Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

A Plastic That Chills

Materials that change temperature in response to electric fields could keep computers--and kitchen fridges--cool.

By Prachi Patel

Monday, August 11, 2008

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

Thin films of a new polymer developed at Penn State change temperature in response to changing electric fields. The Penn State researchers, who reported the new material in Science last week, say that it could lead to new technologies for cooling computer chips and to environmentally friendly refrigerators.

Cool spool: Films of a specially designed polymer, just 0.4 to 2.0 micrometers thick, can get colder or hotter by 12 °C when an electric field is removed or applied across them.
Credit: Qiming Zhang, Penn State

Changing the electric field rearranges the polymer's atoms, changing its temperature; this is called the electrocaloric effect. In a cooling device, a voltage would be applied to the material, which would then be brought in contact with whatever it's intended to cool. The material would heat up, passing its energy to a heat sink or releasing it into the atmosphere. Reducing the electric field would bring the polymer back to a low temperature so that it could be reused.

In a 2006 paper in Science, Cambridge University researchers led by materials scientist Neil Mathur described ceramic materials that also exhibited the electrocaloric effect, but only at temperatures of about 220 °C. The operating temperature of a computer chip is significantly lower--usually somewhere around 85 °C--and a kitchen refrigerator would have to operate at lower temperatures still. The Penn State polymer shows the same 12-degree swing that the ceramics did, but it works at a relatively low 55 °C.

The polymer also absorbs heat better. "In a cooling device, besides temperature change, you also need to know how much heat it can absorb from places you need to cool," says Qiming Zhang, an electrical-engineering professor at Penn State, who led the new work. The polymer, Zhang says, can absorb seven times as much heat as the ceramic.

Zhang attributes these qualities to the more flexible arrangement of atoms in polymers. "In a ceramic, atoms are more rigid, so it's harder to move them," he says. "Atoms can be moved in polymers much more easily using an electric field, so the electrocaloric effect in polymer is much better than ceramics."

Story continues below


The material's properties make it an attractive candidate for laptop cooling applications, says Intel engineer Rajiv Mongia, who studies refrigeration technologies. Computer manufacturers are looking for less bulky alternatives to the heat sinks and noisy fans currently used in laptops and desktop computers. The ideal technology would be small enough to be integrated into a computer chip.

Until now, says Mongia, exploring the electrocaloric effect for chip cooling had not made sense. The first ceramic materials didn't exhibit large enough temperature changes--chip cooling requires reductions of at least 10 °C--and the more recent ceramics don't work at low enough temperatures. They also contain lead, a hazardous material that is hard to dispose of safely. The polymers do not have those drawbacks. "The fact that they've been able to develop a polymer-type material that can be used in a relatively thin film is worth a second look," Mongia says. "Also, it's working in a temperature range that is of interest to us."

Comments

  • Cool polymer
    Normal COP (efficiency) of small refrigerators is over 100% (depends on the temperature level). Even if we only talk about the efficiency of the compressor it is higher than 30-40% indicated. Besides, HCFCs are on the way out from the small friges, typically replaced by R600a. I think this film looks promising, but it is yet nowhere near to be attractive for home friges.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    GGMarquez
    08/11/2008
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: Cool polymer
      COP being the inverse of efficiency can exceed 100%. How would this compare in efficiency to Peltier Effect cooling?
      Rate this comment: 12345

      clark.gilber...
      08/11/2008
      Posts:1
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
      • Re: Cool polymer
        Actually the COP can be greater than 1 as it is Q/W.  Efficiency cannot be greater than one as it is W/Q, the reciprocal of COP. 
        Rate this comment: 12345

        slipperyweas...
        08/11/2008
        Posts:2
        Avg Rating:
        4/5
        • Re: Cool polymer
          Yep. Can't confirm the formula, but this is why a so-called "heat pump" can deliver more energy (in the form of heating or cooling) than it "burns" in terms of electrical energy. It uses the electrical energy to *move* existing heat into (or out of) the building, rather than directly converting electrical energy into heat (as with 'emergency' backup heating coils in heat pumps).

          But, would it be possible to 'cascade' these thin-film devices (like cells in a battery) to achieve the necessary differential? That is, the first "layer" would chill 12 degrees, passing the heat to a second layer which would in turn lower it another 12 degrees, then to a third and a fourth, achieving a combined differential of more than the needed 40 degrees. Seems this would all be within the operating temperature range already achieved, though the efficiency may drop significantly with the multiple layers.
          Rate this comment: 12345

          stevengt
          08/11/2008
          Posts:3
          Avg Rating:
          4/5
          • Re: Cool polymer
            Temperature's temperature, the film has no way to know if it's at a given temperature due to the action of other layers of film...so cascading should work just fine. As long as the film on the cold/hot sides stay in their respective operating temperature ranges, anyway.

            "In a cooling device, a voltage would be applied to the material, which would then be brought in contact with whatever it's intended to cool. The material would heat up, passing its energy to a heat sink or releasing it into the atmosphere. Reducing the electric field would bring the polymer back to a low temperature so that it could be reused."

            The explanation's a bit unclear...but apparently the film is to be brought into contact with a heat sink, exposed to an electrostatic field to raise its temperature and dump out the heat stored in it, then brought in contact with the object being cooled and the electrostatic field removed, cooling the film and allowing it to absorb heat. Voltage-controlled heat capacity, essentially.

            I am uncertain how this makes a cooling system with no moving parts however, the description specifically uses the phrase "brought in contact with". However, the distance to move can be very tiny, and the motion could be done electrostatically (as in electrostatic speakers) or piezoelectrically, the motion being just enough to preferentially transfer the heat in the desired direction. And perhaps there's changes in thermal conductivity as well which make it possible to eliminate the need for motion...

            Operating at 120 V is not an issue for laptops. Laptop cold-cathode backlights operate at hundreds or even thousands of volts. As a result, there's a wide range of compact, high efficiency, high voltage inverter designs that could be used for powering a heat pump.
            Rate this comment: 12345

            cjameshuff2
            08/11/2008
            Posts:14
            Avg Rating:
            4/5
          • Re: Cool polymer
            I think you two are a little off on your logic. You're forgetting about the law of diminishing returns more or less. If what you say was true, then they'd be able to bring any substance to almost absolute zero with the film... Unfortunately... if for example the temp of the air is 40 degrees celsius and the film could lower itself from 40 to 28, multiple layers would only help the air approach 28 degrees. It would get closer and closer to 28 degrees, but never actually go below it UNLESS the film could go below it. Multiple layers WOULD be GREAT for larger quantities or more efficiency though
            Rate this comment: 12345

            bcollegec
            09/03/2008
            Posts:1
  • ascii art
    This article is not very specific so let me lay out how you could use this. I would recommend people that have not read http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pipe
    to read it. A heat pipe can be used as a thermo check valve. “See thermo diode”

    Some ascii art

    Heat sync
    IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII < heat pipe
    Fancy new device
    IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII < heat pipe
    Cold object

    The heat pipe could be the micro channel kind that are very thin, all it requires is a phase change that allows the heat to travel in only one direction.

    I see no reason that you could not stack several such devices, but I suspect it would rapidly loose efficiency like the Peltier Effect coolers do.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    zig158
    08/12/2008
    Posts:64
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: ascii art
      That's an interesting variation on heat pipes that I haven't seen before. In this incarnation, it is dependent on gravity to draw water from the condenser, and so is dependent on orientation, and also looks difficult to make efficiently in a thin package, so it's a bit of an unlikely choice for laptops, but it could certainly have other uses.

      I wonder if something other than gravity could be used to "polarize" the device...perhaps a fully solid state heat diode could be created. It might even be a relative of this variable-heat-capacity plastic film...
      Rate this comment: 12345

      cjameshuff2
      08/12/2008
      Posts:14
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
  • clothing applications
    All of the applications mentioned in these threads and in the article are probably of great significance, but what I want is a hat for tennis that will cool the head. Passive and active heat retaining or generating clothing is already on the marketplace, but cooling clothing is a rarity. Overheating for athletes compromises performance. There may be some way to adapt this to help. 
    Rate this comment: 12345

    pstokstad
    08/14/2008
    Posts:2
    • Re: clothing applications
      Consider the power requirements and the mass/bulk of the heat exchangers. It might cool your head, but if it means carrying a backpack of batteries and aluminum fins on your head...

      You'd probably be better of working on improvements to those gel headbands...evaporative cooling seems to be the way to go for this application.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      cjameshuff2
      08/17/2008
      Posts:14
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
  • Water heating
    Why can't the heat being pulled out of the fridge or freezer be used to heat water for washing or drinking/cooking etc. , for instance so that less energy has to be used to boil water for drinking ? Plus , dusting the heat exchanger regularly is a good way to ensure it works as efficiently as possible .
    Rate this comment: 12345

    DJTal
    08/16/2008
    Posts:145
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Efficiency
    I agree that the efficiency of these plastics will be substantially lower than advanced heat pump cycles. By association, that makes this a niche application. So not very exciting in terms of energy impact. But there may be some interesting applications where efficiency isn't paramount but portability and other aspects are strongly valued. Think micro-electronics. I'm not sure about microprocessors though; they are a substantial energy requirement of society, so efficiency is important.

    Many of these MIT articles contain too much marketing talk. Universities should not subscribe to this; it is downgrading MIT's intellectual property. Just like Nocera's absurd claims, it's just bad journalism on MIT's side.

    Hope to see more objective, fuller disclosed articles on this site.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Siphon
    08/18/2008
    Posts:152
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
  • Scientific Nonsense
    There is a mistake there: "current hydrofluorocarbon refrigerants contribute to global warming". You should know that CFCs or haloalkanes or whatever you want to call them do not contribute to the global warming effect, they destroy the ozone layer. That is equally dangerous, but a different process though!
    Rate this comment: 12345

    CountZ3ro
    08/29/2008
    Posts:20
    Avg Rating:
    2/5
  • [no subject]
    So, you have this plastic which you apply voltage to to get it's chemical state to flip, which cools it off by 12C. Now the object you are cooling gives it enough energy to raise it 12C again.

    What do you do then? If you switch it back, it will end up 12C hotter than it's initial state.

    Do you have a belt of this material cycling between the cooled object and the heat sink/radiator?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    ASEI
    09/02/2008
    Posts:1

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Malleable Maps, Artistic Robots and Bubble Interfaces
Technology Review January/February 2010

Current Issue

Security in the Ether
Information technology's next grand challenge will be to secure the cloud--and prove we can trust it.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.