Communications

Jeff Hawkins Q&A

(Page 2 of 2)

  • October 13, 2005
  • By Technology Review

JP: Is the higher consciousness -- what philosophers sometimes call "self-consciousness" -- a byproduct of HTM?

JH: Yes. I think I understand what consciousness is now. There are two elements to consciousness. First, there is the element of consciousness where we can say, "I am here now." This is akin to a declarative memory where you can actively recall doing something. Riding a bike cannot be recalled by declarative memory, because I can't remember how I balanced on a bike. But if I ask, "Am I talking to Jason?" I can answer "Yes." So I like to propose a thought experiment: if I erase declarative memory, what happens to consciousness?" I think it vanishes.

But there is another element to consciousness: what philosophers and neuroscientists call "qualia:" the feeling of being alive. Qualia mean different things to different people, but the way I like to think about them is to ask, "Why does anything feel like anything?" And I think I understand this a little, too. Qualia have to do with the world itself: I perceive the world in a certain way because that's the way the world really is.

JP: Is a dolphin conscious?

JH: They've got a very highly developed neocortex. I bet they are. The only difference between you and me and dolphins is that they have a very limited motor cortex. They can reason; but they can't control motor behavior. Imagine! Their perceptual world is probably very rich. But they can't communicate those perceptions to each other. They have no real language, just songs from deep inside their reptile brain. It's like they have a robotic body. All they can do is fin through the sea.

JP: Why would Numenta want to build an HTM? After all, there are already billions and billions of human HTMs. We can make billions more from sexual intercourse.

JH: [Laughs.] Well, we wouldn't use artificial HTMs to do things that humans can already do. But an artificial HTM could do things that humans can't. We could use them to recognize patterns using exotic sensors. Maybe I could use weather sensors all around the world, and if I fed them into an HTM, it would perceive the weather like you and I perceive that building. HTMs could think in the higher mathematical dimensions or they could see how proteins fold. You could create an entire sensory world of things that humans just have problems seeing and predicting because we just didn't evolve in the right time-frames or scales. People say, "Jeff you shouldn't talk about stuff, because people will think you're crazy," but I say, I think this stuff is really going to happen.

More in Communications

Buying the Song

Read More »
Print

Related Articles

Outward Bound for Robots

A new approach teaches objects how to navigate unfamiliar territory as humans might.

Big Brain Thinking

Stanford neuroscientist Bill Newsome wants to implant an electrode in his brain to better understand human consciousness.

Palm's Life Line

What can Palm's tumultuous history tell us about the future of the mobile device market?

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

Guest (DanS)

  • 2261 Days Ago
  • 12/07/2005

HTM

Having read the book _On Intelligence_, I am anxiously awaiting the movie (a product based on Numentas research). I believe the scientific community is resistant to theories originating from outside the community, usually for good reason - but in this case, the theory, as I understand it from the book, is the first that integrates consciousness, memory and perception fits the physiology of the neurons arrangement in the neocortex and is also (relatively) simple. Like E=mc2, thats a good sign! (If it were too complicated, it would not be so successful, in my opinion. It also partially answers the argument that evolution operates too slowly to have evolved the neocortex.) The possibilities Jeff Hawkins outlines for sensing artificially at different scales and time-frames are really exciting. (Of course, I dont get out much.)

Reply

jorge.chapiro

1 Comment

  • 1956 Days Ago
  • 10/08/2006

Re: HTM

My focus of interest is the logic of structure of social system and I have worked in very different cultures (1960 onwards) using as a background metaphore the logic of the structure of the human neurophisiologic system.

Jeff Hawkins "On Intelligence" and his view of the role of the talamus stimulated me to start thinking all over again.

Jeff´s theoretical approach is not only intellectually captivating, but emotionally stimulating.

Reply

Guest (DanS)

  • 2261 Days Ago
  • 12/07/2005

HTM

Having read the book _On Intelligence_, I am anxiously awaiting the movie (a product based on Numentas research). I believe the scientific community is resistant to theories originating from outside the community, usually for good reason - but in this case, the theory, as I understand it from the book, is the first that integrates consciousness, memory and perception fits the physiology of the neurons arrangement in the neocortex and is also (relatively) simple. Like E=mc2, thats a good sign! (If it were too complicated, it would not be so successful, in my opinion. It also partially answers the argument that evolution operates too slowly to have evolved the neocortex.) The possibilities Jeff Hawkins outlines for sensing artificially at different scales and time-frames are really exciting. (Of course, I dont get out much.)

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Synthetic Genomics

Silver Spring Networks

Nissan

Siemens

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement