Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

TR Editors' blog

Insights, opinions, and our editors' analysis of the latest in emerging technologies.

Blog Topics

Recent Posts

Recent Comments

  • ssptng01 : U suck and so does Bush!!!!!
  • ... : I am very excited about this project, and can foresee the day when we might be able to harness...
  • ... : I believe the same is said for the human brain. There is no information completely beyond recall,...
  • ... : Very cool.  I think it's interesting how in trying to program effective AI we seem to end up...
  • SirLanse : Getting the government to give you cash is not capitalism.  The complaint is that the chinese...
  • justme : I wiped out the flu with high daily doses of Vitamin D.  First day the congestion markedly...
  • UgoSugo : All the China-US thing has nothing to do with bloody environmentalists or corrupted politicians...
  • gabrielg01 : If solar cells become a commodity, then it's far better to let the Chinese do it. Low wages,...
  • msmsimon : The E.coli strain used in our research is non-pathogenic and of Biosafety Level 1 ("work...
  • xyzt : Now that Multitouch is realized this is the next concept from Minority Report that is being...
Advertisement
Thursday, November 01, 2007

Pinpointing the Source of the Out-of-Body Experience

Unfortunately, the technology is not yet available as a carnival ride.
By Emily Singer

La Reproduction Interdite 1937
Credit: René Magritte

A 63-year-old Belgian patient suffering from tinnitus--ringing in the ears--has brought the out-of-body experience back down to earth. In a common treatment for the disorder, doctors implanted an electrode into part of his brain in an attempt to stop the ringing. When they sent small jolts of electricity through the electrode, the ringing unfortunately remained. But the patient reported feeling as though he was outside his body--about 20 inches backward and to the left, to be precise.

The case isn't the first to link the out-of-body experience with abnormal brain activity. Patients with epilepsy, migraines, and tinnitus have occasionally reported spontaneous out-of-body experiences. And two previous studies report inducing feelings of disembodiment by electrically stimulating the brain.

The newest study does help pinpoint the neural culprit. Using a form of brain imaging called PET, doctors found a spike in activity in two spots near the implanted electrode every time the patient reported feeling disembodied.

Lead scientist Dirk De Ridder, of the neurosurgical department at Antwerp University, explains his concept of the out-of-body experience to HealthDay News:

"Self-perception is nothing else but a creation of your brain," explained study lead author and neurosurgeon Dr. Dirk De Ridder, of the neurosurgical department at Antwerp University. "We found a key spot in the brain in which different areas are normally activated whenever stimulus comes in, so you can relate that stimulus to yourself, which helps create a unified perception of ourselves."

"The 'total perception of self,' " he added, "is built out of different parts. And one of these parts is that your consciousness belongs within your body."

"But when something goes wrong in that brain area so that the integration of all the incoming information--sight, sound, smell, the senses--is not happening as it should, then you can feel that you're not in your body," De Ridder said. "You can get an out-of-body experience. You're perfectly conscious. But you just feel as if you're not actually sitting in your body."

The findings may disappoint some whose lives have been changed after out-of-body experiences triggered at the brink of death. Perhaps one scientist I heard speak several years ago at a science conference in the United Kingdom is especially disappointed. To test whether people who report out-of-body experiences are truly outside their body, the scientist suggested putting cards on the ceiling of an emergency room, with symbols posted on the side facing up. If the person really was floating above him- or herself, he or she would be able to read the cards. Genius.

Comments

  • Out-of-Body Experience
    Showing the abnormal brain activity, does not prove that there is no "entity" out of the body...it just points to the part of the brain that manages or induces such information...
    Dealing with information of radical gas like NO it is not difficult to assume patterns of information organised out of the body...
    http://www.notes.co.il/dina/32099.asp
    Rate this comment: 12345

    dina11
    11/02/2007
    Posts:1
    • Re: Out-of-Body Experience
      I agree that simply pinpointing the area of the brain that emits out of body experience does not allow one to conclude that it doesn't happen in near-death experiences.Rather than placing the cards on the ceiling,why not place the on top or behind the subject's scalp so that they can only be read from outside the subject's body?
      Rate this comment: 12345

      plasticdoc
      11/02/2007
      Posts:23
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
    • Re: Out-of-Body Experience
      I agree that simply pinpointing the area of the brain that emits out of body experience does not allow one to conclude that it doesn't happen in near-death experiences.Rather than placing the cards on the ceiling,why not place the on top or behind the subject's scalp so that they can only be read from outside the subject's body?
      Rate this comment: 12345

      plasticdoc
      11/02/2007
      Posts:23
      Avg Rating:
      3/5
  • out of body experience
    Why not simply place the cards on top or behind the subject's head so that they can only be read by actually being outside of one's body;agree that simply pinpointing the anatomic area does not prove the "experience" does not really occur.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    plasticdoc
    11/02/2007
    Posts:23
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • dramatic conclusions
    I found myself a bit lost as to the logic of the editor's conclusions about this brain stimulation case.  Our brains and senses can be stimulated in all sorts of ways to make us feel and experience sensations that aren't "real".  For example, one could have their brain stimulated in such as way as to experience the sensation of being cold.  This does not prove that the actual experience of feeling cold due to being in a chilly environment does not really occur or is not real. 
    Conducting an experiment in order to prove whether the feeling of being outside one's body due to electrical stimulation is a real OOBE or just a feeling, while very interesting, again wouldn't necessarily prove or disprove anything about OOBE's relating to near-death experiences.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    PanKmita
    11/02/2007
    Posts:1
  • tinnitus
    I hadn't heard before of a connection between tinnitus and out-of-body experience. I have had one out-of-body experience in my life -- at an extremely loud Mission of Burma concert in Boston in the early 80s. Years later, I developed tinnitus.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    dancer
    11/02/2007
    Posts:1
  • deja vu, too?
    I'm thinking (thru my Vietnam Tinnitus) that I should carry a notepad to quickly write down "what happens next...". Otherwise, I may just be viewing "now" from a different brain view. Hmmm...
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Henry1951
    11/04/2007
    Posts:7
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • tinnitus
    I experience tinnitus about 8" outside my
    right ear. During a brief but too long
    period of hallucinations I was hearing my
    thoughts "broadcasting" about 15' away.
    Very little of my auditory stuff actually
    felt like it originated in my head. It all
    did, of coarse.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    longnow
    11/25/2007
    Posts:3
Advertisement

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
•  Subscribe
Save 36%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
» Gift Subscription
» Digital Subscription
» Reprints, Back Issues
» Subscribe
» Table of Contents
» MIT News

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.