• 531 Days Ago
• 08/31/2010

Re: Maximal, how?

Wire-making "technology" was fairly straight-forward, even back then, once someone realized you could "draw" a hot stub of metal through sequential incrementally-smaller holes in something hard (usually a rock, sometimes bone, etc). The labor intensive prep was to drill the hole. The rest of it was fairly simple -- as you drew more wire, the hole got larger, so you moved that rock-with-eroding-hole tool-piece closer to the beginning of the process and kept some trainee busy drilling the tiniest hole possible for the constantly-replaced "finishing" rock.

(Edited to add:) Granted, early on, wire was fabricated in lots of different ways -- and I can't say when my description above would be pertinent -- but "how" really isn't exactly the point here, is it... Sorry...

And "maximal" had everything to do with the geometry of the situation -- which apparently you didn't catch, either this time or (more pertinently) the previous time, the discussion with the rope... When you twist two strands of anything together, there is a point where twisting ANY MORE introduces a visible instability, a "kink", into the helix. THAT is the point of "maximal" twist, and it is the most trivial bit of the whole procedure -- "go until THIS happens" (and demonstrate) "back off, then stop."

But why stop? That kink presents a certain visual effect that could be used as a "gimmick", a style-element, maybe -- except that "kink" is demonstrably the weakest point in the helix now. Weakening a piece of expensive jewelry is bad for repeat business (edited to add:) and of course, the stuff that BROKE didn't make it down the timeline to reach us. It got melted down and "disappeared" back into "the mists of time".

Which raises the question of "why didn't this go without saying, it was SUPPOSED to go without saying." I.e., was there any directed point in this whole discussion? Because what's being discussed is one of those "technically obvious to a craftsman" issues that are going to be "discovered" by anyone who spends any time at all working with similar materials...