 Comments

  • 568 Days Ago
  • 07/20/2010

Re: well, duh - What fair playing field?

interesting. glad to find reports from such "unbiased" sources. while the reports may be true, at least in some regard, I would like to see some data from other than the competition (cleantech) or a traditionally anti-business, anti-reality lobby group (UCS). I also would have to agree with a previous poster that simply allowing a company to keep money it has earned by failing to apply some punitive tax or fee is not a "subsidy." TPTB in DC have been trying to condition us for years that our money belongs to the government, and when they allow us to keep some of it, it is a gift. this used to be a free country that was centered on the rights of the individual - we need to get back there.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Printing Parts

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Lyric Semiconductor

IBM

iRobot

Akamai

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement