TR Editors' blog

Smoking out Stem Cell Charlatans

The International Society for Stem Cell Research plans to evaluate the claims of clinics offering experimental stem cell treatments of dubious value.

Emily Singer 06/17/2010

From spinal cord injury in China to heart disease in Thailand, desperate patients trolling the internet can find a number of clinics and companies offering purported stem cell therapies of dubious value and great expense. According to Irving Weissman, president of the non-profit International Society for Stem Cell Research, there are more than 200 purveyors of such treatments.

"This is not rare, it's common and it's our responsibility to fix it," said Weissman, a physician and biologist at Stanford University, in his opening address at the society's annual meeting in San Francisco this week. These purveyors often offer treatments for a broad range of disorders but provide little proof that their therapies truly involve stem cells, and little experimental evidence exists in the scientific literature to back their claims. A 2005 Technology Review feature, "The Problematical Dr. Huang Hongyun", highlighted the troubling trend in a profile of a Chinese physician offering cell therapy for spinal cord injury.

The ISSCR is now taking steps to shine light on stem cell snake oil schemes by asking these entities to provide very basic information on their practice; whether it has approval from an ethical review board to perform the treatments and whether it has applied for approval from the Food and Drug Administration or its equivalent in other countries. The results of the inquiry, which will likely take several months, will be posted on a new website, www.closerlookatstemcells.org. 'If they don't have either of those, they'll be listed on the site automatically," says Weissman.

The public can submit names of clinics or companies they would like evaluated via the site, which also lists a set of questions patients can ask providers about experimental treatments. Sean Morrison, a stem cell biologist at the University of Michigan and a member of the society's board of directors says the initial response to the site has been substantial. Despite being up for just a few days, dozens of patients have made inquiries.

GoDaddy Will Stop Registering Domains in China

The company claims that, like Google, is has suffered serious attacks originating in China.

Erica Naone 03/24/2010

The domain registration company GoDaddy plans to stop registering domains in China, according to reports today. In testimony to a congressional commission, the company said that, like Google, it has suffered from a number of serious cyber attacks that seem to have come from mainland China. GoDaddy complains that the Chinese government hasn't done enough to stop the attacks.

GoDaddy says it will, however, continue service for existing customers with domains based in China.

China Blocks Google's Hong Kong Redirect

Tensions rise after Google redirects Chinese users to an uncensored Hong Kong site.

Erica Naone 03/23/2010

  • 2 Comments

The conflict between Google and China continued to escalate on Tuesday. The government criticized the search company's decision to redirect Chinese visitors to its uncensored site in Hong Kong, and some users say the government has begun blocking sensitive results served up from that site.

The official Xinhua news agency quoted an official in charge of the Internet bureau under the State Council Information Office as saying, "Google has violated its written promise it made when entering the Chinese market by stopping filtering its searching service and blaming China in insinuation for alleged hacker attacks."

As of this writing, Google's service availability page suggests that its Web search is still available in China. But reports are surfacing that Great Firewall censors are already partially blocking the Hong Kong site, filtering out sensitive searches for terms such as "Tiananmen Square".

While unsurprising, this move seems to confirm that redirecting users to Google's Hong Kong site is not going to result in improved access. The obvious anger of the Chinese authorities makes it hard to imagine how Google will be able to continue operating an ad-sales business in mainland China.

About

Insights, opinions, and our editors' analysis of the latest in emerging technologies.

Subscribe to the TR Editors' blog RSS Feed

Advertisement
Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement