Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Emerging Technologies Conference

Technology Review's EmTech Conference brings together world-renowned innovators and senior business leaders to discuss the emerging technologies that are poised to make a dramatic impact on our world.

Links

Comments

  • ncm : Burning natural gas releases just as much carbon as other fossil fuels.  Nowadays we know that is...
  • ncm : Repeat after me: It's only a conspiracy if it's against the law. 
  • ronwagn : Natural gas finds and biogas successes have changed the energy picture. It will be more difficult...
  • jlmose : So three people at a conference think that photosynthetic algae, hydrogen and carbon capture are...
  • Garthh : Sounds like a conspiracy! Please expand & provide actual data I have trouble believing a...
  • Daretodiff :   Hello, its simple the reason is at least 100 years old. The big ones do not want us to be able...
  • SirLanse : Perhaps your grand children or great grand children will have a solar powered vehicle that can...
  • jesup : Turns out it isn't as good as hoped - takes too much water, too low yield if not grown in good...
  • nanogarden : I for one would like to know what exactly are the experts and investors looking for in a...
  • kangeloux :

Tags

Recent Posts

Advertisement
Friday, September 26, 2008

Is There a Clean-Tech Bubble?

Experts analyze the debate held at EmTech08.
By TR Editors

At Technology Review's 2008 Emerging Technologies Conference, EmTech08, experts debated the idea of a clean-tech bubble. Here is CNET News' Senior Writer Martin LaMonica and author of the blog "Green Tech" analysis of their opinions and the related issues:

Clean-tech bubble talk is a red herring
It's fashionable these days to ponder whether there's an investment bubble in clean tech. But I believe this discussion obscures a bigger problem for the clean-tech crowd: not enough money.

A panel of venture capitalists at the Technology Review EmTech 2008 conference on Thursday took the bubble question head on. The response from investors tends to be nuanced: No, there isn't a bubble, but there are some silly company ideas getting funded...read more

GS Early of KCI Investing gives his insight on the panel in his blog "At These Levels":

Is There a Clean-Tech Bubble?
This was the last breakout session of the EmTech 08 Conference and I stuck around for this panel of venture capital guys to see what they were seeing in emerging energy technology companies.

On the panel was David Berry, Principal at Flagship Ventures, Robert Day, Principal at @Ventures, and James Kim, Senior Partner at CMEA Ventures...read more

Comments

  • A $7 Trillion Market
    $7Trillion per year.  That's the big difference between the clean energy market and other rapid growth phases like the internet bubble.  In the internet space, or software or computer hardware, people have been competing aggresively over a potential future total market size of $10 Billion or $100 Billion.  $7,000 Billion currently changes hands every year to deliver energy to users around the world.  This "bubble" is like no other we've seen in a long time since it's playing in a real market and a huge market.  And it's only just begun, with renewable energies having 1% of the market; they can grow at 30% per annum for many years.  At this rate, market saturation might begin to occur in the late 2020s.  Furthermore, the economics of renewable energy are now competitive with "conventional" energy and continue to improve relentlessly.  "Conventional" energy forms dominate because of huge momentum and installed capital bases, but the renewables are shaping up to be fundamentally better mousetraps.  This spells fantastic profit opportunities for a game-changing industry. 
    Rate this comment: 12345

    FreddyG
    09/27/2008
    Posts:11
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • First Things First
    The old paradigm has made demand a lot fatter than necessary. The financial crisis will end up with is much less demand. Energy efficiency is one of the most important Clean-Tech opportunities for a sustainable world, which like distributed resources are located on the demand side, not the supply side.

    In order to be able to change the world on a firm footing, Clean-Tech needs to address first the electricity restructuring issue to enable the digital era raise the plateau level of the power industry. That will only happen with business model Clean-Tech innovations that replace the obsolete price controls business model highly risky bets that regulators are now doing on the retail market. In order to avoid throwing good money after bad money, please take a look at the article EWPC Blog's First Year Anniversary: Electricity for the Digital Era to learn about it.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    javs
    09/29/2008
    Posts:89
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
Advertisement

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
•  Subscribe
Save 36%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
» Gift Subscription
» Digital Subscription
» Reprints, Back Issues
» Subscribe
» Table of Contents
» MIT News

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.