There's also a question of whether, once a person starts
smoking, increased nicotine consumption causes certain genes to turn on or off.
To that end, Philibert plans to run similar genome-wide analyses on younger
people who have not yet started smoking but may have a family history of
nicotine dependence. He will also analyze DNA samples from patients with single
psychological diagnoses to obtain what he calls a "cleaner phenotype."
Anthony Hinrichs, assistant professor of psychiatry at
Washington University, in St. Louis, studies genes that code for certain
nicotine receptors in the brain. He sees this latest approach as casting a wide
net for other potentially related genes.
"Transcriptional
profiling in general, and this study in particular, are very promising ways of
nominating candidate genes," says Hinrichs. "I'm sure that these genes will now
be on the map for other investigators."
However, Hinrichs believes it will be a while before
scientists can design accurate genetic tests for such disorders. "So far, researchers have identified a number
of genetic markers which may increase susceptibility to drug addiction," says
Hinrichs. "Any of these would only increase the risk of addiction by a small
percentage. We certainly have a long way to go before we can routinely use
genetic tests."
Meanwhile, Gunter and Philibert recognize that this kind of genetic
testing comes with a host of ethical questions.
"There are some
people [to whom] you may be able to say on a genetic basis, 'You should never
take the first drink,'" says Gunter. "And some will listen, and some may not.
But it may have more impact on somebody if you are able to say, 'This is why
you, as an individual, don't need to take the first drink: because you are at a
particular risk for this to become a dependency, and this is how we know.' That's
different from taking a profile and saying, 'This is another alcoholic; I'm not
going to insure them.' Our part in this is to inform them of the level of their
risk so it's truly an informed choice."
Tags
addiction biology flourescent genetics genome