Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Potential Energy


Kevin Bullis is Technology Review’s energy editor.

Recent Posts

Blog Topics

Recent Comments

  • devassocx : This is the last thing this body should be allowed to consider.  Even the thought of such a thing...
  • welrifai : Well, there's quite a bit of talk about the severity of the problem, and a healthy dose of...
  • Cheap... : I think this is so true, Electric vehicles are a great idea, but like most new advances in tech,...
  • RD : No. Cap & Trade taxes Americans for energy use and redistributes it to political supporters like...
  • RD : Those you call AGW, ARE in favor of nuclear energy. It's the Progressives who have been blocking...
  • RD : CO2 isn't the problem.  In Maryland, a new study in the International Journal of Climatology – by...
  • kstauff : The only agreement I recall us not upholding recently is the ABM treaty, for which we informed...
  • kstauff : Kevin:  You're either unaware or glossing over recent history.  The House climate bill BARELY...
  • cheadrick : Where did that 1% number come from? There have been no accurate measurements of atmospheric CO2...
  • colinnwn : "We fly planes so much that on 9/11 global temperatures dropped a large amount more than usual as...
Advertisement
Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Steven Chu's Energy Plan

At yesterday's hearing, Obama's selection for secretary of energy outlined his priorities.
By Kevin Bullis

Steven Chu, president-elect Obama's pick for secretary of energy, emphasized the need to address climate change and decrease reliance on foreign oil during his confirmation hearing on Tuesday, January 13, and he backed off of some of his earlier rhetoric against coal (which he'd previously called his "worst nightmare"). Here's a sampling of his take on key issues.

Oil and gas, and efficiency:
He tiptoed around the issue of increasing oil and gas production on the outer continental shelf and elsewhere, saying that he supported it, but immediately qualifying his statement. He said that only 5 percent of the world production of oil comes from the United States, implying that increased production won't make much difference. Then he said, "The more efficient use of energy in the United States is the one big factor that can help us reduce our dependency on foreign oil."

Nuclear:
It has to be part of the energy mix, so we need to figure out how to dispose of it. That means, in part, some more research on recycling waste.

Electric grid:
A "very crucial" part of the development of natural resources. Steady winds and clear skies for solar power are often far from big cities where power is needed, so we'll need better electrical transmission. Challenges: cost, state boundary issues, siting the power lines.

Renewable energy:
"Renewable energy is something we really have to work on as quickly as possible . . . It will be my primary goal as secretary to make the Department of Energy a leader in these critical efforts." (Quote from CQ Politics.) Chu's work as the director of the Lawrence Berkeley Lab focused on advanced biofuels, artificial photosynthesis, and solar technologies.

Hybrids, electric vehicles:
"These first electric hybrid cars don't have the energy capacity and the battery lifetime we need," he said today. "Let's push hard towards more fuel-efficient personal vehicles." (Quote from Earth2Tech.)

Coal, carbon sequestration:
Coal is the most abundant fuel source in the U.S., and the dirtiest. But capturing the carbon dioxide that it produces and burying it could make it cleaner. Chu supports developing technology to do this.

"If the world continues to use coal the way it is now, that is a pretty bad dream," he said at the hearing, pointing out that carbon dioxide isn't the only problem. In many places, pollutants like sulfur dioxide and mercury aren't captured, he said. "It is imperative that we figure out a way to use coal as cleanly as possible. My optimism as a scientist is that we will develop those technologies to capture a large fraction of the carbon dioxide that is emitted from power plants and to safely sequester it."

Comments

  • Distributed Generation
    RE: Electric Grid, Efficiency and Solar Power

    I think that there should be a way to have efforts on these three challenges to dovetail. A house with solar on it reduces demand on the electric grid, is more likely to have highly efficient devices, and reduces polluting and CO2 producing fuel use. DG sounds like a prudent choice for Mr. Chu.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    jwgorman
    01/15/2009
    Posts:10
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re: Distributed Generation
      A hydrogen buffer is critical for renewable energy sources. Metal hydrides such as nickel and titanium offer concentrated, safe, hydrogen storage. Compressed hydrogen gas is similar to propane. Mass hydrogen gas production from electrolysis is now viable from carbon-free energy sources such as solar, wind, and wave energy. Methane is no longer required as the main source for industrial hydrogen gas production. Grid connected, mass production, hydrogen facilities are a superior option to nuclear or fossil fuel back up systems. We can replace pump storage and other back-up storage systems with hydrogen. The conversion efficiency should be a secondary consideration to the fact that hydrogen is carbon-free and produces potable water when used as an energy source.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      mwr
      01/24/2009
      Posts:2
      Avg Rating:
      5/5
      • Re: Distributed Generation
        Dear Dr. Valone, et al,

        I challenge the statement of Dr. Chu enclosed in the quotation marks, below.

        Aside from the performance of Tesla roadsters, powered by lithium batteries, Stanford Ovchinski’s claims made of his amorphous type nickel metal hydride batteries have been proven to be equal, if not superior to lithium, in power, charging capacity and mileage.
        “What happened to this battery”? http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/553.html

        (Quote from CQ Politics.) Chu's work as the director of the Lawrence Berkeley Lab focused on advanced biofuels, artificial photosynthesis, and solar technologies.
        Hybrids, electric vehicles:
        "These first electric hybrid cars don't have the energy capacity and the battery lifetime we need," he said today. "Let's push hard towards more fuel-efficient personal vehicles." (Quote from Earth2Tech.)

        I feel that this glaring contradiction of the facts is most critical, coming from someone advising (misleading?) President Obama on US energy strategy.

        I urgently await your reply.

        Yours very truly,

        David Thomson
        725 Franklyn Road
        Kelowna, British Columbia, Canada
        (250) 765-6826
        Rate this comment: 12345

        idslayer
        03/24/2009
        Posts:2
  • High Leverage Energy Plan
    This is a high system leverage suggestion for Dr. Chu: "For free society to face "perhaps the most serious series of crises in the republic’s existence, and for our" power industry, we need to introduce as soon as possible the creative destruction of the divine dispensation of IOUs perverse communism."

    For details, please read the electricity without price controls (EWPC) article IOUs Perverse Communism, which is based on the EWPC article Dr. Chu backed away slightly and responds Energy Central Network's vice president Warren Causey's articles We'll see who was right, Keynes or Adam Smith & Milton Friedman and Chu trying to appear less ‘scary’.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    javs
    01/15/2009
    Posts:89
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
  • CO2 deficiency
    Earth has a looming atmospheric carbon deficit.  We should NOT promote sequestering of CO2.  CO2 is essential for plant life, once it drops to about 150ppm, most life on Earth will die of starvation. As CO2 rates progresses downward towards 150ppm, agriculture yields will drop.  According to the IPCC charts, atmospheric CO2 has dropped 80% at a linear rate over the past 170 million years (when life flourished) .  Only in the past 200 years has there been a small uptick.  In the past 200 years, crop yields are estimated to have increased 30-40% because of the extra carbon. To try to reverse this is to inhibit agricultural production.  Carbon is a finite resource and nature has been sequestering it underground in carbon based fuels and carbonates, inaccessible to most natural recirculating patterns.  Mankind's burning of fossil fuels has released some of this carbon but ecopolitical goals are to promote human sequestering, which will accelerate the demise of Earth's flora and fauna.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    RD
    01/15/2009
    Posts:112
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: CO2 deficiency
      Its true that increased CO2 prevented us from sliding into another ice age.  However the amount of CO2 buildup has now exceeded safe limits and is projected to soon rise to dangerous levels.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Gene_Preston
      01/16/2009
      Posts:2
      Avg Rating:
      2/5
    • Re: CO2 deficiency
      Are we on top of the bubble or at the bottom of the glass? Nobody knows the stability of Earth's climate. Pending ice age or rising sea levels are subjects of human speculation, but finite fossil fuel resources are not. Are you suggesting we intentionally pump more carbon dioxide into the atmosphere? Plants will use the carbon dioxide that is available. They will adapt.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      mwr
      01/24/2009
      Posts:2
      Avg Rating:
      5/5
  • Energy Facts and Forecast
    · The scientific process has been used to show that CO2 buildup is likely to harm the Earth in the future.
    · Coal is not likely to find a CO2 storage solution. This will cause a phasing out of coal for electric power.
    · The era of cheap oil is coming to a close. Natural gas and oil will be available but will be very expensive.
    · Electrified transportation will drive up the demand for electricity and the need for new lines and power plants.
    · Solar cell manufacture is still too expensive. It's not clear when a low cost process will be realized.
    · T. Boone's wind power plan will need many new transmission lines which I think will take years to implement.
    · A power system that relies only on wind and solar will require energy storage, which is not economically available.
    · Nuclear fission has two problems which have technical solutions. One is nuclear waste and the other is cost of plant.
    · The nuclear waste problem is solved by reprocessing and reburning the waste. France and the US have plans on how to do this.
    · The US should implement the way the French hold down the capital costs of nuclear plants by reducing the investment risk.
    · More R&D fusion power projects are needed in the US. There is an infinite supply of fusion deuterium fuel in the oceans.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Gene_Preston
    01/16/2009
    Posts:2
    Avg Rating:
    2/5
  • Priority and Consumption Areas
    The mix of power sources and clean initiates are well understood, but I believe the whole mess becomes clearer if matched against the areas where we consume the most. I'm not sure what order we use energy the most from, but I think these are reasonable starting points.

    Manufacturing - use coal?
    Buildings - natural gas?
    Transportation - petroleum and coal
    Agriculture - petroleum?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    mkogrady
    01/16/2009
    Posts:198
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Coal only if........

    ...we are able to develop a economic way to use  coal as liquid fuel which is a reliable process since 1940 and new processes can raise if we work hard on it.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    advill
    01/20/2009
    Posts:15
    Avg Rating:
    2/5
  • Hybrids, Electric Vehicles
    Dear Dr. Valone,

    I challenge the statement of Dr. Chu enclosed in the quotation marks, below.

    Aside from the performance of Tesla roadsters, powered by lithium batteries, Stanford Ovchinski’s claims made of his amorphous type nickel metal hydride batteries have been proven to be equal, if not superior to lithium, in power, charging capacity and mileage.
    “What happened to this battery”? http://www.brasschecktv.com/page/553.html

    (Quote from CQ Politics.) Chu's work as the director of the Lawrence Berkeley Lab focused on advanced biofuels, artificial photosynthesis, and solar technologies.
    Hybrids, electric vehicles:
    "These first electric hybrid cars don't have the energy capacity and the battery lifetime we need," he said today. "Let's push hard towards more fuel-efficient personal vehicles." (Quote from Earth2Tech.)

    I feel that this glaring contradiction of the facts is most critical, coming from someone advising (misleading?) President Obama on US energy strategy.

    I urgently await your reply.

    Yours very truly,

    David Thomson
    725 Franklyn Road
    Kelowna, British Columbia, Canada
    (250) 765-6826
    Rate this comment: 12345

    idslayer
    03/24/2009
    Posts:2
Advertisement

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
•  Subscribe
Save 36%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
» Gift Subscription
» Digital Subscription
» Reprints, Back Issues
» Subscribe
» Table of Contents
» MIT News

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.