Energy

Power from Not-So-Hot Geothermal

This power system could make it feasible to generate cheap electricity from lukewarm geothermal sources.

  • Thursday, September 21, 2006
  • By Prachi Patel

A large share of the geothermal resources suitable for power generation--those with temperatures higher than 300 °F--are deep underground, beyond the reach of current technology. Lower-temperature resources, which are common across the United States, are generally used for heating, but could be a bountiful source of power as well, if researchers were able to find an economical way to convert them into electricity.

Engineers at the United Technologies Research Center (UTRC), a unit of United Technologies based in East Hartford, CT, say they have developed a low-cost system that can utilize low-temperature geothermal resources. The technology could be particularly useful in generating electricity from waste hot water generated at oil and gas wells.

The modular, 200-kilowatt power plant from UTRC can convert temperatures as low as 165 °F into electricity. The technology is similar to steam engines, except that steam or hot water vaporizes a hydrofluorocarbon refrigerant that drives the turbine. And the refrigerant has a lower boiling point than water. "It's hard to run a steam engine at 165 degrees [Fahrenheit]," says Bruce Biederman, who leads the project at UTRC. "The size of the equipment would be enormous and your turbine would be very poor in efficiency."

The UTRC power plant can be thought of as a reverse cooling system, and the new turbine is essentially a refrigerator compressor running backwards, Biederman says. Instead of using power to create a temperature difference, like a refrigerator does, it converts a temperature difference into electricity.

Advertisement

The company is now testing a unit at a remote hot springs resort 60 miles northeast of Fairbanks, Alaska. Biederman expects a commercial power plant to be ready by early next year, after they've tested the reliability of the demonstration system.

According to him, the system could utilize the large amount of hot water pumped out of the ground at oil and gas wells. In Texas alone, more than 12 billon barrels of water are produced from wells. Oil companies usually discard the waste water by re-injecting it into the earth; but they could use it to generate electricity. Biederman is planning to set up demonstration projects at oil and gas wells in Texas and Nevada next year.

This reverse cooling concept isn't new; but until now no one has made an efficient turbine at a reasonable cost, he says. UTRC has kept down costs by modifying refrigeration units that its sister company, Carrier Corp., makes, and using its production line in Charlotte, NC.

The system's small size also keeps costs down, and makes it more usable, says Maria Richards, who coordinates the geothermal laboratory at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. "The fact that it can fit on the back of a flatbed truck and be driven to a well site makes it much more convenient and less expensive," she says. "It's [like comparing] a mainframe computer and a laptop." And, as with other renewables, increasing fuel costs are spurring interest in geothermal power units, she adds.

Print

Related Articles

Using CO2 to Extract Geothermal Energy

Carbon dioxide captured from power plants could make geothermal energy more practical.

Cheaper Geothermal

Fluid extracts more heat out of low-temperature wells.

Prospecting for Power

Helium isotopes reveal hidden stores of geothermal energy.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

MarkShapiro

13 Comments

  • 1972 Days Ago
  • 09/21/2006

Another part of the solution

Add this great idea to the thousands of other forms of renewable energy sources, efficiency, and conservation.  Well thought out, good cost-controls, marketed right at the sweet spot with the biggest returns. 

A clean energy regime just got closer.

Reply

Hardheadjarhead

18 Comments

  • 1971 Days Ago
  • 09/22/2006

Re: Another part of the solution

Am I to understand "dry" wells that are used up could use this technology to produce electricity?  How far down does one have to go for it to be hot (165 degrees) for this to work?

Would it be practical to dig down for that purpose?

Reply

mkogrady

425 Comments

  • 1968 Days Ago
  • 09/25/2006

Low Heat Geothermal

By replacing the refridgerent with a higher temp gas, can a small scale unit for homes be developed so the unit gets mounted in an attic space where the heat builds up enough to get the widget running or does something like this require a heat source with a lot of density that continually drives the compressor unit?

Reply

ackprod

1 Comment

  • 1968 Days Ago
  • 09/25/2006

Re: Low Heat Geothermal

What about using focused sunlight to heat the system?

Reply

gadamson

1 Comment

  • 1967 Days Ago
  • 09/26/2006

Re: Low Heat Geothermal

great idea! put a radiator on the roof of your house working in reverse and capture all that solar heat!

Reply

prettger

1 Comment

  • 1954 Days Ago
  • 10/09/2006

Not new technology

ORMAT (www.ormat.com) in Israel and the US has been commercialy providing this technology for over 40 years for both high and low temepraure geothermal and waste heat sources.  They have over 600 MW of systems in long-tem operation.

Reply

scott712

2 Comments

  • 1837 Days Ago
  • 02/03/2007

Use Thermo-Siphons

Thermo-siphons (heat-pipes without wicks since the liquid water will fall back down the tube) can move heat much more efficiently from the ground to the surface.  The pressure inside is adjusted so that water vaporizes at a little below the temperature of the heat-source and condenses, releasing heat to the refrigerant-based system.  This way there is no cost for pumping water.

Reply

rabi1939

2 Comments

  • 1808 Days Ago
  • 03/04/2007

Re: Use Thermo-Siphons

We have many areas in India where the temp. is <100 C r n padhi

Reply

rabi1939

2 Comments

  • 282 Days Ago
  • 05/08/2011

Re: Use Thermo-Siphons

till date India doesnot gererate any power from geothermal resource.Neither the govt. nor any private party is interested nor any foreign investor in spite great potential.Why?

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Printing Parts

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Roche

Joule Unlimited

Crowdcast

Novomer

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement