Building solar: An array of solar panels serves as the façade of Suntech Power Holdings’s headquarters in Wuxi, China.
Technology Review

Business

Suntech Stresses R&D

China's solar giant shifts its strategy.

  • Friday, April 9, 2010
  • By Kevin Bullis in Shanghai

The solar industry is entering a new era in which investment in R&D--and the new technologies it produces--will be crucial for solar companies to survive, says Stuart Wenham, the chief technology officer of Suntech Power Holdings, based in Wuxi, China, one of the largest solar panel manufacturers in the world. But don't expect radical changes to solar panels, at least for the next several years, he says. The best new technologies will be those that can easily be integrated into existing production lines and work with existing suppliers.

The solar-power market is undergoing radical reorganization. Countries such as Germany and Spain are scaling back solar incentives even as other countries, such as the United States and China, are implementing new ones. In the next few years, the United States and China are expected to become the largest markets for solar panels. Suntech, for one, is well positioned for the new markets, as one of few Chinese companies that have established themselves in the U.S., says Sam Jaffe, an analyst with IDC Energy Insights, in Framingham, MA. The solar market, which has been doubling every couple of years, exists today almost completely as a result of government incentives such as "feed-in tariffs" that guarantee that solar power can be sold for high prices. These incentives, put in place during the past decade, caused demand to ramp up quickly, too fast for suppliers of the high-grade silicon needed for most solar panels to keep up. But now a big increase in the number of silicon suppliers, paired with the economic downturn, has helped balance supply and demand.

"The industry was getting into a situation two years ago that was getting to be a little unhealthy," Wenham says. "The demand was so much higher than the supply that it was possible for people to enter the industry, and enter manufacturing, without even having a decent product. Whatever product they could produce they could sell at a significant profit, even if it was a poor-quality product."

Now, however, even if the solar market were to double this year and next, the silicon suppliers would have no trouble keeping up, which will help keep prices for solar panels relatively low, Wenham says. In that scenario, only the companies with the best technology will be able to sell their products at prices that are high enough to make a decent profit. "Those that don't have good technology will probably end up being bought up by companies that do," he says.

Advertisement

Suntech has invested about 5 percent of its revenues in R&D and employs 350 full-time researchers. The emphasis, however, is on near-term technology--changes to crystalline silicon solar cells rather than entirely new types of cells, says Zhengrong Shi, Suntech's CEO. For example, its next generation of solar panels can be made on the same equipment used to make the company's conventional solar panels. It is also making smaller investments in more advanced technologies that could become important 20 or more years from now, Wenham says.

Print

Related Articles

Advance Could Challenge China's Solar Dominance

New technology could tip the balance back in favor of some solar-panel manufacturers outside China.

Chinese Solar Companies Thrive on Manufacturing Innovations

Suntech Power's CTO argues that the secret to China's success is not cheap labor but advanced equipment for making solar cells.

Cheaper High-Efficiency Solar Panels

Suntech Power has developed a better way to make high-grade silicon wafers.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

aunderdown

77 Comments

  • 670 Days Ago
  • 04/09/2010

We too must stress R&D

In its prospectus to investors, Suntech states "We believe our China-based design, development and manufacturing facilities provide us with several competitive advantages, including access to low-cost technical expertise, skilled labor and facilities." Also, senior members of their R&D team did key enabling solar research at the University of New South Wales; and that connection continues. The company appears to function as a true multinational, locating manufacturing, distribution, R&D, and other functions where it's most cost-effective.

As the US is a major market, the company has had sales and other downstream functions here for some time. Suntech is now building a manufacturing plant in Arizona, apparently to bypass US government tariffs that recently went into effect.

A few years ago, many economists, "business thinkers", and “policy experts” envisioned a global economy where China and other developing nations provided the "world’s workshops" while we did the "grey matter" type jobs — because, of course, we are more innovative than other nations (or so we thought). Some of our "bright minds" still believe this idea. But as Kevin's article illustrates, it's a whole new world. Reliance on import tariffs (protection from foreign manufacturers) and feed-in tariffs (protection from other forms of energy) will not, over the long-term, be sustainable. We need to do more R&D, of the type that leads to innovation and commercial products. And we need to create the conditions so that R&D, manufacturing, and high value-added functions can be done here cost-effectively.

Perhaps the interim use of tariffs can allow our solar industry to build critical mass or "get on its feet". But economic history is full of cases where tariffs have caused the “protected” industries to become inefficient, weak competitors, relying almost exclusively on their protected market to survive. We had better do more than rely on these tariffs to automatically create a globally competitive solar industry.

Reply

holoman

37 Comments

  • 669 Days Ago
  • 04/10/2010

Wind and Solar - Where the Beef ?

According to super computers running simulation
scenarios on future US energy supplies.

The most solar and wind could ever hope to supply to US power needs is 8 %.

We definetly need to continue research into other
break through energy technologies not currently
available.

Who will invent and produce the Holy Grail of
future energy is still unknown.

Reply

Anumakonda

133 Comments

  • 81 Days Ago
  • 11/19/2011

Innovate or Perish -Solar Energy

I agree with you Stuart Wenham,more and more R & D is the need of the hour in Solar Energy as it is one of the fast emerging field like IT.Innovate or perish is the mantra in Industry now more so in Solar Energy.

Dr.A.Jagadeesh  Nellore(AP),India
E-mail: anumakonda.jagadeesh@gmail.com

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Consumer-Driven Disruptions

More

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Twitter

iRobot

Pacific Biosciences

Zynga

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement