Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

March/April 2009

A Zero-Emissions City in the Desert

Oil-rich Abu Dhabi is building a green metropolis. Should the rest of the world care?

By Kevin Bullis

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

The first hints of the project are visible. A white wall stretches through the desert, like a chalk line on a dusty playing field. A bus with darkened windows stirs a low cloud, ferrying workers past a cluster of steel cranes, two portable drilling rigs, and a stand of concrete columns sprouting rust-colored rebar. A tall wire fence guards rows of solar panels mounted on concrete pads.

Desert city: The Masdar City development, near Abu Dhabi, was in the first stages of construction last October. In the distance, cranes erect the first building, a research institute.
Credit: Kevin Bullis
Multimedia
video  Watch Gerard Evenden, developer of the master plan for Masdar City, describe the main techniques he uses to save energy.
video  See a fly-through animation of the Masdar City design.
photo  See a diagram of the Masdar Initiative's Headquarters.
video  Visit the solar test field site at Masdar City.
Reporters Notebook: Kevin Bullis

Click here to hear what is was like reporting from Abu Dhabi for this story.

The construction is the start of a vast experiment, an attempt to create the world's first car-free, zero-carbon-dioxide-emissions, zero-waste city. Due to be completed in 2016, the city is the centerpiece of the Masdar Initiative, a $15 billion investment by the government of Abu Dhabi, which is part of the United Arab Emirates. The new development, being built on the outskirts of Abu Dhabi city, will run almost entirely on energy from the sun and will use just 20 percent as much power as a conventional city of similar size. Garbage will be sorted and recycled or used for compost; sewage will be processed into fuel. Concrete columns will lift the city seven meters off the ground, creating space underneath for a network of automated electric transports that will replace cars. Planners predict that the development will attract 1,500 clean-tech businesses, ranging from large international corporations to startups, and--eventually--some 50,000 residents.

The city will be an oasis of renewable energy in a country of five million, made rich by oil, that consumes the most natural resources per capita in the world. Seen one way, it's just the latest ostentatious project in a country that's been defined by them. Indeed, the UAE is already home to the world's tallest building and an enormous indoor ski facility that features a 200-meter-long black-diamond slope. Real-estate developers have dredged coral and sand from the sea floor, piling it up in the Persian Gulf to create islands in the shape of palm trees and a map of the world.

Yet many experts are optimistic that the city can become a test bed for new approaches to the engineering and architectural problems involved in creating environmentally sustainable cities. Although architects have already designed and builders constructed many small zero-emissions residences and commercial buildings, projects involving large, multi-use commercial buildings have fallen short of expectations, using too much energy or failing to generate enough. Part of the problem is the growing complexity that comes with scale, says J. Michael McQuade, senior vice president of science and technology at United Technologies in Hartford, CT; today's design software hasn't been able to handle it. But Masdar City, itself developed with the help of extensive modeling, will be wired from the beginning to collect data that could prove valuable for developing better models. That information could make future zero-emissions cities cheaper and easier to build.

And the development is meant to make money, not just introduce new technology. "We want Masdar City to be profitable, not just a sunk cost," said Khaled Awad, the project's director of property development, at a huge real-estate exhibition in Dubai last fall. "If it is not profitable as a real-estate development, it is not sustainable." Yet if it is, it may be replicable.

Story continues below


"If environmental engineers, by gaining experience from building this wild city, become much more productive at building the next city, this starts to move from being science fiction to something Houston would adopt," says Matthew Kahn, a professor of economics at the University of California, Los Angeles. Gil Friend, CEO of Natural Logic, a sustainable-design company based in Berkeley, CA, agrees. "I see Masdar on the one hand as a playground for the rich," he says, "and on the other hand as an R&D opportunity to deploy and test out technology that, if things go well, will show up in other cities."

Of course, much of what's learned from Masdar won't apply outside the incredibly hot and sunny coast of the Persian Gulf. A site in Germany, which wouldn't get as much sunlight, couldn't rely as heavily on solar energy. A site in San Francisco might not need air conditioning, making information about advanced cooling systems less relevant. But if the project reaches its environmental goals, it will at the very least show that such cities can be built. "People say, 'Gee, that would be great. That would be a good idea, but obviously it's not possible,'" Friend says. "Once you can point at something, it takes away a lot of those arguments."

Comments

  • Interesting...
    An oil producing country taking the alternative energy route?  What's the 'behind closed doors' reason for this?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    lasertekk
    02/25/2009
    Posts:88
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: Interesting...
      No doubt part of it is to make themselves look good. But they also seem to think they can make a lot of money with alternative energy.  The city itself is just part of the project--maybe the city will end up losing money, but provide valuable marketing for other efforts, such as making solar panels. But they do claim they can make money with the city, as well.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Kevin Bullis
      02/25/2009
      Posts:101
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
    • Re: Interesting...
      According to a friend of mine who lives there, they're also looking ahead to the day when they have no more oil, which apparently is somewhere around a decade up the road. Also, they understand the advantages of diversification.

      It's nearly 2010 as I write, and with the economic body blow they've taken, it's not clear what will happen with this project.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Mekhong Kurt
      12/26/2009
      Posts:7
      Avg Rating:
      5/5
  • What about solar concentrators?
    I wonder why they're using large arrays of solar panels instead of smaller solar concentrator systems, which should be cheaper and more efficient. Plus, if they were using concentrators they'd have much smaller PV devices to worry about so washing them regularly would require much less water...
    Rate this comment: 12345

    o_obrien
    02/25/2009
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
    • Re: What about solar concentrators?
      Solar concentrators aren't really smaller--the solar cell part is, but the collector isn't. These systems typically require tracking systems that are less than ideal for rooftops.

      That said, they will be installing concentrated solar within the city acreage, but not on top of buildings.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Kevin Bullis
      02/25/2009
      Posts:101
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
  • It's their money....
    I agree, it's an interesting testbed for new technologies, but I'm very disappointed that TR has become a pulpit for GW religious dogma.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    IggyDalrympl...
    02/25/2009
    Posts:9
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Debt Load
    $80 Billion of debt was incurred by Abu Dhabi to build Dubai World, and now they are in desparate straits.  With the loss of projected oil revenue, they now are trying to sell assets (at a loss) to meet the interest payments. The additional $15 Billion of debt for this eco project likely will force a work stoppage of this city.  Thus it is with feel good eco projects.  While they raise prestige, they still are mostly uneconomical.  A similar comparison can be made between US eco projects and traditional energy.  The eco projects usually are more expensive and drain investment money away from other productivity gains.  There is only so much capital to use for business and if the government increases taxes (to fund eco projects), the result will be decreased investment in production efficiency.  Some eco projects are wise investments, but the current political climate is throwing money at a wall to see what sticks.  Projects such as ethanol from corn damage our economy, our environment, and our common sense.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    RD
    02/25/2009
    Posts:125
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: Debt Load
      It's probably good to differentiate between Dubai and Abu Dhabi, both of which are part of the UAE. Dubai has been hit harder than Abu Dhabi, since Dubai relies more on real estate (it has very little oil of its own.)
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Kevin Bullis
      02/25/2009
      Posts:101
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
  • Government Built Cities?
      My focus is not so much on the green aspect but on the fact that their government is trying to build an entire city from scratch.
      Are their any successful precedents for this?
      I can only think of Saint Petersburg and the capitol of Brazil.
    I think 300,000 people were killed building Saint Petersburg and in the capitol of Brazil they forgot to put in sidewalks and a ridiculous amount of people get run over every year.....
       Government at work!!
     
    Rate this comment: 12345

    DennisBuller
    03/01/2009
    Posts:47
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re: Government Built Cities?
      China builds (starts or finishes) new cities of a million or more every year... it works pretty good for them, even if their methods do not match the western worlds tastes.  India should be doing the same, but I understand that democracy gets in the way... interesting thought huh?
      Abu Dhabi is doing this because they full well that their oil revenue will dry up sooner than later, and want to replace that as exporters of energy technology.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Grant837
      04/16/2009
      Posts:1
      Avg Rating:
      5/5
  • Anticipating Oil Shortage?
    The 'Peak Oil' proponents think that declining production will force exporting nations to cease exports in as few as eight years. Perhaps they are preparing for life with less oil.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Phineas
    08/04/2009
    Posts:93
    Avg Rating:
    4/5

Technology Review Magazine

The 10 Emerging Technologies of 2009
Technology Review presents its annual list of 10 technologies that could change the way we live.

FEATURES

A Zero-Emissions City in the Desert
Oil-rich Abu Dhabi is building a green metropolis. Should the rest of the world care?
By Kevin Bullis
But Who's Counting?
No one really knows how many people visit websites. A San Francisco startup and Google are both working to change that.
By Jason Pontin

Read more articles from this Issue

NOTEBOOKS FORWARD ESSAY TO MARKET Q&A PHOTO ESSAY REVIEWS HACK DEMO
Archives MIT News Subscribe Contact

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Malleable Maps, Artistic Robots and Bubble Interfaces
Technology Review January/February 2010

Current Issue

Security in the Ether
Information technology's next grand challenge will be to secure the cloud--and prove we can trust it.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.