Free space?: This ultrasonic range finder, stuck to a car door with magnets, is the basis of a prototype system developed at Rutgers University for monitoring street parking.
Rutgers University

Communications

Finding a Parking Space Could Soon Get Easier

Networking sensors attached to taxis could ease the hunt for street parking.

  • Monday, February 8, 2010
  • By Erika Jonietz

Anyone who's driven in a crowded downtown knows that parking can mean almost endless circling in the hunt for a space close to your destination. Now engineers at Rutgers University in New Jersey have combined simple ultrasonic sensors, GPS receivers, and cellular data networks to create a low-cost, highly effective way to find the nearest available parking space.

The Rutgers researchers say that making detailed parking data widely available via Web-based maps or navigation systems could alleviate traffic congestion by allowing travelers to decide whether to park in a central garage, hunt for street parking, or choose another mode of transportation in advance. If drivers choose street parking, it could help by suggesting parking spaces to users through a navigation device or cell phone.

The team, led by assistant professors Marco Gruteser and Wade Trappe, mounted ultrasonic distance sensors on the passenger-side doors of three cars. Using data collected over two months as the drivers commuted through Highland Park, NJ, the researchers developed an algorithm that translated the ultrasound distance readings into a count of available parking spaces that was 95 percent accurate. By combining this with GPS data, they also generated maps of which spaces were occupied and which were open that were over 90 percent accurate.

Traffic congestion is a huge problem nationwide, particularly in downtown areas. A study by Transportation Alternatives, a New York City transportation advocacy group, found that up to 45 percent of the traffic in Manhattan is generated by cars circling the block looking for parking. In 2006, Donald Shoup, a professor in the department of urban planning at the University of California, Los Angeles, calculated that, over the course of a year, vehicles looking for parking in one small business district of Los Angeles burned 47,000 gallons of gasoline and produced 730 tons of carbon dioxide. The problem is so serious that some cities, such as San Francisco, have invested millions of dollars in "smart parking infrastructure"--systems that detect the presence of vehicles in parking spots using fixed sensors installed into the asphalt or in parking meters.

Advertisement

But such systems work only for metered or slotted parking spaces. They also have large installation and operating costs. The SFpark project in San Francisco covers 6,000 spaces--only about 25 percent of available street parking spots. At an estimated cost of $500 to install and maintain each sensor for a year, that adds up to $3 million. The Rutgers team set out to create a lower-cost alternative that can work for both metered and unslotted parking spaces.

The engineers devised a prototype of a sensing platform using a $20 ultrasonic sensor that reports the distance to the nearest obstacle and a $100 GPS receiver that notes the corresponding location. They connected both to a lightweight PC with a Wi-Fi card to transmit the data to a central server.

The algorithm that the researchers devised bases the detection of parked vehicles on dips in the ultrasonic sensor readings. To distinguish parked cars from other, smaller obstacles in the sensor's path--for instance, trees, recycling bins, or people--they compared the width and depth of each dip with thresholds determined from a round of training data in which the engineers marked each sensor dip as a car or another object. They then developed filters that remove all dips that have a depth of less than the threshold that the algorithm "learned" from the training data. For slotted parking spaces, the algorithm had a detection accuracy of about 95 percent. For unslotted parking, they achieved about 96 percent accuracy.

Print

Related Articles

Tracking Traffic with Cell Phones

A new project collects traffic data from GPS-enabled cell phones.

Find a Parking Space Online

Street-embedded sensors monitor parking availability.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

carlhage

84 Comments

  • 726 Days Ago
  • 02/08/2010

Webcams

Why not just put a cheap webcam and grid-networked microprocessor on a lightpole or garage ceiling? Image analysis software only need be smart enough to distinguish an occupied vs free space. Then only 1 sensor per block or parking aisle would be required, not one per stall, or one per car passing by. I thought of this and really wanted one while frustrated driving around an IKEA parking lot trying to find a space. Parking cameras could also do double duty as security cameras, deterring breakins. [I suppose this could be a negative.]

While the project is interesting, also as a social networking application, it seems inefficient and expensive. Much of SFPark is similar to the London demand-based billing, so the price changes depending on congestion. But adding a $500 sensor per parking meter doesn't seem like a good use of public funds (or a reason to increase parking rates).

Many parking garages have magnetic counters on the in and out passages and between floors and calculate free spaces. Some cities have displays on road signs showing availability on approaching downtown and near garages.

Reply

Cyruscosmo

7 Comments

  • 725 Days Ago
  • 02/09/2010

Parking Complaints are Funny

I have worked in the greater downtown area of Seattle for almost 16 years now and a couple points come to mind after reading this article. After working in the area for only a few weeks I began to wonder if the city planners were simply blind or stupid. They have absolute control over what gets built and where yet they will issue a permit to build a structure that will accommodate say five thousand people and then NOT "require" included parking for the projected workers/customers of that structure.

Where are they supposed to park?

The same goes for those little "Compartment" buildings popping up all over town. You know… the eight separate family units they put on a lot that a single house barely fit on in the first place. They usually have one spot per unit and I say spot with a smile because unless you own a Mini you will not get that average car in it. And what about the kids cars or visitors? Now there are eight or nine extra vehicles looking for the one or two spots out front.

Where are the rest going to park?

I still have not found any reason to come to Downtown Seattle. They have nothing here that can't be found easier somewhere else.

I'm a bit biased anyway as I see nothing interesting or special let alone "beautiful" in the concrete, steel and glass monoliths screwing up the skyline and the view of the mountains. Am I a "Tree Hugger" not really I just don't see the point in trying to get hundreds of thousands of people into a square mile of real-estate and find it funny that people will do so and then complain.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Square

Toyota

Amyris

eSolar

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement