Energy

A Better Solar Collector

(Page 2 of 2)

  • Thursday, July 10, 2008
  • By Kevin Bullis

The researchers tested how much of the light emitted by the dye makes it to the edges of 10-centimeter squares of coated glass, the largest allowed by their laboratory equipment. Based on their measurements, they project that they can make solar concentrators large enough to bring down the costs of solar power to near that of conventional electricity, given expected reductions in the cost of solar cells. "We showed much bigger concentration factors than people had shown before," Baldo says.

The researchers also tested an inexpensive way to improve the efficiency of solar cells by capturing more of the energy in sunlight. Each wavelength of light, or color, has a different amount of energy. Infrared photons have the least energy, and ultraviolet photons have the most. Different types of semiconductor materials are best for different wavelengths. It's possible to build more than one type of solar cell into a single module, but this can be more expensive than it's worth.

The dye-coated glass sheets provide a cheap way to use more than one type of solar cell in a single solar module--one solar cell tuned to work with low-energy light, and the other to work with high-energy light. Two glass sheets are stacked. The top one absorbs high-energy light and channels it to a small solar cell matched to that light. The other captures lower-energy photons and channels those to another solar cell. Based on the researchers' initial results, Baldo says, "you can almost double the efficiency of your overall system if you do this."

The researchers still need to make bigger concentrators to test their predictions. They are also working to improve the quality of the dyes, including the range of colors that they can absorb. Baldo and his colleagues have founded a company--Covalent Solar, based in Cambridge, MA--to bring the technology to market within three years. Jerry Olson, an expert in solar concentrators at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, in Golden, CO, says that the work represents some "good steps forward." But, adds Olson, "time will tell if the projections come true."


Print

Related Articles

Solar Roofing Materials

Integrating solar cells into building materials could make solar power more attractive to homeowners.

Intensifying the Sun

A new way to concentrate sunlight could make solar power competitive with fossil fuels.

More-Efficient Solar Cells

A new solar panel could lower costs and improve efficiency.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

javs

97 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

A Barrier to this Potential Breakthrough

The electric power industry regulations have a strong barrier to the development of the resources of the demand side. For the better solar collector to be integrated to power system planning, operation and control a new market architecture and design is required to eliminate said barrier.

I am partially repeating what I said earlier. The article is a good contribution to TR readers about one of the most important kinds of uncertain generation... The EWPC article Uncertain Generation is Here to Stay takes the idea into the context of the Third Industrial Revolution. . . . . . . With regard to solar distributed generation, please read the EWPC article Nanosolar Breakthrough and the Old Paradigm. Research for scheduling and integrating ... solar power to power systems planning, operations and control, will be part of the next stages. . . . . . . To understand what to do first in the wider, and highly uncertain, legislative and regulatory context, TR readers should consider reading the EWPC article Leadership Answers What to do First, whose summary is "The answer to the question of what to do first is for the global power industry to get out of the wrong jungle to produce a EWPC based EPAct as soon as possible. That is the kind of leadership needed to face the inevitable fundamental changes required to significantly reduce today’s legislative and regulatory uncertainty."

Reply

nekote

139 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

Re: A Barrier to this Potential Breakthrough

EWPC: Electricity Without Price Controls
EPAct: Energy Policy Act

Reply

javs

97 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

Re: A Barrier to this Potential Breakthrough

Thanks.

Reply

mkogrady

425 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

Missed a point?

Forgive my ignorance -

Do these died plates of glass function as stand alone converters or do they work in concert with thin panel and polysilicon wafer systems too?

Can a fresnel lens increase their potential by focusing sunlight into a smaller area and increasing the energy onto a smaller plate surface? If yes can it be adapted to work off big desert tower installations or arrays?

In any case - let us know when the IPO is coming. I'll ante up some 401K funds!

Good job and very cool!

Reply

Globe99

28 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

Re: Missed a point?

You're absolutely right, this system does not do any of the actual "conversion" in the light-to-electricity sense. What they've developed is technology to channel the light to the edge of the plates, where you would then have your photovoltaic device. The trick is that you could filter off select parts of the spectrum and then channel them into PV's designed specifically to handle them.

Reply

johnalphonse

78 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

just wondering also...

this is really encouraging.  i believe mkogrady makes a valid point worth considering and i was thinking along the same lines myself.  if you can start a fire with a 50-cent magnifying glass, why is it so difficult to focus this awesome power onto something that won't catch fire yet will harness it?  like colored glass!  i mean the magnifying glass obviously multiplies the collective potential far greater than mirrors, and i believe it would be a good place to look for future experimentation within this model.  as mk suggests i also believe incorporating a layer of magnifying glass above these others, and combining this with the current movable array designs, would skyrocket efficiency and bring this to viability a lot sooner, which i'm sure we mostly agree we sure do need, like, yesterday.

additionally, mentioning the obvious may be worthwhile for those working in the field: nothing absorbs heat quite like the color black, which absorbs all wavelengths of light...

Reply

TragicComic

6 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

Re: just wondering also...

The problem with concentrating light via a magnifying glass, or Fresnel lens, is that you have to aim it at the sun in order to get the effect.

This means you need to have moving components, timers, etc. and can dramatically increase the cost of the device.

Essentially ou have a trade off between the cost of the PV material and the cost of the device to concentrate it.

Reply

Advertisement

mkogrady

425 Comments

  • 1310 Days Ago
  • 07/14/2008

Re: just wondering also...

Maybe a fresnel lens MADE of colored glass that actually filters and focuses only the spectrum you want!

Moving parts aside, it places more energy per pixel than send it to the edge of the glass itself.

Reply

Globe99

28 Comments

  • 1313 Days Ago
  • 07/11/2008

Photonic Technology

This has been a long time coming.... the concept of using basic photonic technologies such as waveguides (as in this example) or photonic crystals seems to have been lost on a lot of solar researchers. Over the years we've gotten much better at manipulating light on the micro and nanoscale using photonics and plasmonics respectively, however little of these ideas seem to have seeped into solar cell research.

It's really simple: (A) the vast majority of photovoltaic elements will NOT span the entire solar spectrum, so (B) why don't you make part of the cell a device (like a waveguide) to channel that color specifically into a PV optimized to handle it?

No, solar researchers would rather just throw everything into some structurally ill-defined soup and hope for the best. Well, kudos to these guys for bucking the trend. Expect in the future to see this optimized on the nanoscale using quantum dots and/or more advanced waveguide structures.

Reply

incm79

1 Comment

  • 1312 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2008

Re: Photonic Technology

Globe99: "This has been a long time coming.... the concept of using basic photonic technologies such as waveguides (as in this example) or photonic crystals seems to have been lost on a lot of solar researchers."

You might be interested in a project I was involved with back in the '80s and 90s that developed the concept for what we called the Lateral Aperture design. As far as I know it was the first design for a wave guide that integrated one side as a collection surface with the internal capture of radiant energy which could then be directed parallel to the surface to multiple edges if desired. This technology doesn't use dyes, and therefore has potential for other various applications besides solar, such as fiber optics, satellite dishes, etc.

Back then if you claimed to be able to capture solar energy within a flat sheet of glass and direct it to an edge you were considered crazy. Times and attitudes change and its nice to see Professor Baldo and other researchers can take non-traditional technology and ideas forward without being committed. There are some pages on the Lateral Aperture research at: http://research.atspace.org/index.html

Reply

mkogrady

425 Comments

  • 1310 Days Ago
  • 07/14/2008

Re: Photonic Technology

By waveguide - do you mean something like a fiber optic channel to contain and control the delivery of the light or energy?

Reply

Globe99

28 Comments

  • 1310 Days Ago
  • 07/14/2008

Re: Photonic Technology

Yes. The term "waveguide" refers to a broad class of materials, ranging from fiber optics to thin films of polymers (in this case) to nanostructured strips of metal on a dielectric. The purpose of all of these is to channel and transport light in certain defined directions.

wiki -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waveguide_%28optics%29

Reply

zig158

64 Comments

  • 1312 Days Ago
  • 07/12/2008

paradigm-shift that the solar field has needed

I agree with that this is the paradigm-shift that the solar field has needed. Modules like the one they describe would be so much more practical than the traditional panel.

Reply

Siphon

152 Comments

  • 1311 Days Ago
  • 07/13/2008

Issues

Very interesting approach.

Whether or not this will work will depend on key issues like:

- Durability; how do the dyes hold up over time?

- Cost; dyes are probably cheap but the entire module has to be cheap as well.

- Concentration factor; how many times can light be concentrated using this method? If it's really big (say 500x) then high efficiency exotic cells can be used, lowering total cost per Watt considerably. I suspect though, that the maximum achievable concentration will be much lower.

Also, I have a question: does this work with diffuse light as well as direct insulation? It looks like it does.

Reply

Advertisement

Kevin Bullis

178 Comments

  • 1310 Days Ago
  • 07/14/2008

Re: Issues

It does work with diffuse light, which is one of the main selling points. It's related to the fact that these systems don't require tracking mechanisms.

The best way to describe the concentration factor possible in this system is through something called "flux gain," which is equivalent to how much more power a solar cell produces when it's connected to the concentrator. The researchers project that 30 centimeter sheets can multiply the power by about 50.

Reply

Siphon

152 Comments

  • 1308 Days Ago
  • 07/16/2008

Re: Issues

Thanks. 50x isn't as high as I'd hoped. Uneconomical for GaAs multijunction. But more than good enough for high efficiency silicon technology. Sliver Cells maybe, if they hurry up with their production rate.

Reply

vv111y

8 Comments

  • 1294 Days Ago
  • 07/30/2008

Re: Issues

Has there been any discussion to use larger panels to get a larger multiple?
Is there any technical limitation where increasing the concentration/panel size provides diminishing returns?

This seems very exciting and it would be great to find any way to use the higher efficiency cells. Especially the GaAs cells at 40%.

What would it take to get GaAs cells cost effective?

Reply

briang1621

173 Comments

  • 1311 Days Ago
  • 07/13/2008

Power generating window and Skylights

I see this technology as being directly applicable to large window skylights.
Right now skylights come in all different type of shapes and sizes from small individual windows to large complex shapes covering huge indoor rooms. Most are tinted anyways. Even if adding this technology increase the price of the skylight by 20% to 100% that may still be acceptable to many home and business owners. Resorts, business, and homes in remote regions may especially find this attractive because of the high variable in electricity cost, but I don’t see this as replacing electricity, only as a supplement. Some people may find it attractive even if it only produced enough electricity to run a single fan.
I strongly think these researchers should license the manufacturing process for the special glass (or plastic) to anyone they can. They should also have a list of suppliers who can build the photovoltaic cells that go on the edges. The goal is to make the plastic easy to come by in any needed size, and let the larger photovoltaic industry take advantaged of the features of this special concentrator.
Also they could license the plastic material to plastic manufactures because I think they could sell it as a special material that may be used in special applications like clubs, bars, and so on.
   Thanks
Brian Glassman
www.TechRD.com
Commercialization
Innovation Management 

Here are some pictures of skylights
http://www.skylightwindows.net/skylightwindows.htm
http://www.majorskylights.com/technical/

Reply

shirtale2

3 Comments

  • 1310 Days Ago
  • 07/14/2008

A better solar collector

I don't see any mention on how to handle the heat generated, would this not require some kind of cooling system if the efficiency of the collector is multiplied X times?

Reply

Siphon

152 Comments

  • 1308 Days Ago
  • 07/16/2008

Re: A better solar collector

The collector essentially filters out unneeded wavelenghts, so there wouldn't be too much heat to deal with. A very low cost passive cooling device should do.

Reply

aldeseng

1 Comment

  • 1310 Days Ago
  • 07/14/2008

organic dyes as solar collectors

This concept was pioneered by Nobel prize winner Ahmed Zewail at Caltech in the late 1970's --about 1977 as I remember. I had the pleasure of working with him for several months in 1978, on another project. Fluorescing dyes were incorporated in plastic sheets (perhaps Plexiglas or Lucite).  The broad visible solar spectrum was absorbed by a mix of dyes that absorbed and fluoresced at lower frequencies, while the radiation was reflected to the edges of the pane of plastic.  Then the photovoltaic collector was attached to the edges of the pane.  So the system acted as a spectral and optical concentrator.  As I remember, it was turned over to the Jet Propulsion Laboratory to optimize the concept for architectural appeal as well as solar electric conversion efficiency.

Reply

Advertisement

vv111y

8 Comments

  • 1294 Days Ago
  • 07/30/2008

Estimated national yield

According to someones analysis, for say the US, you could potentially generate 3TWe from a very large solar farm in the SW desert.
link: http://www.ez2c.de/ml/solar_land_area/

He is assuming 8% efficiency. What kind of efficiency could we get using this technology, and thus what kind of potential yield with such an installation?

What am I missing with regards to the feasibility of such a scenario? 

Reply

vv111y

8 Comments

  • 1294 Days Ago
  • 07/30/2008

energy lost in the panels

I did not see any mention of the amount of energy that is lost by the dyes. What % of energy gets to the edge of the panels?

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Printing Parts

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Roche

Joule Unlimited

BIND Biosciences

HTC

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement