Comets 'n' commas
The best of the rest from the physics arXiv this week
kfc 03/28/2009
- 1 Comment
Jupiter - Friend or Foe? II: The Centaurs
Origin of Martian Moons from Binary Asteroid Dissociation
Theoretical Construction of stable Traversable Wormholes
Dynamics of Cold Atoms Crossing a One-Way Barrier
Bohmian Particle Ttrajectories Contradict Quantum Mechanics
The Outbreak of Cooperation Among Success-Driven Individuals Under Noisy Conditions
On Twitter
Become a Fan on Facebook
Subscribe to the Feed
norm
3 Comments
Bohmian particle trajectories contradict quantum mechanics
As I understand it, Bohm's theory produces the same predictions as standard QM. In the "Bohmian particle trajectories contradict quantum mechanics" paper, Fig. 2, A and B are not observables in the setup where A' and B' are measured. In the setup that measures A and B, any "correlations" between A' and B' are destroyed, so it becomes an entirely different experiment. I don't believe that anything that can actually be observed will contradict either Bohm's theory or standard QM.
There is a similar situation with the two-slit experiment. There is no way to measure which slit a particle came through without destroying the interference pattern. Yet Bohm's theory tells you definitely which slit it went through, without doing any measurement. This "contradiction" is only at the ontological level and does not make any any verifiable propositions. There is some discussion about this here: http://groups.google.com/group/sci.physics/browse_frm/thread/2566c78afe9491c9/5f0bab42ab48a7d8
Reply