Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement
« Back 1 2 [3]

Friday, January 26, 2007

Smaller Is Better, Say Makers of Ultraportable PCs

Continued from page 2

By Wade Roush

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

The first group of UMPCs shipped with a plain Windows Tablet PC operating system. But at the Consumer Electronics Show, the company introduced the Origami Experience, a new user interface for Vista-based UMPCs that does away with the traditional desktop environment in favor of a single menu that scrolls both horizontally and vertically, letting users navigate quickly to their media files without a stylus or keyboard. Reviewers are calling the Origami Experience "speedy," "intuitive," "helpful," and "sexy"--terms not often associated with Windows devices. This suggests that the UMPC may have a shot at attracting the same kinds of consumers who shell out for the indisputably sexy Apple iPod.

At OQO, Rosin and Whang say they're not worried about going up against the UMPCs. "We see the OQO 02 as a productivity tool," says Rosin. "The businessperson may want to have some personal stuff on their mobile PC, but our focus is really on the professional user, not on the teenager on the couch wanting to browse the Web with a tablet-type device."

Nor is OQO concerned about Apple's forthcoming iPhone, which is descended from the video iPod but will mimic many of the functions of a full PC, via an advanced touch-screen interface that early reviewers have greeted as potentially revolutionary. "The iPhone is probably the best thing that's ever happened to us," says Rosin. "Everyone is now thinking, 'We need more than just voice on a cell phone,' and 'We need more than just audio on small devices.' So there's a lot of interest in this category, and we think that's a good thing for OQO."

The OQO 02 and the other small PCs hitting the market this year do have a few common weaknesses. One is battery life. It's getting longer--four hours in the case of the OQO 02 and three hours for the Samsung Q1--but it's still not long enough to keep a businessperson busy for the duration of a transcontinental flight. OQO's devices and the UMPCs "need a minimum of 8 hours of battery life to succeed," writes Tim Bajarin, president of Creative Strategies, a technology consulting firm based in Campbell, CA.

And the screens and keyboards on the new devices, while improving, are still impractically small for some users, especially older users with less-than-perfect vision or dexterity. "My 28-year-old son can use the OQO 02 just fine," Bajarin says. "But for old guys like me with bad eyes and fat thumbs, it's really tough."

But Bajarin's biggest concern relates to manufacturers' marketing strategy rather than to mechanics. He believes consumers will start buying ultraportable PCs only when they're shown to have a compelling application--say, browsing the Web and controlling the TV, set-top box, DVR, and stereo system from the sofa. But as long as ultraportable PCs are marketed as general-purpose devices, software writers won't be inspired to write the killer app that makes the devices take off, he argues.

"With a device of this size, if you take the PC mentality and say, 'Let it be all things to all people,' it will fail," Bajarin says. "But if you say, 'It's a platform for application-specific solutions,' then you're more likely to get it right."

Enderle, however, believes PCs could find a market even without further tweaking or new software. With its faster processor and full Windows capability, OQO's device, in particular, could appeal to "folks for whom a smart phone isn't really enough and a laptop is too much," he says. "That's still a niche group--but it could be a pretty good-sized niche."

« Back 1 2 [3]

Comments

  • The incredible Cellular Phone + WindowsXP Computer
    Gaetano Marano on 01/26/2007 at 10:38 AM
    Posts:
    71
    Avg Rating:
    2/5
    .
    .

    I've found a (much smaller than OQO and Q1) advanced Cellular Phone + full performance WindowsXP Computer, all in a small 143 x 92 x 30 mm, 560 g. case!

    List of features and image here: www.gaetanomarano.it/news/001samsung.html

    .
    .
    Rate this comment: 12345
  • the Ultraportable PC
    ecelyot on 01/26/2007 at 5:17 PM
    Posts:
    2
    Just read the piece and thought of the new iPhone.

    if the iPhone does what Jobs and Apple state it will then OQO isn't even in the ball park.

    It is instructive that OQO 1.0 did not rock too many worlds; perhaps because the market is too small?

    Listen to my Music, watch movies, phone everyone and surf the web and do my work too.

    Can OQO do that for $600 plus tax? Seems a hard act for OQO to follow.
    Rate this comment: 12345
    • Re: the Ultraportable PC
      gabrielg01 on 01/26/2007 at 7:13 PM
      Posts:
      314
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
      OQO runs Vista, and it can do anything a computer can do, except hardcore gaming. Did you actually read the article?

      The iPhone is just another overhyped, candy-colored yesterday's device for the iFools. A cell phone without 3G is not a latest generation machine.
      Rate this comment: 12345
  • i like my oqo model 01
    bshanks on 01/29/2007 at 9:15 PM
    Posts:
    3
    I have an OQO model 01 and I like it. I usually keep it in my pocket and I use it frequently to write down notes to myself (books or journal articles suggested by friends, phone numbers, to-do items). I also take it to class and use it to take notes. Sometimes I use it to connect to the wireless internet from various locations. I have a regular laptop, but I never take it out of my apartment anymore; the regular laptop just sits on my desk in my room, and sometimes on the dinner table. It's nice not to lug around a laptop, and equally nice to have a place to write a note or book suggestion at a time when you wouldn't have brought a laptop (say, while out to dinner with another grad student if we talk about our research) (yes, napkins and pads of paper exist, but when I used to do that, I found that I lost all of the notes).

    As a test of its usability, I took the OQO to a wiki conference in place of a laptop and it did the trick. It's the only thing that I know of that fits in your pocket, has a keyboard, and can run standard Debian GNU/Linux without undue hassle.

    The article claims the OQO 01 had a number of problems, but they weren't problems for me. It's significantly slower than today's laptops, but my other laptop (other than the oqo) is 5 years old, so the OQO was actually a slight step up for me. The limited battery life is ameliorated by the small size and light weight of the batteries; I just carry a spare battery with me in my pocket next to the OQO. One of my few complaints about the 01 was that the keyboard was not backlit.

    So, I expect that OQO 02 will be great, too. My only fear is that the increase in size will make it that much less suitable to fit in one's pocket.

    My plan is to buy an OQO every other computer (with normal laptops interspersed in case I ever want to do heavy-duty number crunching or run games).

    However, I am a niche market. I suspect that computer nerds like me will all acquire UMPCs once they get cheaper. I suspect that other people won't buy them until we have computer screens in our sunglasses and air keyboards (at which point the GPS and location-based social networking and IM will become killer apps).
    Rate this comment: 12345
Advertisement

Current Issue

Technology Review November/December 2008
Sun + Water = Fuel
An MIT chemist has opened the way to making hydrogen fuel from water using sunlight.
•  Subscribe
Save 41%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News

Magazine Services

Career Resources

MIT Technology Insider

Stories and breaking news from inside MIT about the latest research, innovations, and startups--in a convenient monthly e-newsletter. Subscribe today

Follow us on Twitter

Twitter

Get Technology Review updates via the web, cellphone, or Instant Messager – Follow techreview on Twitter!

Advertisement

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
Advertisement
TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology