Computing

DRM Under Siege: The Yahoo Music Experiment

Jessica Simpson's DRM-free single could be the beginning of the end for copy-protected digital music.

  • Thursday, July 27, 2006
  • By Wade Roush

There's something noteworthy about the digital download version of "A Public Affair," the latest single from pop star Jessica Simpson.

No, it's not that the song can be personalized: Simpson and her backup singers actually recorded 500 first names, from Adriana to Zachary, that Yahoo Music will electronically insert at a dramatic moment in the music for $1.99 a pop.

Far more significant is another feature of the song: it is being distributed as a standard MP3 file, with no digital rights management (DRM) technology. And this offering comes from none other than Sony BMG, the record label that has taken the most extreme measures to keep customers from making digital copies of its songs (see "Inside the Spyware Scandal").

Until now, essentially all the legally purchased and downloaded music from the four major record labels, Sony BMG, EMI, Warner, and Universal, has been offered in formats designed to make copying and sharing difficult. Apple's iTunes Music Store -- the source of more than 70 percent of all commercial music downloads -- limits customers to playing its songs on their iPods or up to five "authorized" PCs.

Advertisement

But because it's being released in the most universal audio format, Simpson's song, which debuted on July 19 at Yahoo Music and goes on sale at other digital music retailers this week, can be copied and played on an unlimited number of devices, including the iPod. (Posting such digital files on file-sharing networks for anyone to copy is still illegal.)

Of course it's only one song out of millions available at Yahoo Music, iTunes, and other online music stores. But music-industry watchers are interpreting this promotional offer as an important experiment -- one that may foreshadow a wider loosening of the major labels' restrictive policies.

"This is a sign that the enthusiasm for DRM is beginning to wane in the music industry," says Fred von Lohmann, a senior staff attorney and intellectual-property expert at the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) in San Francisco. "I certainly don't expect DRM to disappear overnight. But I would not be surprised if you saw specific genres or subsidiaries of the major labels experimenting with more unprotected MP3s."

Print

Related Articles

It's Gamers vs. Game Companies

Companies struggle to balance copyright technologies with players' interests.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

Guest (Amulek)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

They're totally different markets

eMusic's customers are mostly indie and classical lovers. These are the kind of people who want to support their artists. They are totally different from the teenyboppers who would pirate mainstream pop. The examples of eMusic are totally inapplicable to pop.

Reply

Guest (Teejay)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

unprotected = asking for trouble

what is likely to happen is one person downloading a legal version and then 1000's of people leeching of that. Piracy is not easy to stop and its solution in the future will most likely be technical rather than legal. DRM is something that had actually worked.

Reply

Guest (shegeek)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

music companies bring it on themselves

By over-pricing CDs. It costs about 3 - 5 cents to press a CD, add a jewel case, paper insert and other costs, including the seller's profit and a CD should cost around $7. Why are they priced twice that much or more? One word: Greed.

Reply

Guest (Greg)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

DRM doesnt work

No it doesn't work. The solution is not technical.

Reply

Guest (clgoh)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

DRM does not prevent that...

This is no different than a person buying a legal version on CD, ripping it and then 1000's of people leeching that.

Reply

Guest (Scott)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

Worked??

How can you say something like this "worked"??  Even iTunes allows a user to burn a CD... you can then rip that CD to any sort of unprotected MP3 format you like.  How does that "work"?

Reply

Guest (Edward Lawford)

  • 2028 Days Ago
  • 07/28/2006

DRM worked??

"what is likely to happen is one person downloading a legal version and then 1000's of people leeching of that."

My question is: if DRM is so important to stopping piracy, why do they still sell Compact Discs?

The thing about piracy is that it only takes ONE COPY of the song to be obtained in DRM-free format (ie. from a CD) to make the whole exercise a complete waste of time.

I think the record companies are waking up to this and realising that if you make music instantly available, DRM-free, plays anywhere at a reasonable price, people will be less inclined to pirate it in the first place.

You will never stamp out piracy completely but as long we have CDs, piracy will be dead simple so people will continue to do it.

The idea is to make it almost as easy to buy the music legitimately.

Reply

Advertisement

Guest (Mark)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

DRM will be irrelevant

Its only a matter of time before someone cracks the DRM for Itunes or WMA files and then they'll be free to use on whatever players we like without limit.  The only reason I can choose to stream my video at home is because someone cracked the DRM to allow me to extract my property from DVD to a different format.  Do I now upload it?  No.  I just use it the way I want to.

Reply

Guest (Scott)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

No need to "crack" DRM iTunes

Just burn a CD from your album or song download from iTunes, then rip to unprotected MP3.

Not a very difficult "crack".

Reply

Guest (Nils)

  • 2017 Days Ago
  • 08/08/2006

Not a real "crack"

music on iTunes is compressed into a lossy format, so burning a CD from it results in a lower-quality compared to the original CD. Then ripping to MP3 reduces the quality further. Some people can hear the difference between an original CD track and 128k MP3 - you will *definitely* hear the difference if you burn it to a CD and then re-rip. It will sound pretty bad - like an AM radio.

Reply

Guest (Firozali A.Mulla)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

DRAM

Now we are entering the age og the MagneticRam that is better then the DRAM. This will be in the market in 2006 silicon-on-insulator (SOI)

Reply

Guest (Ronnie)

  • 2029 Days Ago
  • 07/27/2006

Free the music

Last year there was a grammy won in a Jazz catagory that was recorded promoted and sold all with out a lable by the artist on the internet.If the big 3 do not step away from DRM and free the music. The listening public will do it for them simply by not listening. The choices for free independant music are growing. With recording equipment getting cheaper, better and easier to use more artists are taking it to the net. Now if we can just keep the internet "Tubes" from getting blocked!

Reply

Guest (Rolo Tomasi)

  • 2019 Days Ago
  • 08/06/2006

"Free" is too easy & tempting.

You can get any music on the net. Free. It aint legal but it's free. DRM trys to fight it and has SMALL success. The best minds in the industry can't come up with a viable solution and the band keeps on playing.

The latest chapter has State courts assuming juridiction nationwide. Due proccess and fair trial take a backseat to easy & cheap.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Sponsored Content

Technologies from National Instruments

Adding Data Logging
Log measured data to a file and open it in Microsoft Excel

> Click here for more National Instruments Videos <
Whitepaper

Temperature Measurements with Thermocouples: How-To Guide

This document is part of the “How-To Guide for Most Common Measurements” centralized resource portal. This tutorial provides a detailed guide for measurement and device considerations to take temperature measurements using thermocouples. Get an introduction to thermocouples, which are inexpensive sensing devices widely used with PC-based data acquisition systems. Also review some specific thermocouple examples and learn how thermocouples work and ways to integrate them into a data acquisition measurement system.

View full PDF > Listen to story >
Find us on Youtube

Videos

A Robot Recruit that Can Do It All

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Pacific Biosciences

Complete Genomics

Claros Diagnostics

PrimeSense

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement