arXiv blog

Designing The Perfectly Smooth Roller Coaster Ride

Mathematicians have derived the shape of a roller coaster that gives a perfectly smooth ride

kfc 07/20/2010

  • 7 Comments

One of the challenges that roller coaster designers face is controlling the forces their passengers experience as they take the ride.

The forces in a vertical plane are simple to state. They are the sum of the gravitational force pulling down and any centrifugal force that depends on radius of curvature and acts normally to the track.

The easiest track to design is circular but this causes a problem, "In practice this leads to unpleasantly large time variation of the normal force," say Arne Nordmark and Hanno Essat the KTH Royal Institute of Technology in Stockholm. So designers are forced to rely on other more complex shapes, such as the clothoid.

So a reasonable question to ask is what shape should the tracks be to deliver a constant smooth normal force to a passenger taking the ride. Such a roller coaster would offer the perfect smooth ride.

(A curious feature of Nordmark and Essat's analysis of this problem is that they say it is related mathematically to Kepler's problem of planetary motion. Who'd have guessed.)

The answer, say the Swedes, is the shapes in the picture above. These do not yet appear to have a name--Nordmark and Essat call them Case 1 trajectories. Readers of the arXiv Blog will surely have better ideas. Suggestions in the comments section please.

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/1007.1394: The Comfortable Roller Coaster -- On The Shape Of Tracks With Constant Normal Force

TRSF: Read the Best New Science Fiction inspired by today’s emerging technologies.

Print

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

UncleAl

409 Comments

  • 573 Days Ago
  • 07/20/2010

Coaster curve

"coastoid" for application.
"minkoid" for Minkowsky field flatness.
"sipoid" for sounding nice.
"antibarfoid" for the engineering.
"barfoid" for the inverse effect curve.
"roaroid" for the intended effect (and its half-loop, the hemiroaroid).

Reply

millikenresearch

12 Comments

  • 573 Days Ago
  • 07/20/2010

curve name

the spirograph. For those of us old enough to remember what that is.

Reply

hendersonmj

33 Comments

  • 573 Days Ago
  • 07/20/2010

Hysteroid

For both hysteresis and hysteria.

Reply

rsanchez1

213 Comments

  • 573 Days Ago
  • 07/20/2010

Butter

Smooth as butter? The butter curve?

Reply

dmm

270 Comments

  • 572 Days Ago
  • 07/21/2010

basic assumption is wrong

Nice mathematics, but bad roller coaster design.  In real life, coasters are purposely designed to subject riders to weird forces and to be un-smooth.  It makes the ride more exciting and scary.  If the only force riders experienced were a constant normal force, that would be a very tame coaster.

Reply

rsanchez1

213 Comments

  • 572 Days Ago
  • 07/21/2010

Re: basic assumption is wrong

I guess they're targeting a different market than the hardcore coaster enthusiasts.

Reply

ew1880

1 Comment

  • 570 Days Ago
  • 07/23/2010

Roller coaster design

Modern roller coasters use very carefully engineered curves using advanced spline math and simulation techniques. The German design & engineering company Stengel first introduced clothoid curves to roller coaster design ("Revolution", Magic Mountain, Los Angeles, 1976). http://www.rcstengel.com

Reply

Bio

The Physics arXiv Blog produces daily coverage of the best new ideas from an online forum called the Physics arXiv on which scientists post early versions of their latest ideas. Contact me at KentuckyFC @ arxivblog.com

Follow The Physics arXiv Blog on Twitter

Subscribe to the arXiv blog RSS Feed

Advertisement
Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement