arXiv blog

Relativistic Navigation Needed for Solar Sails

A decent-size solar sail could accelerate out of the solar system in no time, and this raises new challenges for navigators.

kfc 08/19/2009

  • 9 Comments

If we're ever going to travel a significant distance from Earth, we're going to have to break our dependence on chemical propulsion systems. It's just not possible to carry enough chemical propellant to get up to a decent trot.

An alternative is a solar sail, which uses the force of solar radiation pressure to accelerate. By one calculation, a solar sail with a radius of about a kilometer and a mass of 300 kg (including 150 kg of payload) would have a peak acceleration of about 0.6 g if released on a parabolic trajectory about 0.1 astronomical unit (AU) from the sun (where the radiation pressure is higher).

That kind of acceleration would take it beyond the Kuiper belt to the heliopause, the boundary between the solar system and interstellar space (and a distance of 200 AU), in only 2.5 years.

In 30 years, a solar sail could travel 2,500 AU, far enough to explore the Oort Cloud.

But such a journey may not be smooth sailing, particularly when it comes to navigation, say Roman Kezerashvili and Justin Vazquez-Poritz, physicists at the City University of New York. They claim that ordinary Newtonian physics just doesn't cut it for this kind of journey.

The problem is that the sail would have to be launched so close to the sun that the effects of general relativity, such as the precession of the perihelion of orbiting objects, have to be taken into account. And even though those effects are relatively minor to start with, they have a significant effect over long distances.

The calculations carried out by Kezerashvili and Vazquez-Poritz show that the effects of general relativity could push a solar sail off course by as much as a million kilometers by the time it reaches the Oort Cloud and that even tiny relativistic forces such as frame dragging could cause a deflection of 1,000 kilometers.

What these guys are saying is that the interstellar navigators will have to be proficient in a new discipline of relativistic navigation.

That won't be an issue for a while, though. The most optimistic estimate for the launch of such a mission is around 2040.

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0907.3336: Escape Trajectories of Solar Sails and General Relativity

TRSF: Read the Best New Science Fiction inspired by today’s emerging technologies.

Print

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

arbelos2

2 Comments

  • 910 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2009

A song for the journey

And when, in 2040 they begin their journey, here's a song they can enjoy on their way...

http://www.arbelos.eu/portraits-in-stone/sunjammer/

Reply

pasward

32 Comments

  • 910 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2009

1000 km from where?

If you are navigating you are going from somewhere to somewhere.  A trip to the Oort cloud goes from Earth to where, exactly?  There is no observed Oort cloud object that such a mission would target, so 1000 km error is an error with respect to what exactly?

Reply

jporitz

2 Comments

  • 889 Days Ago
  • 09/09/2009

Re: 1000 km from where?

The Oort cloud is just one particular example. If you are aiming towards a star, for example, then deviations of course matter.

Reply

pasward

32 Comments

  • 820 Days Ago
  • 11/17/2009

Re: 1000 km from where?

Do they?  If you are headed toward a star, being off by 1,000,000 km is still going to get you more or less exactly where you want to be, and certainly 1000 km is fine.  Consider, for example, flying to Earth from Alpha Centauri: if you are off by 1000km, you are still here, since the Earth has a diameter of 12,000km!  (And I would hope that if we sent some probe to some hypothetical planet around Alpha Centauri, we would have the sense to put in some local navigation system for what to do when it arrived!)

Reply

phlyerphil

2 Comments

  • 910 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2009

sailing

How many of you people are sailors?  Please tell me how you can "navigate" a keel-less solar sail except directly downwind????  Or how you can squeeze a watermelon seed with one finger????  Or how you can walk without a resistance to your steps?

And then, how do you get back???

Reply

MacLir

12 Comments

  • 910 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2009

Re: sailing

Photon "bounce" from the sail can generate a vector off-axis from the radial trajectory of the photons.

Reply

Monsterboy

92 Comments

  • 907 Days Ago
  • 08/22/2009

Re: sailing

Since we're talking about a probe, not a manned mission, presumably it wouldn't get back, just like all the other probes of the outer solar system.

Reply

Advertisement

ms

190 Comments

  • 910 Days Ago
  • 08/19/2009

course correction?

Seems to me the errors associated with GR are small compared to errors caused by whatever mechanism is doing the steering. Presumably there would be some sort of feedback mechanism based on measuring where you are vs where you want to be along the route, and continual course correction would be applied.

Reply

jporitz

2 Comments

  • 889 Days Ago
  • 09/09/2009

Re: course correction?

No one is claiming that there aren't larger effects that also need to be considered. There are many factors to consider besides GR, including the gravitational effects of other planets, surface degradation of the solar sail and stochastic solar activity. However, no matter how many complexities are added to the model, the effects of GR are still present, and if we can account for them at the beginning of the voyage then we should. Remember that with solar sails we want to try to avoid having to continually correct our course, since practically all of the acceleration occurs at the beginning of the trip when we are close to the sun.

Justin

Reply

Bio

The Physics arXiv Blog produces daily coverage of the best new ideas from an online forum called the Physics arXiv on which scientists post early versions of their latest ideas. Contact me at KentuckyFC @ arxivblog.com

Follow The Physics arXiv Blog on Twitter

Subscribe to the arXiv blog RSS Feed

Advertisement
Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement