Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

A Camera to Help Dementia Patients

A specialized camera regularly takes pictures to aid with memory.

By James Butcher

Monday, December 10, 2007

smaller text tool iconmedium text tool iconlarger text tool icon

When Mrs. B was admitted to the hospital in March 2002, her doctors diagnosed limbic encephalitis, a brain infection that left her autobiographical memory in tatters. As a result, she can only recall around 2 percent of events that happened the previous week, and she often forgets who people are. But a simple device called SenseCam, a small digital camera developed by Microsoft Research, in Cambridge, U.K., dramatically improved her memory: she could recall 80 percent of events six weeks after they happened, according to the results of a recent study.

Memory boost: A small digital camera (shown here) developed by Microsoft Research, in Cambridge, U.K., could boost memory in people with dementia. The camera takes wide-angle, low-resolution photographs every 30 seconds. The photos can be collapsed into a movie that patients can later review to jolt their memory.
Credit: Microsoft Research Cambridge
Multimedia
•  Images taken by SenseCam are converted into a movie.

"Not only does SenseCam allow people to recall memories while they are looking at the images, which in itself is wonderful, but after an initial period of consolidation, it appears to lead to long-term retention of memories over many months, without the need to view the images repeatedly," says Emma Berry, a neuropsychologist who works as a consultant to Microsoft.

SenseCam is worn around the neck and automatically takes a wide-angle, low-resolution photograph every 30 seconds. It contains an accelerometer to stabilize the image and reduce blurriness, and it can be configured to take pictures in response to changes in movement, temperature, or lighting. "Because it has a wide-angle lens, you don't have to point it at anything--it just happens to capture pretty much everything that the wearer can see," says Steve Hodges, the manager of the Sensor and Devices Group at Microsoft Research, U.K.

An entire day's events can be captured digitally on a memory card and downloaded onto a PC for subsequent viewing. Using specially designed software, the Microsoft researchers can convert the pictures into a short movie that displays the images at up to 10 frames per second, allowing a day's events to be viewed in a few minutes.

Story continues below


SenseCam was originally developed as a memory aid for healthy people, but it is now in clinical testing for those with memory impairment, such as dementia. Narinder Kapur, head of the Neuropsychology Department at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, U.K., and leader of the eight-patient study, recently published an initial case report of one patient in the journal Neuropsychological Rehabilitation. Kapur and his colleagues found that Mrs. B could remember most nontrivial events after she had spent around one hour reviewing the SenseCam images with her husband every two days for a two-week period.

The device might help patients with mild forms of Alzheimer's disease, says Giovanni Frisoni, a neurologist at a clinical research institute in Brescia, Italy, who is not involved in the research. He is skeptical, however, about whether SenseCam could be used by patients with Alzheimer's disease without assistance from their caregivers. Still, "it might have a beneficial effect on soothing the patients' anxiety," he says. "All Alzheimer's patients have a deep anguish due to their perceived, although usually not confessed, inability to remember their recent past. Being able to go through the recent events may have a reassuring effect. Reassurance is what Alzheimer's patients want but, unfortunately, [is] what they are often denied."

Comments

  • Reminder camera
    I forget what I wanted to say to my wife before I get from my room to the first floor, so I carry a digital voice recorder everywhere. The camer's the next step. Where can I see one and what do they cost?

    Thank you,   dib
    Rate this comment: 12345

    dib
    12/10/2007
    Posts:9
    Avg Rating:
    2/5
    • Re: Reminder camera
      Nice idea.  I can see one problem in usage for people with memory problems might be what they do when they go to the loo.  If they turn it off, how do they remember to turn it back on?  Or, if they don't turn it off, they might not want anyone else to view the pix.  The camera could use a "temporarily disable for 5 minutes" button, with a beep that either lets one know it is recording again, or that it's time to turn it on again.  This could be good for the my wife's mom, and mine.  It might not be bad for me, either.  When my wife says, "What did you do today," I can simply play her the film.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      MITfoo
      12/10/2007
      Posts:1
      • Re: Reminder camera
        The camera isn't looking at you, it's looking at what you see.  When you're in the loo, there will be boring shots of the wall -- not a real privacy issue.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        kennita@kenn...
        12/10/2007
        Posts:2
        Avg Rating:
        5/5
  • awesome!
    This is technology investigation at its best. I read that modern people recall less information than their parents - numbers, names, addresses, etc. It seems they rely more on electronic aids to do their remembering for them. I wonder if these always-on camcorders will also come to be relied on for modern people.

    I have always thought that in the future, memory implants will become the first voluntary surgical procedure widely adopted.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    SVE
    12/10/2007
    Posts:48
    Avg Rating:
    3/5
    • Re: awesome!
      I WAS going to be funny BUT WHO'S going to remind them to PUT IT ON??Turn it ON?? ECT.. It could be a REAL draw back.Then again why not just buy a CHEAP digi camera on a key chain and take IMPORTANT pictures??If you are not TOO FAR ALONG!~!
      Rate this comment: 12345

      McMillan968
      12/10/2007
      Posts:38
      Avg Rating:
      2/5
      • Re: awesome!
        With good batteries, it may be possible to leave it on all the time (power off when there's no movement for a while).  Building it into clothes might help with forgetting to put it on, but it seems to be designed for situations where there's a helper, anyway.

        There are problems with the digi-camera-important-pictures plan.  For one thing, raising a camera to your face can drastically change the flow of conversation.  For another, it's often not clear that an event is important until after it's happened. 

        An option to record voice might be the next step.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        kennita@kenn...
        12/10/2007
        Posts:2
        Avg Rating:
        5/5
  • Reverse
    It appears that I have damage to my basal ganglia -- so I have the reverse problem of Alzheimers; my long term memory works fine, but short term working memory/sensory integration is *shot*.

    I wonder if a twist on this system would help -- recording everything (or all "significant" events, measured by change in motion, etc) in 30fps detail. This would create a longer movie to review, but it'd be worth it. I'm also curious to see if a system like this would help short term working memory like the current system seems to help long term memory.

    edit: thinking a little more, I can see one easy way that this would be hepful almost immediately: activing as a 2 minute "tivo" for events through the day. I often find myself "lost" b/c I've forgotten the current task (or current thought) -- a visual reminder might really help "jog" the working memory into recalling the current task.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    adin
    12/11/2007
    Posts:1
  • DIY SenseCam
    I got fed up waiting for Microsoft to release anything more than a few research studies and a smattering of details on the SenseCam device so decided to create my own out of a cell phone. Many of the issues discussed in the comments I have already faced or pondered in the two years I have been wearing mine. My biggest issue at this time is the sheer amount of data I am collecting. I think that the biggest breakthrough with these devices will not be the device itself but the software applications to manipulate and search through our lives. You can read more about my personal adventures with a SenseCam at http://www.justinlloyd.org/category/sensecam/
    Rate this comment: 12345

    JustinLloyd
    06/08/2009
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    3/5

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement

Videos

Malleable Maps, Artistic Robots and Bubble Interfaces
Technology Review January/February 2010

Current Issue

Security in the Ether
Information technology's next grand challenge will be to secure the cloud--and prove we can trust it.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Subscribe to Technology Review's daily e-mail update. Enter your e-mail address

TECHNOLOGY RESOURCES
Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2010 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.