Sulfur power: This prototype lithium-sulfur battery was developed by Sion Power. In cooperation with BASF, the company intends to improve the battery design for use in electric vehicles.
Sion Power

Energy

Revisiting Lithium-Sulfur Batteries

Advances could at last make the high-energy batteries practical.

  • Friday, May 22, 2009
  • By Kevin Bullis

Lithium-sulfur batteries, which can potentially store several times more energy than lithium-ion batteries, have historically been too costly, unsafe, and unreliable to make commercially. But they're getting a fresh look now, due to some recent advances. Improvements to the design of these batteries have led the chemical giant BASF of Ludwigshafen, Germany, to team up with Sion Power, a company in Tucson, AZ, that has already developed prototype lithium-sulfur battery cells.

"Compared to existing technologies used in electric vehicles, the plan is to increase driving distance at least 5 to 10 times," for a given-size battery, says Thomas Weber, CEO of a subsidiary of BASF called BASF Future Business. Other experts say that a threefold improvement is a more reasonable estimate, but that would still be an impressive jump in performance. Weber says that BASF's expertise in materials will help Sion Power further improve its technology and bring it to market faster. He declined to provide details of the arrangement, however, including how much money is involved and how the companies will share any profits.

Lithium-sulfur batteries have one electrode made of lithium and another made of sulfur that is typically paired with carbon. As with lithium-ion batteries, charging and discharging the battery involves the movement of lithium ions between the two electrodes. But the theoretical capacity of lithium-sulfur batteries is higher than that of lithium-ion batteries because of the way the ions are assimilated at the electrodes. For example, at the sulfur electrode, each sulfur atom can host two lithium ions. Typically, in lithium-ion batteries, for every host atom, only 0.5 to 0.7 lithium ions can be accommodated, says Linda Nazar, a professor of chemistry at the University of Waterloo.

Making materials that take advantage of this higher theoretical capacity has been a challenge. One big issue has been that sulfur is an insulating material, making it difficult for electrons and ions to move in and out. So while each sulfur atom may in theory be able to host two lithium ions, in fact often only those atoms of sulfur near the surface of the material accept lithium ions.

Advertisement

Another problem is that as the sulfur binds to lithium ions, eventually forming dilithium sulfide, it forms a number of intermediate products called polysulfides. These dissolve in the battery's liquid electrolyte and eventually can settle in other areas of the battery, where they can block charging and discharging. Because of this, the battery can stop working altogether after only a few dozen cycles.

What's more, the lithium metal electrode presents potential safety problems. For example, during use, the lithium electrode can grow branchlike structures that increase the impedance of the cell, causing it to heat up. Eventually these structures can cause a short circuit. If the battery heats up, the metal can melt. If the molten lithium leaks out of the cell and comes into contact with water, it can start a fire. The battery's electrolyte can also catch fire.

Although he declined to give specifics, Weber says these safety issues have been solved. BASF's goal is to further improve the materials to access more of their theoretical capacity, something he says the company has a clear plan for doing.

Print

Related Articles

A Boost for Battery Life and Capacity

Electric cars could benefit from a new manufacturing method.

Packing More into Lithium Batteries

Lithium sulfur promises a longer charge, and safer operation, compared to standard lithium batteries.

High-Energy Batteries Coming to Market

Rechargeable zinc-air batteries can store three times the energy of a lithium-ion battery.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

killian

74 Comments

  • 988 Days Ago
  • 05/22/2009

good article

Thanks Kevin. I have seen a number of Lithium Sulfur articles so far, and this was the first one that discussed the issues in such detail. It helps to have specifics though, and so I would add that GreenCarCongress gave Sion's specific energy as "more than 350 Wh/kg", and they had some nice charts.

Reply

Kevin Bullis

177 Comments

  • 988 Days Ago
  • 05/22/2009

Re: good article

Thanks Killian.  I can confirm that number, 350 Wh/Kg is correct for Sion's prototype cell. But that only gets 50 cycles, so in some ways comparing that to lithium ion is apples and oranges.

Reply

dancrissco

54 Comments

  • 792 Days Ago
  • 12/04/2009

Looks like a perfect battery for the pemmPOD

I have been looking for a perfect battery for the pemmPOD. (Personal Emotional Mobile)
This looks like an ideal candidate.
More details on the pemmPOD can be found at
http://dancrissco.wordpress.com/
The pemmPOD is a Solar experimental under concept design. It is configurable like a PC and serves as personal transportation, PC, media player and office work station. It is proposed to be made out of renewable materials.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Printing Parts

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Apple

Nissan

Joule Unlimited

PrimeSense

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement