arXiv blog

Where the Equivalence Principle Breaks Down

Modified gravity theories violate the equivalence principle. If they are correct, we should see the effect in nearby galaxies.

kfc 05/22/2009

  • 2 Comments

One way to explain the puzzling acceleration of the universe is to modify Einstein's theory of general relativity to create a fifth force that can account for the acceleration. These theories have to be carefully constructed so that this fifth force works on the cosmic scale but not on the scale of planets like ours, where we'd have spotted it by now.

Today, Christopher Stubbs from Harvard University in Cambridge and a couple of buddies from Columbia University in New York city examine the consequences of this idea.

Their main result is that on a galactic scale, these modified versions of gravity would cause a failure of the equivalence principle: so gravitational and inertial mass would no longer be the same for galactic objects. That means large objects like galaxies would not all fall at the same speed.

That should have some easily observable effects. For example, small galaxies should accelerate faster than large galaxies while stars and diffuse gas in small galaxies should have different velocities, even if they
are on the same orbits.

So with the right kind of gear it should be possible to confirm the predictions of these modified theories of gravity or put strong limits on the influence they must be having.

Better get those lens cloths out and start dusting off a few old plates.

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0905.2966: Equivalence Principle Implications of Modified Gravity Models

TRSF: Read the Best New Science Fiction inspired by today’s emerging technologies.

Print

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

ZephirAWT

299 Comments

  • 998 Days Ago
  • 05/22/2009

Conceptually,

Equivalence Principle breaks down everywhere, where (general) relativity breaks down, i.e. at quantum scale in particular, because quantum mechanics products different results, then relativity.

http://aetherwavetheory.blogspot.com/2009/03/inconsistency-of-general-relativity.html

For example, at the moment when antigravity behavior will be confirmed for antiparticles or dark matter, it's evident, the gravity force doesn't follow inertial force in its consequences (gravitational lensing, etc).

Under more general view, though, all these violations of relativity are just consequences of it in more general reference frame at mutually perpendicular direction(s)/dimension(s).

http://aetherwavetheory.blogspot.com/2009/05/four-approaches-to-dark-matter.html

Reply

MidiMagic

5 Comments

  • 979 Days Ago
  • 06/10/2009

There is no acceleration

There is no acceleration of the expansion of the universe. It is an observation error caused by a relativity effect on a positively curved universe. The slower speeds observed for farther objects are caused by the curvature, not slower speeds.

The expansion itself is in a hidden dimension we call "time". We can not perceive this dimension as a space dimension, because it is Lorentz-contracted to zero length.

Reply

Bio

The Physics arXiv Blog produces daily coverage of the best new ideas from an online forum called the Physics arXiv on which scientists post early versions of their latest ideas. Contact me at KentuckyFC @ arxivblog.com

Follow The Physics arXiv Blog on Twitter

Subscribe to the arXiv blog RSS Feed

Advertisement
Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement