Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Superconductors to Wire a Smarter Grid

A superstation for connecting three independent grids could help solar and wind power.

By Kevin Bullis

Thursday, November 12, 2009

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

A proposed hub for connecting the three independent electricity grids that span the continental United States could make it easier to ramp up production of renewable electricity.

Cool power: These superconducting wires form the basis of power cables that carry far more power than conventional copper cables.
Credit: American Superconductor

The project, called the Tres Amigas Superstation, would use superconducting "pipelines" and converter stations to connect three grids: the Western, Eastern, and Texas Interconnections. Connections between the grids have been limited because the grids aren't synchronized--the AC power is out of phase. Special stations that convert AC power into DC power and then back into AC power in the correct phase are needed to move power from one grid to another.

Only a fraction of 1 percent of the electricity generated in the United States can currently be transferred between the grids, and there is no direct connection between Texas and the Western grid. The Tres Amigas station, which will connect all three grids together in one place for the first time, will initially more than double the ability to transfer power between them, providing five gigawatts of capacity. Eventually, the station is expected to transfer as much as 30 gigawatts of power.

The station will "solve a host of problems" related to renewable energy, says Phil Harris, CEO of the Tres Amigas company, based in Santa Fe, NM. Primarily, it will help address a key problem with renewable sources of energy--their intermittency. Because wind comes and goes and clouds block the sun from time to time, wind and solar power can destabilize the electric grid.

One way to compensate is to make sure that no renewable source accounts for too much of the total power mix--so that other sources can easily fill in when there's a drop in power. In Texas, however, this strategy would quickly limit the size of wind farms, since the grid there is relatively small. By connecting to the rest of the country, Tres Amigas removes the limit on the size of these farms.

Story continues below


Intermittency can also be addressed by gathering renewable energy over a wide area. That way, a drop in solar power due to a cloudy day in one region could be offset by wind or solar elsewhere. Connecting the three grids makes it possible to draw on a wider variety of renewable sources, especially in the Southwest, which is divided by the borders between them. The station will also provide between 50 and 150 megawatts of battery storage to smooth out power fluctuations on the grid to help prevent outages.

The project could also be a valuable testing ground for direct current superconducting transmission lines, which could have significant advantages over conventional power lines for delivering large amounts of power over long distances, says Steven Eckroad, a project manager at the Palo Alto, CA-based Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), which is studying the potential of superconductors for long-distance transmission. Such transmission lines could collect wind power from the Midwest, where it is abundant, and transmit it to the South, which has fewer renewable resources.

Comments

  • Issues
    Don't superconducting materials require some rare earth metals?  And doesn't China now have a virtual monopoly on rare earth metals because environmentalists have blocked the type mining in the US needed to extract rare earth metals? 

    And wouldn't a single connection point be a very attractive terrorist target?

    RD
    11/12/2009
    Posts:125
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: Issues
      Rd, smile when you say environmentalist, I'm an environmentalist who wants to protect my environment as well as yours, I do travel you know.  People throw around the word environmentalist like they  to used the word Liberal.  I believe that's a corporates smear tactic.  Funny how the so called environmentalists couldn't stop mountain top removal mining which is going on as we speak.
      Yes I'm an environmentalist, And you are?
      Sam

      ssamd
      11/12/2009
      Posts:5
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
    • Re: Issues
      If they are going like other American Superconductor (a company) projects it will be something like BSCCO-2223 which is made of bismuth, strontium, calcium, copper oxide, and a tiny bit of lead. None of which are "rare earth" elements. I know there are superconductors which do use all sorts of rare elements but power lines require a special mix of properties to stay superconducting at the desired power levels used in these lines. So even though there may be higher temperature conductors in the lab I am betting the one I listed is the one being used.

      As to the terrorism and grid security angle. These lines will likely be undergound and sufficently buffered and as it is expanded more and more redundancy will be added. Remember there is no special spot where all these regional grids come together so what you see as one facility is actualy three or more facilities linked by underground superconductor lines to form a power distribution and load balancing network.

      As to the other commentor on AC-DC-AC conversion. This is regularly done all over the world. High voltage DC transmission lines superconducting or not are more efficient in many applications. (long transmission lines, underground, or underwater, etc.) These efficiencies more than make up for the conversion losses and allow you to link grids which are not in phase.

      Gurthang
      11/12/2009
      Posts:23
      Avg Rating:
      4/5

This discussion has been moved to our discussions forum.

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review January/February 2010

Current Issue

Security in the Ether
Information technology's next grand challenge will be to secure the cloud--and prove we can trust it.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.