NREL

Energy

More Energy-Efficient Ethanol

A process used in wastewater treatment may increase efficiency in ethanol plants.

  • Monday, August 18, 2008
  • By Jennifer Chu

Making corn ethanol is an energy-intensive process, requiring fossil fuels to grow and harvest corn and to power the production plant. To make the process more energy efficient, researchers at Washington University are proposing to borrow a process used in breweries and wastewater treatment facilities: oxygen-less vats of bacteria that naturally feed on organic waste produced from the fermentation process.

As bacteria break down waste, it releases methane, which can be funneled back through the system to help power a plant. The process requires little additional energy to run, and can further cut down on energy costs by producing its own power. Largus Angenent, a professor of chemical engineering, and his team at Washington University have tested anaerobic digestion on waste from ethanol plants and found that the process could cut down an ethanol facility's use of natural gas by 50 percent. The team has published the results in the recent issue of the journal Environmental Science and Technology.

Angenent says that the process would serve as a short-term solution until more-efficient biofuel, such as cellulosic ethanol, is commercially viable. "Rather than have hope for new technology that comes to fruition in 10 or 20 years, we need technology we can implement now," says Angenent, who recently became an assistant professor of biological and environmental engineering at Cornell University. "This is an interim process, and it's off the shelf."

Nearly all ethanol biofuel in the United States is made from corn. Typically, the ethanol production yields organic waste that is then consolidated into two parts: a dry, cake-like substance and a syrupy solution, called thin stillage, that's layered on top. The concoction is used as animal feed. Angenent says that a large portion of this feed, particularly thin stillage, which is laden with salts, provides low nutritional value but may have high energy potential for powering a plant when broken down via anaerobic digestion.

Advertisement

To test this theory, the researchers cultivated thermophilic bacteria from a wastewater treatment plant in two small, five-liter anaerobic digesters. Angenent and his colleagues then slowly began feeding waste samples into the digesters, which were kept at 55 °C to maximize the bacteria's activity. As the digesters ran, the team measured the amount of methane released.

However, initial tests found that the process produced very little methane. Angenent guessed that the system might be missing an essential ingredient but was unsure as to what that might be. So the team dug into the scientific literature and found that methane-producing bacteria require certain trace elements to jump-start the process--particularly cobalt.

Print

Related Articles

Battling Ethanol-Propelled Food Prices

Demand for corn-derived fuel is driving up food prices, but new technologies could help.

The Price of Biofuels

Making ethanol from corn is expensive. Better biofuels are years away from the gas tank. Farmers are reluctant to change their practices. But do we really have any alternative to biofuels?

Cheaper, Cleaner Ethanol from Biotech Corn

The genetically-modified plants break down their own cellulose, making it possible to use waste biomass to produce ethanol.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

Plataputylus

10 Comments

  • 1276 Days Ago
  • 08/18/2008

Don't forget the water

None of the estimates of energy usage to create corn-based ethanol include the cost of the water needed to grow the corn.  With aquifer levels dropping all over the mid-west, there are both short- and long-term costs that have yet to be considered.

Reply

Pat495

16 Comments

  • 1276 Days Ago
  • 08/18/2008

More efficient ethanol

Seems pretty elementary to use all the power available.  Anaerobic digesters will also accept cellulosic fuels. 

Reply

ChuckInReno

20 Comments

  • 1275 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2008

cellulose in anaerobic digesters

Could you cite some work that shows anaerobic digestion transforming cellulosic biomass to CH4? Cellulose passes right through the digesters used in large wastewater treatment plants. So you must be describing something I haven't seen yet.

Reply

Flip

30 Comments

  • 1270 Days Ago
  • 08/24/2008

Re: cellulose in anaerobic digesters

I think the ArrowBio process can handle cellulose. The process is generically known as Upflow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket Digestion (UASB).

Reply

  • 1275 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2008

What about digester effluent?

Adding anaerobic digestion has already been considered by consultants.  Capital and operating costs are prohibitive. Digester effluent is a problem.  It is a sludge with an extremely high organic- and ammonia-N content.  All of the treatment options are extremely difficult if you actually do the detailed analysis. Wastewater energy demands will greatly reduce energy efficiency gains. Land application is no easy solution.  Good work hiking to the mountain.  All the hard climbing is still left to do.

Reply

EmmettLBrown

1 Comment

  • 894 Days Ago
  • 09/04/2009

Re: What about digester effluent?

Anaerobic Digestion for use in Cellulosic Ethanol plants is already patented by For Fuel Freedom, Inc. and called Organic Hydrolysis™.  The additional effluent is taken care of by a blend of organisms, and the water is purged of ammonia during processes like sugar separation.  But energy is not the only economic issue.  Along with its Hybrid Ethanol and Bio-diesel reactor, For Fuel Freedom's algae and organisms triple the output: 2.7 times more than sugarcane, 3.4 more than corn, and 4.3 more than any other cellulosic technology.  That sounds like a good investment.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Printing Parts

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

BIND Biosciences

Lattice Power

Suntech

Novartis

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement