Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Space Shuttle Science

Continued from page 1

By Richard A. Muller

February 10, 2003

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

There is another major misconception that NASA has more actively spread, perhaps because many in the agency have convinced themselves that it is really true. Here it is: the primary goal of the Space Shuttle is the advancement of scientific knowledge. Most scientists roll their eyes when they hear this claim.

Don't misinterpret what I say: there is good, even great science launched into space on the Shuttle. Results from the Hubble Space Telescope excite physicists and astronomers as much as the general public.  But a case can be made that Hubble could have been launched at a lower cost by non-reusable rockets. The United States military prefer to launch their spy satellites-close cousins of the space telescopes-with unmanned vehicles. Such satellites don't have to be man-qualified, that is, they don't require the extra engineering costs to make them absolutely safe to be in space alongside humans.

True, Hubble was defective, and required repair by Shuttle astronauts. But the military loses its spy telescopes too, and its response is to launch a replacement. Launching two completely new Hubble telescopes--the original and a replacement, with neither qualified for human servicing (and therefore cheaper)-- would arguably have been less expensive in the long run.

When it comes to the science itself, the Space Shuttle is a poor choice of platforms. Humans are a source of noise-vibrational, infrared, gravitational. Sensitive experiments must get away from this. Just flying an experiment on a manned mission automatically raises the experiment's costs. Many scientists moan privately about scientific missions that were delayed and made more costly because they were moved off unmanned launch vehicles and forced to become part of NASA's scientific justification for the Shuttle.

Hubble aside, what would you name as the really glorious achievements of NASA in the last 20 years? My favorite: the discovery that every moon of every planet is significantly different from every other moon, a result completely unanticipated and still not understood. One might also pick the amazing success of weather satellites. Or the remarkable pictures you get from your satellite TV system. Those in the know might pick our space spy systems. Then there's GPS-the Global Positioning System, used to guide airplanes, boats, hikers, automobiles as well as soldiers and smart weapons. These projects have one thing in common: they were all unmanned.

Comments

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Laser-Triggered Chemical Reactions
Featured Content
Sponsored by:
White Papers

Twelve ways to reduce costs with SQL Server 2008
Find out how to reduce costs and get more efficient

Download

Total Economic Impact of SQL Server 2008 Upgrade
Forrester reports on increasing productivity and management capabilities

Download 

Achieving Cost and Resource Savings with UC
How Office Communications Server R2 and Exchange Server can make your business smarter and more efficient

Download 

The Compelling Case for Conferencing
Read how you can improve workload support and find IT efficiencies

Download

How Windows Server 2008 R2 Helps Optimize IT and Save you Money
Read how you can improve workload support and find IT efficiencies

Download

Windows Server 2008 R2 Hyper-V Live Migration
See how Windows Server 2008 R2 and Hyper-V enable virtualization and Live Migration

Download
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.