Wednesday, July 08, 2009
How F = ma Could Break Down at Low Accelerations
If Newton's second law is wrong, we might just be able to see the evidence in the orbital motions of the planets, suggests a new analysis.
Newton's second law, F=ma, is one of the bedrocks of modern physics. Or at least it was until the early 1980s, when astronomers noticed that stars orbiting spiral galaxies don't obey it.
Here's the problem. By Newton's law, more distant objects should orbit
a central massive object more slowly. That's exactly what happens in
the solar system. But the stars in spiral galaxies orbit far more quickly than Newton's law predicts.
Astronomers have proposed two solutions to this conundrum. Most think that there must be a halo of invisible matter pulling the stars in some unseen way. Others think that Newton's law must somehow break down for the tiny accelerations that stars feel in galaxies. These guys have spent the 20 years since then exploring the implications of Modified Newtonian Dynamics, or MOND, led by Mordehai Milgrom from the Weizmann Institute Center for Astrophysics, in Israel, who dreamed up the idea in 1983.
The trouble is that MOND only kicks into action when the acceleration is tiny--so small that no experiment on Earth has been able to distinguish its effects from Newton's law. And measurements on stars in distant galaxies are difficult to make, so it has been hard for astronomers to find evidence for or against it.
But today, Milgrom says that he has calculated a new effect of MOND that should be measurable for planets and comets in the solar system.
The new effect is a quadropole force that repels objects in the space above and below the plane of the solar system while attracting objects that lie within the plane. Milgrom says that this should produce an effect on the precession of the perihelion of planets in the solar system.
He says that the current measurements are not yet precise enough to see or constrain this effect, but the appropriate precision seems to be within reach.
Interestingly, last year astronomers found that the precession of the perihelion of Saturn does not quite fit with predictions.
Could this be the smoking gun that Milgrom is looking for?
Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0906.4817: MOND effects in the inner solar system
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Comments
http://aetherwavetheory.blogspot.com/search/label/dark%20matter
Note that Newton law violation means, equivalence principle is violated for relativity too, because gravitational law remains violated by Casimir force at small distances only.
ZephirAWT
07/08/2009
Posts:158
Ideas?
- a magnetic attraction
- others?
andrew_d_mac...
07/08/2009
Posts:1
We should always consider consistent description of reality based on single mechanism (like the space-time curvature here) first before introduction of ad-hoced concepts (hidden forces, fields, unknown particles and so on). While observed value of anomalous acelleration agrees with theory well, here's no reason to consider another less probable effects, like magnetic field and other phenomena.
ZephirAWT
07/08/2009
Posts:158
Why should we care about tiny effects that are almost impossible to measure?
Are there any significant implications, or are these scientists just OCD?
dmm
07/08/2009
Posts:207
ZephirAWT
07/08/2009
Posts:158
http://apod.nasa.gov/apod/ap070516.html
From certain extent, we can consider dark matter ring as a phenomena supersymmetrical to black hole rings (i.e. gallaxies) and stellar and planetary rings, like this one illustrated in above post.
ZephirAWT
07/08/2009
Posts:158
pbfleetwood
07/09/2009
Posts:1
In AWT such negativism and surface tension is a direct analogy of dark matter phenomena. When some subject gets into pressure, it surround itself by repulsive, negativistic stance. The acceptance of new ideas usually meets with instinctive refusal, which is the more pronounced, the more fundamental these ideas are. Global warming proponents are become surrounded by denialists - the more, the more money is in the game, etc.
Maybe these social analogies will help us understand better, how dark matter phenomena is working in context of information spreading in multiparticle systems.
ZephirAWT
07/09/2009
Posts:158
http://aetherwavetheory.blogspot.com/2009/07/awt-approach-to-dark-matter.html
ZephirAWT
07/12/2009
Posts:158