Technology Review

Business

Cheaper Butanol from Biomass

A startup has raised $25 million for inexpensively producing biofuel.

  • Monday, October 27, 2008
  • By Kevin Bullis

Cobalt Biofuels, a startup based in Mountainview, CA, has developed a cheap way to make butanol from biomass. Last week, the company announced that it had raised $25 million to expand from a small laboratory-scale production to a pilot-scale plant that can produce about 35,000 gallons of fuel per year.

"Our models tell us it is a very low-cost process that can be competitive with anything on the market today," says Pamela Contag, the company's founder and CEO. The process is cheaper because it uses improved strains of bacteria to break down and ferment biomass, as well as improved equipment for managing fermentation and reducing water and energy consumption, she says.

Butanol could help increase the use of biofuels, since it doesn't have the same limitations as ethanol, the primary biofuel made in the United States. It has more energy than ethanol: a gallon of butanol contains about 90 percent as much energy as a gallon of gasoline, while ethanol only has about 70 percent as much. What's more, while ethanol requires special pipelines for shipping, butanol can be shipped in unmodified gasoline pipelines. And butanol can be blended with gasoline in higher percentages than ethanol without requiring modifications to engines.

Cobalt Biofuels joins a handful of other companies developing biobutanol. The biggest such effort comes in the form of a partnership between DuPont and BP: the companies plan to be selling commercial quantities of butanol made from sugar beets by 2010. Other companies developing biobutanol are Gevo, a startup based in Englewood, CO, that is commercializing advances from UCLA, and Tetravitae, based in Chicago, which is commercializing advances from the University of Illinois. In spite of their progress, Andy Aden, a research scientist at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, in Golden, CO, says that no company has demonstrated yet that it can make butanol cheap enough to compete in the market.

Advertisement

Cobalt Biofuels uses the bacteria Clostridium to break down components of plant matter, including cellulose, hemicellulose, and starch, and produce a combination of butanol, acetone, and ethanol. That is nothing new: Clostridium naturally produces these chemicals and was employed in the early 1900s to make butanol for use in solvents and to make acetone for explosives and other products. What's new, Contag says, is that a combination of fuel prices, government biofuel mandates, and the company's new technology have made butanol competitive as a fuel.

Print

Related Articles

Jet Fuel from Plants

A way to get a high-energy fuel out of an abundant and renewable resource.

Ethanol from Garbage and Old Tires

A versatile new process for making biofuels could slash their cost.

Better Bugs for Making Butanol

Engineered E. coli proves efficient at churning out the biofuel.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

jmaximus9

86 Comments

  • 1206 Days Ago
  • 10/27/2008

Cheaper Butanol from Biomass?

Cheaper than ethanol from corn or just cheaper than it was before? When you make Butanol from garbage, hemp, or grass clippings then we may have something. Sugar beets... please.

Reply

Kevin Bullis

178 Comments

  • 1206 Days Ago
  • 10/27/2008

Re: Cheaper Butanol from Biomass?

Cheaper than making butanol from biomass used to be--it used to be too expensive a process to use the butanol for fuel. Cobalt says it's cheap enough now to be competitive with other fuels, which is good news considering the advantages of butanol.

While BP is starting with beets (and moving on from there to other sources), Cobalt is planning to use a variety of waste products, not food.

Reply

Pat495

16 Comments

  • 1206 Days Ago
  • 10/27/2008

Butanol

to jmaximus9.  Have you never seen the mountains of waste from Beet producers?  Currently it is used as a feedstock mix for pigs.  I would think it is more plentiful and easier to find than paper mill offal, it is just beets sans the sugar.  But I applaud any Biofuel that does not use human food as its feed. 

Reply

Siphon

152 Comments

  • 1185 Days Ago
  • 11/17/2008

Efficiency

So what's the efficiency of this process, in terms of joules of butanol output per joule of biomass input. (including all losses in conversion and distillation etc.)

This is very important, given the relatively limited availability of feedstock. Every article like this should have an efficiency quote.

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Consumer-Driven Disruptions

More

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Zynga

BIND Biosciences

A123 Systems

Serious Materials

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement