Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

TR Editors' blog

Insights, opinions, and our editors' analysis of the latest in emerging technologies.

Blog Topics

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

  • david k : There is strong history of the street view as art.  Ed Ruscha took photos along the Sunset Strip...
  • chimenti : Under NADIN what procedure does a pilot follow for submitting a flight plan and how is the...
  • fiberman : How amusing. A contributor to the WSJ suggests eating your fellow man. Well, isn't that just what...
  • kstauff : I believe the deficit left by the Bush administration for fiscal '08 was around $500 billion. ...
  • kstauff : You're right, I overestimated the number of democrats in both houses, although I believe that the...
  • kstauff : Are you as angry at Roosevelt, Truman, Kennedy, Johnson and Clinton for the wars they prosecuted?...
  • kstauff : The Obama administration told us it would be 8% without the stimulus.  You tell me if he and his...
  • ... : Just to make it apparent, there's already a Chromium browser which uses the Chrome codebase for...
  • Adalast : people keep throwing around the "New Deal" and saying that it was horrible and didn't help our...
  • ... : All of these careful studies and delays in taking up a form of energy that is far superior to the...
Advertisement
Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Oil Is Still Cheap

Even with oil prices soaring, by some estimates, they're still short of historic highs.
By Kevin Bullis

High oil prices are supposed to get people to use less, yet oil consumption continues to rise in many places. That could be because oil really isn't as expensive as it's been in the past, according to some ways of looking at it. A recent article in the Economist says that because Western consumers' incomes have risen considerably over the past few decades, oil prices would need to top $134 a barrel to have the same impact as prices in 1981. The price of oil was a mere $119 a barrel yesterday.

Comments

  • [no subject]
    Give it 6 months, then it will be up to your $134
    Rate this comment: 12345

    zig158
    04/24/2008
    Posts:64
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re:
      It hit $138 today.
      Now what?
      Rate this comment: 12345

      deafwolf
      06/06/2008
      Posts:1
  • Oil needs to be cheap for the economy to work
    The whole economy functions on cheap oil to be able to transfer goods cheaply so it doesn't affect the U.S. economy deliberately by limiting production. If people cannot see this they are either blind to the truth or haven't studied the situation correctly. China is cooperating with the saudies and deliberately buying unneeded amounts of oil to bring the price up and strangle the U.S. economy. Because everthing is further away in the U.S. they consume much more oil. The high price of natural gas is also strangling the economy because it is used for heating, 90%of fertlizers, powering electric gas stations and trucks powered by liquified.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    danimiller
    04/24/2008
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    2/5
    • Re: Oil needs to be cheap for the economy to work
      Oil needs to be expensive for Government to work ! About half of every dollar is TAX, federal or state. Vote the incumbents out, get the right people in, and cut the price by half. An aside, Europe pays $5-6 per gallon, and in the major cities, the rush hour traffic rivals NYC. Psychologically, we haven't maxed out yet - behavior hasn't changed.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      z0rr0
      04/24/2008
      Posts:54
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
    • Re: Oil needs to be cheap for the economy to work
      I suppose that depends on what you mean, when you say "for the economy to work". If you mean the economy of consumer spending, cheap goods from China, then yes, cheap oil is required for that. We should have a debate about what constitutes a good economy, i.e., quality of living. I'm pretty sure it's closer related to education, health care, rather than big cheap TVs. But, that's a conversation for a different day...

      However, we certainly haven't had cheap oil in a long time, if you include all the costs you and I are paying. Estimates vary, but it's safe to say that the US government subsidizes the cost of oil imported from the Persian Gulf to the tune of $1 - $2 per gallon.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      ChuckInReno
      04/28/2008
      Posts:19
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
  • If Oil is a Bargain ...
    If oil is such a bargain, then coal-to-liquids and gas-to-liquids, which are profitable at $50 a barrel, ought to be just what we need. Seriously, let's get started on some alternatives.

    There's something much different today than back in the OPEC-induced crisis of yore. We import 75% of our crude oil consumption (30 Quads out of 40 Quads or so). Back in the 1970s, we imported about 30%. This means that high prices impact our trade deficit to a much greater extent than back in those perfectly acceptable days of gas rationing, locks on gas caps and lines for miles at filling stations.

    It's funny that people say in effect, "Oil isn't quite as expensive as it was in the days of oil Hell." What's the take away from a statement like that? Kevin, you're awesome, but I think this is bad news, not glass-half-full news. Maybe you had to experience those days as I did to realize that they were anything but normal times.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    MakeSense
    04/24/2008
    Posts:93
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: If Oil is a Bargain ...
      In so many ways oil isn't a bargain. That includes the trade deficit you mentioned as well as environmental, military, and political costs. And I'm sure people who have no alternatives to buying gas to get to work don't think its a bargain either, especially the poor for whom gasoline is a big chunk of their income.

      The blog is just pointing out one of the reasons people continue to pay for oil largely from other countries. There are other reasons, too, such as people living far from work and having no choice. Even if prices reach historic highs, many people will have to keep paying.

      What's the solution? How will people come to use less gasoline? I don't know. One interesting proposal is to increase gas prices still further with taxes, and then take that money to help those who can't afford the gas, to invest in the development of gasoline alternatives, and to promote changes to American cities so that people can live closer to work.

       
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Kevin Bullis
      04/29/2008
      Posts:92
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
      • Re: If Oil is a Bargain ...
        Raising taxes and prices would probably not fly politically, but I think that a federally mandated oil price floor would encourage development of alternatives.

        If we want to import far less oil, then we have to anticipate that success will bring lower oil prices. If oil could not be bought or sold for less than say $55/bbl, then companies that could potentially impact oil imports would not have to fear their own success, a la lower oil prices. If the international oil price fell below the minimum price, the resulting tariff would go to the government.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        MakeSense
        05/09/2008
        Posts:93
        Avg Rating:
        3/5
        • Re: If Oil is a Bargain ...
          You've actually suggested a very wise and logical solution. Oil will continue to be the cheapest fuel as long as we have an abundance of cheap recoverable oil reserves around the world. OPEC can afford to reduce oil prices to undercut any alternative. However the U.S. could combat OPEC's monopoly on energy by enacting a floating price floor (i.e. market price plus tariffs). The price floor could even be "reset" on a weekly basis as the need (for price relief) fluctuates.

          But  as we deplete the most abundant cheap oil reserves in the world in 2030 or 2040, oil prices will steadily rise until final depletion of cheap reserves. Price floors are an excellent way for the U.S. to develop a stable and reliable alternative energy industry. But no politician has the cajones to do this.
          Rate this comment: 12345

          energymv@gma...
          05/15/2008
          Posts:5
          Avg Rating:
          5/5
  • Artificially Cheap Oil....
    We subsidize and externalize the SOx, NOx, particulate matter, smog, greenhouse gas climate change, etc.  We also subsidize a military complex in the mid-east for secure access to cheap oil in unstable regions. We ostensibly went to war in Iraq partially because of their abundance of cheap oil. And we sometimes fund the other side of the "war on terror" indirectly. Saudi Arabia is the largest exporter of oil, not exactly a model democracy.  You could say that oil is the 800 lb gorilla that sometimes corrupts our foreign policy, which is yet another hidden cost of imported oil.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    energymv
    05/22/2008
    Posts:19
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Don't forget about income distribution
    The rich have gotten twice as rich, but the poor are just as poor as they were 30 years ago. Here is a graph from the U.S. census bureau that illustrates the point. The flat blue line in the middle is the median 50th percentile income in the U.S. which remains FLAT, while the top yellow line is the 90th percentile super rich getting richer.

    Real income data based on http://www.census.gov/prod/2004pubs/p60-226.pdf

    Income Distribution Graph...(shown in 2003 dollars)
    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/a/a7/United_States_Income_Distribution_1967-2003.svg/800px-United_States_Income_Distribution_1967-2003.svg.png
    Rate this comment: 12345

    energymv
    05/22/2008
    Posts:19
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Want to lower oil prices?
    Yet another reason to buy American. The growing economy of China and other countries is often cited as reasons for the price of oil. We, consumers in the US, are responsible for the current cost of oil. Buy products made in the United States. It is an investment in your future.
    Oil prices will drop. China will have less money to build it's military (yea, believe it. China will be a threat to us) and more jobs will be available in the United States.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    gmm76127
    05/23/2008
    Posts:1
Advertisement

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
•  Subscribe
Save 36%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
» Gift Subscription
» Digital Subscription
» Reprints, Back Issues
» Subscribe
» Table of Contents
» MIT News

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.