Some new search engines are seeking to rise above the tide of ad-driven media content.
Gabriel Weinberg, creator of upstart search engine Duck Duck Go (DDG), says that
some time ago users requested that he remove from results from
eHow.com. The site is owned by Demand Media, a $200 million a year "content
farm" that produces 4,000 articles a day by playing freelance writers to churn
out articles at bargain basement rates, based on what people are searching for
and how much ads those search terms are worth.
Knowing little about the site and the discussions swirling around the quality (or lack thereof)
of its content, Weinberg wasn't moved
to act on those requests until he discovered evidence that Demand Media,
which owns eHow.com, was buying up domains for legitimate businesses and
redirecting them to their own content.
"It pushed me over the edge," says Weinberg.
One example Weinberg discovered concerned the website for the
Bank of Elgin, a small bank in Elgin, Nebraska, which has been in operation
since 1935. Inexplicably, whoever set up the bank's original website made it
available at BankofElgin.net,
and didn't buy the more obvious BankofElgin.com.
While it's not clear who actually owns BankofElgin.com (because that domain is registered under a proxy) Demand Media is certainly benefiting from this oversight. As Weinberg outlined in a recent blog post, visitors to
BankofElgin.com are redirected to http://www.ehow.com/apply-card-credit-online/,
and are greeted
with this message, followed by content from eHow on banking:
Hi There! bankofelgin.com isn't available, but you're
still in a good place -- ehow.com. We think we might have what you're looking
for.
Weinberg says that most of the crawling his
automated web spiders do on the web is conducted solely to keep spam out of the
search results he delivers.
"I had noticed over time the increasing frequency of
made-for-adsense (MFA) results in Google. These are the pages (often worse than
ehow.com) that essentially are full of ads and have very little content, but
nevertheless appear in search results a lot (at least on the major search
engines)," Weinberg said via email.
The content he's blocking includes everything from
"Made-for-Adsense" sites that offer no content at all to sites that
offer only, in Weinberg's judgment, low-quality content designed specifically
to rank highly in Google's search index.
"Usually the stuff I'm blocking is pretty straightforward,
i.e. not really on the line. The few that have been somewhat on the line are
usually big sites, and I've asked users or they have been driven by user
reports followed by my subsequent investigation," says Weinberg.
Weinberg's approach is mirrored by forthcoming
"social search engine" Blekko, which allows users to easily search within clusters of sites that their friends have
marked as trusted content.
In some
sense, Blekko's approach is more democratic--if any content is good
enough for your friends, it's probably good enough for you too.
Follow Christopher Mims on Twitter, or contact him via email.
Comments
camworld
07/27/2010
Posts:1