Columns

New O.J. Trial: Recipe for Disaster

  • April 2002
  • By Seth Shulman

Tropicana tried to co-opt agricultural research it didn't pay for--and the U.S. Patent Office played along.

   

Talk about hoarding the fruits of innovation! Talk about a juicy patent dispute! I know I should be chronicling cutting-edge fights over rights to nanotech devices, genomic tags or esoteric new software applications. But let's face it: an all high-tech diet can be hard to swallow. So on today's menu I'm serving up nothing but 100 percent pure, premium, not-from-concentrate Florida orange juice.

You see, something's gone sour in the orange grove. In an all-too-common tactic, Tropicana, a division of PepsiCo, is abusing the U.S. patent system to-please excuse the pun-put the squeeze on its competitors. And I'm convinced the case offers an important cautionary tale about innovation today.

People have been growing citrus in Florida's sun-drenched groves for a very long time, putting a lot of effort into caring for the trees and figuring out the most efficient ways to harvest the fruit. But making orange juice remains a fabulously straightforward process: you pick the ripest oranges you can and press the juice from them, just the way nature made it, adding nothing.

 

To read the entire article you must log in:

Most of our content — all daily news, blogs, and videos — is free. Magazine stories are paid. To read this story, you must have a subscription or you must use a reading credit. Registration to Technology Review is free and entitles registrants to three free reading credits.

Username or REGISTER
Password  
   
 
Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

Meet 2011 TR35 Winner Jesse Robbins

More

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Layar

ARM Holdings

Applied Materials

First Solar

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement