Tuesday, April 14, 2009
Estimating the orbit of Planet X
If Planet X is out there in the icy reaches of the Solar System, we should see its affect on the orbital motion of the inner planets
"Does the Solar System contain undiscovered massive planets or a distant stellar companion of the Sun?" asks Lorenzo Iorio at the Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare in Pisa, Italy.
If it does, then the orbital period of such a body would be so long that any gravitational influence on the known planets can be thought of as a constant, tiny perturbation.
Iorio has looked at a the perihelion precessions of Venus, Earth and Mars in the last century and asked whether there is any indication of such a force in action.
Apparently not, he says, but that doesn't rule out its presence. Instead, it has allowed Iorio to place limits on how far away such a planet might be.
His conclusion is that if Planet X is out there and about the size of Earth, it must more than 130 AU away. If it is the size of Jupiter, it cannot be closer than 886 AU and if it were a brown dwarf with a mass around 80 times that of Jupiter, it would have to be more than 3800 AU away.
Let's get looking!
Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0904.1562: Constraints on Planet X and Nemesis from Solar System's Inner Dynamics
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Comments
The distances you quote as distance limits don't appear anywhere in the paper. In fact you seem out by quite big factors.
qraal
04/14/2009
Posts:2
kfc
04/14/2009
Posts:5
Grammarian
04/14/2009
Posts:2
http://xkcd.com/326/
http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/affect.html
djweber
04/14/2009
Posts:8
Grammarian
04/14/2009
Posts:2
hdginzo
04/15/2009
Posts:10
mbloore
04/17/2009
Posts:29
Just wanted to see if you are aware that this is a well plowed field.
garylynn
04/15/2009
Posts:4