Features

A Zero-Emissions City in the Desert

(Page 4 of 5)

  • March/April 2009
  • By Kevin Bullis

Neighboring heating and cooling zones can also affect one another to create complex and unpredictable feedback loops, especially as the number of zones increases. United Technologies' J. Michael McQuade recalls what happened when his company designed what was supposed to be an intelligent heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning management system for a new building in Paris. The system was designed to coördinate 3,000 different zones. "When that building was first put together, it was a significant energy consumer, and it took a revamp of the integrated control systems to get it right," McQuade says.

If zero-emissions buildings are to be economical, Scofield says, the designs will have work from the start. "If you don't get it right," he says, pointing to the fiasco at Oberlin, "every correction you make is so much more costly than getting it right the first time."

Personal Transit
Masdar City will be raised on concrete stilts to make room for a personal rapid-transit (PRT) system that will replace buses and trains with smaller vehicles designed for four people. Masdar's planners expect the system to use less energy than conventional mass transit, and they say it will be more convenient, too.

In a PRT system, several small vehicles, often called pods, are kept waiting at each station. An individual or a small group boards one and selects a destination; the pod proceeds automatically to the destination without stopping. In a typical design, each ­vehicle resembles a battery-powered golf cart, only it's completely enclosed and somewhat bigger--and it lacks a steering wheel. The vehicle follows a track, which is connected to stations by on-ramps and off-ramps, and a computer controls how the pods enter and exit the stations: the ramps allow individual pods to make stops while others continue along the main track at top speeds. Simulations suggest that the systems could run with as little as half a second between vehicles.

Video

But although PRTs look promising, they haven't caught on. That's in part because an early PRT-like system built in the 1970s in Morgantown, WV, gave the idea a bad name, says Jerry Schneider, an emeritus professor of urban planning and civil engineering at the University of Washington in Seattle and a longtime advocate of PRTs. "People would get on the vehicles and they wouldn't stop," Schneider says of the system, a transit line with automated cars for about 20 people. Technology has improved since then, he says, but there hasn't been a significant real-world demonstration of the updated systems.

Two demonstration programs are on the way. The first, which will transport passengers to a new terminal at Heathrow International Airport near London, will open later this year. Tests of that system are already under way. And the first stage of the system at Masdar City, to be built by the Dutch firm 2GetThere, is scheduled to be in place for the opening of the Masdar Institute this fall.

The Test Bed
Sameer Abu-Zaid isn't breaking a sweat. It's 39 °C with 74 percent humidity, but he says it's a nice day--much cooler than the summer in Abu Dhabi, when temperatures can reach 49 °C. Abu-Zaid, who's originally from Jordan and was most recently a manager at a semiconductor equipment manufacturer in Silicon Valley, will manage Masdar City's power and distribution infrastructure. "All of these modules have been tested at the factories," he says as he gives a tour of one of the first visible signs of the city, a test site where he's putting 41 arrays of solar panels from various manufacturers through their paces. "But they have been tested under standard test conditions: 1,000 watts per meter squared, 25 °C. Nice air-conditioned space. It is totally different here."

Dust from the desert quickly coats the panels, effectively dimming the light that reaches them. Abu-Zaid has learned that just four months of dust reduces the output of the solar arrays by more than 20 percent--information he'll use to decide how often to wash the panels, balancing power loss against water consumption.

Print

Related Articles

What New Emissions Standards Will Mean to Automakers

Increasing mileage standards to 54.5 mpg won't require major new technologies, say experts.

Using Heat to Cool Buildings

Novel materials could make practical air conditioners and refrigerators that use little or no electricity.

Self-Cleaning Solar Panels

A technology intended for Mars missions may find use on solar installations in the deserts on Earth.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

lasertekk

146 Comments

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

Interesting...

An oil producing country taking the alternative energy route?  What's the 'behind closed doors' reason for this?

Reply

Kevin Bullis

178 Comments

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

Re: Interesting...

