arXiv blog

Mathematician Solves Rowing Boat "Wiggle" Problem

A mathematician has discovered two entirely new arrangements of rowers in a racing eight in which the rowing forces cancel to make the boat wiggle-free.

kfc 11/20/2009

  • 4 Comments

They take their rowing seriously at the University of Cambridge. So seriously, in fact, that the university has press-ganged John Barrow at the Center for Mathematical Sciences to study the serious problem of oscillating non-zero transverse moment in racing boats, otherwise known as wiggle.

The placement of the rowers, the "rig" of the boat, obviously has consequences for the motion of the boat. The question is how best to arrange an even number of crew members in a coxless racing boat in a way that minimizes or eliminates wiggle.

The traditional way of rigging a boat places rowers alternately pulling oars on each side of the boat. "The traditional rig appears symmetrical and simple in ways that might tempt you into thinking it is in every sense optimal. However, this is not the case," says Barrow who goes on to show that the balance of forces in this rig as the oars are pulled through the water always produces a wiggle.

But there is an arrangement in which the transverse forces cancel. This rig consists of one rower pulling on the port side of the boat followed by two on the starboard with a final rower on port. In the rowing world, this arrangement is known as the Italian rig because it was discovered by the Moto Guzzi Club team on Lake Como in 1956. The Moto Guzzi crew went on to win gold representing Italy at the Melbourne Olympic Games later that year.

Barrow next considers a crew of eight and identifies four possible rigs that have a zero transverse moment. These are shown above. The interesting thing is that only two of these rigs are known to the racing world. Rig b is called the "bucket," or "Ratzeburg rig," first used by crews training at the famous German rowing club of the same name in the late 1950s.

Rig c is simply the Italian rig repeated twice. It was used by the Italian Eights in the 1950s after their success with the Fours. It's also known as the triple tandem rig.

The other two, rigs a and d, are brand spanking new and don't seem to have ever been discussed. However, rig d is a combination of a zero-moment Italian Four with its mirror image.

Barrow goes on to generalize the idea for any number of crew, proving along the way that only crew numbers divisible by four can be wiggle-free. (Assuming that they are evenly spaced.)

He also goes on to show that unbalanced boats in which there are unequal numbers of oars on each side, can also be wiggle free if the spacing between the rowers can be altered. As an example, he shows how a Three could have a zero transverse moment.

Barrow ends by saying that his work is not intended to revolutionize rowing tactics. That seems overly modest. Clearly, Barrow's paper should be recognized as a master stroke.

What's the betting that that we'll see at least one of the new rigs at the 2012 Olympics in London?

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0911.3551: Rowing and the Same-Sum Problem Have Their Moments

TRSF: Read the Best New Science Fiction inspired by today’s emerging technologies.

Print

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

seth

1 Comment

  • 817 Days Ago
  • 11/20/2009

Fun permutations

Even though the new arrangements were not immediately obvious, I do think they make common sense.  An evenly alternating seating arrangement isn't truly symmetrical because for every rower with oars on one side of the boat, his or her paired rower (rowing on the opposite side of the boat) will be seated farther back.  The bow-aft orientation affects symmetry.

All the arrangements shown have four sets of a pair of rows, and for each left-right pair of rowers in the boat, there is a mirror-image pair so that in the mirror image, the rower in the forward position should now be sitting in the rear position.  A single left-right pair can never be wiggle free because one side will always be forward of the other.  But when left-right pairs are present with their mirror images, the bow-aft difference cancels out.  The left-right pairs don't even have to be adjacent to each other in the seating line-up.

As long as a grouping of 2 or more pairs creates zero wiggle, any amount of repetition of that arrangement will also have zero wiggle.  I'd assume every possible arrangement where mirror-image pairs take bow-aft position into account would be wiggle-free.  If the symmetrical patterns are merely superficial, I'd be curious how more complex hydrodynamic considerations play a role.

While it might sound like I'm disparaging the math research, I actually quite enjoyed this article.  It's always great to see real-world problems demonstrating the more abstract mathematical relationships.

Reply

shaase

1 Comment

  • 817 Days Ago
  • 11/20/2009

rowing shell wiggle

It would seem difficult to guarantee that oarsmen all pull with the same force, so it will still be difficult to eliminate the wiggle no matter how you position the oars. Excuse the wisexxx comment, but why not solve the problem by giving each oarsman 2 oars, as in a quad? I've heard that an octet goes so fast it's almost impossible to keep up with the speed of the water.

Reply

mulliguns

1 Comment

  • 817 Days Ago
  • 11/20/2009

pairs

Points to why a pair may be the most difficult to row successfully, and that sometimes odd size combinations work out well. bow man and stroke must actually row differently and have different power curves?

Reply

ms

190 Comments

  • 814 Days Ago
  • 11/23/2009

rig a

I'm surprised you didn't mention that rig a is just a doubling-up of each position in the Italian rig.

Reply

Bio

The Physics arXiv Blog produces daily coverage of the best new ideas from an online forum called the Physics arXiv on which scientists post early versions of their latest ideas. Contact me at KentuckyFC @ arxivblog.com

Follow The Physics arXiv Blog on Twitter

Subscribe to the arXiv blog RSS Feed

Advertisement
Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement