Biomedicine

Pig-to-Human Transplants on the Horizon

(Page 2 of 2)

  • Tuesday, October 10, 2006
  • By Emily Singer

Scientists, including Sachs, are still tinkering with better ways to trick the primate immune system into accepting pig tissue. They ultimately want to find a protocol that minimizes the use of immunosuppressants, which raises the risk of infection. (Two of the eight baboons in Sachs' last transplant experiments died of infections.)

One option, says Sachs, is to transplant bone-marrow cells along with the kidneys and thymus, which in some cases has been shown to improve tolerance for transplanted organs. Scientists are also developing additional genetic modifications that might improve the long-term survival of the organ, such as adding human genes for proteins involved in immune regulation or blood clotting.

Sachs says the team hasn't yet decided on the exact measures of success to achieve in baboons before starting human trials. Ethical and safety discussions will likely be required to design a human study. The researchers are carefully monitoring potential viruses that might be passed between pigs and baboons or humans, which has been a major health concern with xenotransplantation.

Sach's most recent research, though, published last month in the journal Transplantation, could be good news for people who are highly sensitive to proteins in human tissue, and are therefore much less likely to match organs from a human donor (about 20 percent of people on the waiting list for kidney transplants). By exposing blood from such patients to tissue from genetically modified pigs, Sachs and team found that the individuals' hypersensitivity did not extend to pigs. Given their low chance of finding suitable human organs, these people might be the first candidates for pig-to-human transplants.

Platt says that transplants from pigs might actually be safer than human-to-human transplants in the long run. "You can screen the organ in advance for infectious agents and other problems," he says, a process for which there isn't much time in today's urgent human transplants. And, he adds, because you can schedule the surgery in advance, you can plan pretreatments, such as bone-marrow transplants, that might better prepare the patient's immune system for the foreign organ.

Print

Related Articles

Building an Implantable Artificial Kidney

A prototype uses kidney cells to help it perform vital functions.

Extending the Life of Donated Organs

An experimental solution could buy time for transplant patients.

Green Genes

The first transgenic primates able to pass on their foreign genes are both a stunning medical advance and a troubling peek into the future.

Close Comments

To comment, please sign in or register

Forgot my password

SirLanse

71 Comments

  • 1953 Days Ago
  • 10/10/2006

Arab Love Us

Well,
if there was a way to make Arabs hate us more,
becoming part pig would be high on the list.

Reply

gabrielg01

450 Comments

  • 1953 Days Ago
  • 10/10/2006

Re: not only islamists...

Not only Islamic peoples, but fundamentalist Jews, and possibly Hindus will be opposed to these organ transplants too. It also won't go over well with the PETA people.

There will be a lot of social ruckus on this technology.

Reply

makornitzky

17 Comments

  • 1953 Days Ago
  • 10/10/2006

Re: not only islamists...

The issue with so-called fundimentalist Jews has long been taken care of.  The priority of saving life out-weighs that of Kosher food laws.  Insulin derived from pig pancreases has already been accepted as was the possibility of using heart valves from pigs as replacements.

A number of Orthodox Jewish authorities have also come out in favor of using excess fertility-clinic embroyos for stem-cell research.

Reply

enantiomer2000

66 Comments

  • 1953 Days Ago
  • 10/10/2006

Re: Arab Love Us

LoL.  I guess cultural tolerance will be a must.  After all, we won't be forcing these transplants on anybody.

Reply

McMillan968

38 Comments

  • 1953 Days Ago
  • 10/10/2006

Re: Pig heart transplant

The author forgot the Polish surgeon who DID transplant a pig heart.The patient only lasted 2 days but it was attributed to being too small a heart!!
Copied from FrontLine a history of xenoplation.
But I hope we can make it work w/o crossing into the world of sci fi diseases.

Reply

gabrielg01

450 Comments

  • 1953 Days Ago
  • 10/10/2006

How about the viral threat?

The author only fleetingly mentions the viral threat. But I think, there are many people who are very concerned about this issue. It is an issue that deserves a wider discussion and debate.

Pigs are known to be viral "mixing vessels", that is, they are known be infected with viruses from different organisms, and possibly produce new, recombined strains. For example, pigs can be infected with various bird viruses and human viruses.

This could be a very dangerous game for us. Let's make sure that we don't accidentally unleash the next plague, before we make these organ technologies widely available.

Reply

Phineas

127 Comments

  • 1952 Days Ago
  • 10/11/2006

Generous Piggies.

Given the alternative, I can live with pig parts. I will respect anyone's refusal to go this route as long as they don't deny it to those of us who choose a porcine fix. And should a xeno-viri do me in, I'll be no worse off.

I'm having way too much fun to worry if necessities are kosher or meshugenah.

Reply

Advertisement

pandora

1 Comment

  • 1034 Days Ago
  • 04/16/2009

solution?

i have been heavly studing advance boilogy and discovered a possible soultion.
whole organ decellularization could pose the answer.
by taking a cadaver pig heart and running a series of chemicals (SDS) throught the heart the pig cells will then be removed leaving only the extra cellular matrix next the fresh human crop of cells (the cells of the DIRECT paitent) will be planted and grow over the base structure.
as complicated as this process sounds the benifits are worth it. no need for anti rejection drugs and a normal life can be given to those in need allowing them to have a second chance of a NORMAL life.
this process was discovered by the university of minnesota and is curretly beeing imporved and reseached more

Reply

Advertisement

MAGAZINE

Can We Build Tomorrow's Breakthroughs?

Manufacturing in the United States is in trouble. That's bad news not just for the country's economy but for the future of innovation.

Videos

The Virtual Nurse Will See You Now

More

Advertisement

Technology Review Lists

TR50

Our list of the 50 most innovative companies, including the following:

Nissan

HTC

Facebook

Goldwind Science and Technology

More

Advertisement

Facebook

Advertisement