No doubt part of it is to make themselves look good. But they also seem to think they can make a lot of money with alternative energy.  The city itself is just part of the project--maybe the city will end up losing money, but provide valuable marketing for other efforts, such as making solar panels. But they do claim they can make money with the city, as well.

Reply

Mekhong Kurt

13 Comments

  • 780 Days Ago
  • 12/26/2009

Re: Interesting...

According to a friend of mine who lives there, they're also looking ahead to the day when they have no more oil, which apparently is somewhere around a decade up the road. Also, they understand the advantages of diversification.

It's nearly 2010 as I write, and with the economic body blow they've taken, it's not clear what will happen with this project.

Reply

o_obrien

1 Comment

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

What about solar concentrators?

I wonder why they're using large arrays of solar panels instead of smaller solar concentrator systems, which should be cheaper and more efficient. Plus, if they were using concentrators they'd have much smaller PV devices to worry about so washing them regularly would require much less water...

Reply

Kevin Bullis

178 Comments

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

Re: What about solar concentrators?

Solar concentrators aren't really smaller--the solar cell part is, but the collector isn't. These systems typically require tracking systems that are less than ideal for rooftops.

That said, they will be installing concentrated solar within the city acreage, but not on top of buildings.

Reply

IggyDalrymple

22 Comments

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

It's their money....

I agree, it's an interesting testbed for new technologies, but I'm very disappointed that TR has become a pulpit for GW religious dogma.

Reply

RD

212 Comments

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

Debt Load

$80 Billion of debt was incurred by Abu Dhabi to build Dubai World, and now they are in desparate straits.  With the loss of projected oil revenue, they now are trying to sell assets (at a loss) to meet the interest payments. The additional $15 Billion of debt for this eco project likely will force a work stoppage of this city.  Thus it is with feel good eco projects.  While they raise prestige, they still are mostly uneconomical.  A similar comparison can be made between US eco projects and traditional energy.  The eco projects usually are more expensive and drain investment money away from other productivity gains.  There is only so much capital to use for business and if the government increases taxes (to fund eco projects), the result will be decreased investment in production efficiency.  Some eco projects are wise investments, but the current political climate is throwing money at a wall to see what sticks.  Projects such as ethanol from corn damage our economy, our environment, and our common sense.

Reply

Advertisement

Kevin Bullis

178 Comments

  • 1084 Days Ago
  • 02/25/2009

Re: Debt Load

It's probably good to differentiate between Dubai and Abu Dhabi, both of which are part of the UAE. Dubai has been hit harder than Abu Dhabi, since Dubai relies more on real estate (it has very little oil of its own.)

Reply

DennisBuller

118 Comments

  • 1080 Days Ago
  • 03/01/2009

Government Built Cities?

  My focus is not so much on the green aspect but on the fact that their government is trying to build an entire city from scratch.
  Are their any successful precedents for this?
  I can only think of Saint Petersburg and the capitol of Brazil.
I think 300,000 people were killed building Saint Petersburg and in the capitol of Brazil they forgot to put in sidewalks and a ridiculous amount of people get run over every year.....
   Government at work!!
 

Reply

Grant837

1 Comment

  • 1034 Days Ago
  • 04/16/2009

Re: Government Built Cities?

China builds (starts or finishes) new cities of a million or more every year... it works pretty good for them, even if their methods do not match the western worlds tastes.  India should be doing the same, but I understand that democracy gets in the way... interesting thought huh?
Abu Dhabi is doing this because they full well that their oil revenue will dry up sooner than later, and want to replace that as exporters of energy technology.

Reply

Phineas

127 Comments

  • 924 Days Ago
  • 08/04/2009

Anticipating Oil Shortage?

The 'Peak Oil' proponents think that declining production will force exporting nations to cease exports in as few as eight years. Perhaps they are preparing for life with less oil.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Printing Parts

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

iRobot

Square

Lyric Semiconductor

Pacific Biosciences

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement