Technology Review

Communications

Review: Nexus One and Android 2.1

Google's first phone is a superfast, elegant device with a few privacy problems.

  • Friday, February 12, 2010
  • By Simson Garfinkel

Google's Nexus One is an astonishingly fast phone. Use it for more than a few minutes and you'll see that much of the slowness we've learned to associate with smart phones is not the fault of the network but of the phones themselves--specifically, their processors.

Today's 3G networks can deliver data to your phone faster than the broadband connections that many people have in their homes: a laptop equipped with one of those USB modems from AT&T or Verizon functions splendidly. Yet most smart phones take several seconds to click between Web pages or launch a new application. That's because the typesetting and image processing necessary to turn the text of a Web page into something that can be displayed on a screen takes a lot of computation. And most phones have comparatively slow processors--in many cases, they are no faster than a Pentium 3 from 10 years ago.

The Nexus One, by contrast, has a one-gigahertz processor--more than 60 percent faster than the processors in the iPhone 3GS, Palm Pre, and BlackBerry Bold 9700, according to several benchmarks. In my testing, it took 2.5 seconds, on average, to click from one Wikipedia page to the next using T-Mobile's 3G network--and half that long when using a Wi-Fi connection. You can open applications, zoom in on photos, and search your phone's databases instantly. The faster processor dramatically improves the phone's enjoyability.

The Nexus One also has a beautiful high-resolution screen--800 by 480 pixels crammed into 3.7 diagonal inches for a display that's roughly 250 dots per inch, making even tiny text quite legible. (Apple's new iPad, in comparison, is 1,024 by 768 pixels on a screen that's 9.7 inches, for just 132 dots per inch.) The Nexus's five-megapixel camera can autofocus and takes detailed photos at six centimeters, and it has a surprisingly bright LED flash. The phone also has a standard 3.5-millimeter headphone jack, which means you don't need those bulky adapters to use high-end earbuds.

Advertisement

Google's phone runs an updated version of the company's Android operating system, the same software that's at the heart of Motorola's new Cliq and Droid phones, T-Mobile's G1 (a.k.a the HTC Dream), and even the Barnes and Noble Nook e-book reader. But unlike the others, the Nexus One runs Android 2.1, the latest and greatest version (of course). Droid runs 2.0, although it's scheduled for an update, while the G1 is still running Android 1.6.

Android has been on the market for nearly 18 months, and this new version has a significantly improved user interface that requires fewer button presses for the same functions. For example, when you are in the middle of a phone call, you can now use buttons on the screen to add a call, display the dial pad, switch to and from a Bluetooth headset, mute, and control the built-in speakerphone (on the G1, these features all require clicking the Menu button). The screens also show more information. For example, a photo of the person you're speaking with is displayed in the middle of screen; put that person on hold to take another call, and the first caller's photo appears behind the second photo.

Photos appear more often than you might expect, thanks to the close integration between the Android and Facebook. Type your Facebook username and password into the phone's Facebook application and the phone's Contacts (the address book) will immediately be populated with the names, phone numbers, photos, and even status updates of your Facebook friends. You can decide whether you want to have the phone augment existing contacts with the Facebook information, bring all of your Facebook contacts into the phone's contact list, or remove all of the Facebook data from that list. It's creepy, sure, but also kind of useful.

Print

Related Articles

An Early Look at Faster Cell-Phone Speeds

HTC releases the first phone with a connection faster than 3G--but the company will face stiff competition soon enough.

Review: Google's In-Car Navigation

It features live traffic data and easy-to-use directions--but also has design flaws that betray a "beta" status.

How Android Security Stacks Up

An Android phone's approach to security is radically different from an iPhone's--but is it better?

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

branon

1 Comment

  • 733 Days Ago
  • 02/12/2010

Repurchasing Apps

Excellent review. Just to clarify, one does not need to "repurchase" apps. One only needs to reinstall them if you purchased them earlier. And once you log on to your new device within a short period, the market lists the apps that you have purchased with any previous devices- so you dont have to go looking for them. Unfortunately "free" apps installed in earlier devices are not listed. However, I think there is an app for that too!

Reply

ksukumar

2 Comments

  • 733 Days Ago
  • 02/12/2010

Correction and notes

I've had a Nexus One since a few days after launch - and I find that I have never been as consistently happy with a phone (smart or otherwise) as I have been with this one.  That being said, what makes me happy is NOT the idea that what the phone is doing is at all cutting edge, or revolutionary.  Instead I find the experience or using it easy, smooth, and refined - with more that enough room (and capacity) for customization to satisfy my need to tinker.

1.  The Nexus one DOES allow the user to set screen sleep time, which, in turn, sets the time span before the screen locks.

2.  An app called "WaveSecure" ( http://www.wavesecure.com/ )allows the other functionality (backup, remote lock/wipe, tracking) - and if you sign up before March 31, it's absolutely free.

And a final note - the "draw pattern to unlock" functionality is a feature of Android, not the Nexus One specifically - users of the G1 had the same functionality.

Reply

jameskatt

3 Comments

  • 732 Days Ago
  • 02/13/2010

So backup  will COST MONEY

So you are saying that backing up your entire system for the Nexus One and Android is going to cost you extra money.  Ahem.

Reply

ksukumar

2 Comments

  • 731 Days Ago
  • 02/14/2010

Re: So backup  will COST MONEY

No, what I'm saying is that there is an app that will allow for that, which at this point is free.  What I did not say is that there are a dozen other apps that allow the same functionality - I've just found WaveSecure to be the most convenient one.

Nice chain of assumptions you followed there, though.

Reply

enantiomer2000

66 Comments

  • 733 Days Ago
  • 02/12/2010

Love my G1

Was tempted by the Nexus One, but think will wait for something with Tegra 2 in it.  Tegra...

Reply

turveysp

1 Comment

  • 733 Days Ago
  • 02/12/2010

Smartphone miscounting

Another publication failing to take into account the fact that the rest of the world has smartphones too!

The Comscore figures are for the US market but the failure to acknowledge this causes your article to imply that this a global measure. Nokia's Symbian-based devices still have a clear market share lead on a global basis.

Further on you say that the "world's best handheld map application" is only available on Android. Well, it's subjective of course but I would encourage you to look at Nokia Maps with free near-global navigation capability and the ability to work offline.

So, I'm not picking sides; the Nexus One is a fine device. I'd just expect a bit more rigour from MIT.

Disclosure: I am employed by Nokia and these views are solely my own and not representative of those of my employer.

Reply

eNonsense

1 Comment

  • 733 Days Ago
  • 02/12/2010

Correction

Good articale.  A Quick correction to add to what ksukumar said.

You do not have to re-purchase apps when wiping or upgrading phones.  Purchased apps are linked to your google account and only need to be re-downloaded.  When you visit the android market and go into the downloads section it will list all previously purchased apps at the top and not require any payment to download again.

Reply

jameskatt

3 Comments

  • 732 Days Ago
  • 02/13/2010

Except for the free apps

Except for the free apps - which make up over 60% of the Google Marketplace.  You will have to manually reinstall each and every one of them.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Amyris

Silver Spring Networks

Serious Materials

Novartis

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement